CITY ATTORNEY ROCKY DELGADILLO opted against trial today and settled the lawsuit filed by black firefighter Tennie Pierce for $1.43 million, with Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa and city council members signing off on the agreement hours after the council meeting was finished and no apparent action had been taken.
“Today’s agreement is the best possible outcome for the taxpayers,” said the mayor in a press statement. “It reduces the original settlement by nearly half, while protecting Angelenos from further liability.” But in fact, with City Hall already paying outside lawyers to prepare to fight Pierce in court, the total price to taxpayers is slightly higher than last November’s proposed settlement, by roughly $100,000.
Pierce had sued, claiming racial harassment among other things, after a colleague slipped dog food into his spaghetti following a volleyball game in which Pierce repeatedly joked “Feed the big dog!” in reference to himself. An L.A. Weekly investigation found no evidence of a racial component, racial comments or other racial undercurrents surrounding the prank.
Noticeably absent from the City Council meeting today was Council Member Dennis Zine, who was strongly opposed to any settlement offers. Zine had told the L.A. Weekly, “The truth of the matter is Pierce is a prankster and a hazer and doesn’t deserve anything on this case.”
The announcement set off immediate debate. City Council President Eric Garcetti promptly took credit for helping broker the deal, which he praised. But an attorney representing Pierce’s two Fire Department supervisors, who were disciplined for allegedly failing to fully investigate the prank against Pierce by a Latino co-worker after Pierce taunted him during the volleyball game, told KFI radio in disgust: “There was no racial component; it was entirely made up.”
Pierce filed a lawsuit in 2005 alleging that he was fed dog food by his co-workers at Los Angeles city Fire Station 5. Last fall, the City Council agreed to pay Pierce $2.7 million in public funds, but the controversial settlement was scuttled after photos emerged showing Pierce spraying water into the face of one strapped-down firefighter, smearing shaving cream around the groin area of another strapped-down firefighter, and gleefully laughing at a third who had been wrapped in a bed sheet on which hazers had scrawled, “Oy Vey! I’m Gay!”
Pierce’s lawsuit had been scheduled for trial on September 24. Instead, a statement was released by Los Angeles City Clerk Frank Martinez at 4:30 p.m. today stating that Pierce will receive an additional $60,000 to resolve claims for back pay. The deal will also make him eligible for his 20-year pension, which is estimated at roughly another $1 million. As part of the settlement, Pierce will resign from the department and not file any further claims against the city. The City Attorney’s Office has already spent $1.35 million defending the case.
By contrast, City Council voted on September 19 to pay $1.15 million to the family of a 26-year-old Glendale motorcyclist who died when he was struck by a car driven by a Los Angeles city employee.
Advertising disclosure: We may receive compensation for some of the links in our stories. Thank you for supporting LA Weekly and our advertisers.