again, the L.A. Weekly has given an unfettered forum to another self-avowed
left-wing propagandist, in this case photographer James Nachtwey [“The
Eyes of Perpetual War,” November 22–28]. Writer Steve Appleford lobs only
softball questions and practically fawns over the answers, no matter how hyperbolic
When in history has there been a sustained period that couldn’t by his definition
be termed “perpetual war”? Like it or not, a decade or two is about the most
amount of time that has ever passed without a major conflict somewhere on the
globe. And why is it always U.S. aggression that is the problem? Anytime the
U.S. does go to war, either the issue is not big enough or the risks are too
great. “Kuwait wasn’t a democracy anyway,” “Places like Bosnia and Somalia are
quagmires,” “. . . too reminiscent of Vietnam.”
Is war ever a good idea? Should he have allowed Hitler or the Japanese to
carry out their unchecked aggression during World War II? Ceded the entire Southeast
Asian peninsula to the communists? Allowed Saddam Hussein to roll over every
rich, defenseless emirate in the Gulf anytime he needed to pump up his bank
And we wonder why the trend in American politics has lurched so far rightward.
The dearth of ideas is on the left, my friends. At least the hawks know where
they stand. And the Weekly?
In John Strickland’s review of Atom Egoyan’s Ararat
of the Missing Dead,” November 15–21], he states that the “propaganda is
too heavy.” His choice of words was careless and offensive. While the film is
not entirely historically accurate (it is not meant to be), its basic premise
— that the Armenian Genocide indeed occurred and has since become the object
of systematic denial — is true.
The word propaganda implies otherwise. I wonder if Strickland or any
other critic at the Weekly has ever referred to a film about the Jewish
Holocaust or American slavery as propaganda. I doubt it. Perhaps Ararat
is too subtle. Maybe the film fails. But propaganda it is not.
Our organization thanks you for your objective consideration of the recently
released film Ararat, by Atom Egoyan. It’s understood that quite a bit
of political and social controversy surrounds this picture, and more specifically
its subject matter as it relates to the tragic Armenian Genocide of 1915. We
appreciate the forthright nature with which you delivered your review, and hope
that you will remain open to future films that may involve stories concerned
with the Armenian Genocide, or the Armenian condition.
Director, Western Office
Armenian Assembly of America
Is Ararat a pure propaganda film, or does it also depict scenes in
which Armenian murderers — collaborating with the invading Russian armies —
massacred countless Turkish men, women and children, among whom were seven members
of my grandmother’s family? Most people are ignorant of the history of the Armenian
terrorists who stabbed the Turks in the back just as the Turkish nation was
fighting for its very existence during World War I.
Patterson, New Jersey
The Weekly, which recommends Jackass, about a bunch of idiots
riding in an oversize shopping cart, but not Ararat, should notify
its readers that they are being taken on a different sort of ride — the one
It’s unfortunate that Margaret Wertheim didn’t
have the intellectual honesty to mention, in her review of The Blank Slate
Science,” Quark Soup, November 1–7], that Steven Pinker disses her twice
(pages 366 and 393). Wertheim obviously has a grudge against Pinker and is incapable
of giving any of his books a fair review.
Re: “Here There Be Dragons” [Quark
Soup, November 15–21]. Margaret Wertheim’s sentence “Miraculously, however,
light is exempted from Einstein’s laws . . .” is nonsense. Einstein didn’t provide
us with laws but, rather, with observations. And the speed of light operates
within the observed laws of physics, just as do radio waves,
X-rays, magnetism and so forth, and is constrained by them just as completely
as any other phenomenon we can name, observe or about which we can speculate.
There is nothing “miraculous” here or even out of the ordinary.