Until January, Josh Tillman was the drummer from Fleet Foxes. When I meet him at Good Luck Bar in Los Feliz it's two weeks after the announcement of his departure from the band. Slumped over the bar, beer in hand, the bearded 6'4″ singer-songwriter stands out; through somewhat of an awkward grin, he navigates our conversation eloquently.

No longer a member of one of the most successful folk ensembles of the past decade, Tillman recently completed his ninth solo project, recorded upon his relocation to Los Angeles from Seattle. It's his first under the new moniker Father John Misty and its title, Fear Fun, speaks to the opposing dualities of his personality. Comedian and actress Aubrey Plaza (from Parks and Recreation) gets crazy in the video for his single “Hollywood Forever Cemetery Sings.”

The album was recorded in Echo Park last spring with producer Jonathan Rich Wilson, who also produced local band Dawes' previous two albums.

Tillman soon tells me he'd prefer to leave the bar and smoke weed in his van during our interview. This only serves to further the mystique I've already derived from his Tumblr page, which features photos of the singer on stage at a strip club sandwiched between heady quotes from existential philosophers.

Before leaving the bar, Tillman has a brief conversation with fellow singer-songwriter Will Oldham, who's called to praise the last song on Fear Fun, titled “Everyman Needs a Companion.”

As we arrive at Tillman's Econoline van parked a few blocks away, he explains his decision to release Fear Fun under the name Father John Misty, as opposed to J. Tillman, the moniker under which he's released his previous solo albums. “In my mind, this J. Tillman person is a far more romanticized, fictionalized person to the world than this ridiculous name, Father John Misty,” he says. He goes on to explain how he felt distanced and trapped by his songwriting persona as he matured in his personal life.

“I wanted to bring my conversational voice and my musical voice in to alignment. The ridiculous name is about satisfying this morbid sense of humor I have that says 'Maybe the most honest thing you can do is to just call yourself something stupid and say something real.'”

The name Father John Misty is partly a reference to cocaine, as in “Misty Mountain Hop,” and partly a reference to Tillman's life-long exploration of religion and spirituality, which started with his evangelical upbringing in the suburbs of Washington D.C. Out of despair, Tillman considered becoming a pastor for a brief time during his youth. “I wasn't good at sports. I wasn't good at school. I didn't see anything outside of Christian jobs,” he says. After becoming unglued from religion in his teens, “I was so angry and terrified that I'd been raised that way that, at some point, my number one mission became to make as big of a joke out it as I could.”

From a lyrical standpoint, Tillman's antagonistic sense of humor is readily apparent on Fear Fun , albeit balanced with a stark sense of realism and existential anxiety. It's something he's embraced since moving to Los Angeles, and after befriending several comedians, he's become something of a regular at the UCB, both as an audience member and a performer. A few weeks after we meet, he sings “Hollywood Forever Cemetery Sings” in front of a panel of guests that includes Zach Galifianakis at comedian Nick Thune's variety show.

Now that he's settled happily in to his new home in Laurel Canyon, it's somewhat surprising to hear Tillman talk about how anxious and overwhelmed he felt while living in Seattle. Nearly two years ago, he packed up and left the city without a destination at 3:30 in the morning. “I just felt like “There is no where to go from here. You have to blow everything up,” he says. Taking off in his van for eight months on something of a spiritual journey, he decided to write a novel a few weeks in and stopped in Big Sur to put pen to paper. The novel is printed on the liner notes for Fear Fun, and Tillman says the writing process helped him entirely rediscover his songwriting voice.

Tillman moved to Seattle in 2004, after dropping out of Nyack College, a private Christian school in New York he attended for one semester three years. Inspired by Bob Dylan and Neil Young, he saw himself fitting in with a blossoming singer-songwriter scene alongside artists like David Bazan and Damien Jurado. The decision to become a songwriter and move to Seattle did not sit well with his parents, but it paid off after Jurado brought Tillman on tour as his opener and he was able to build a name for himself through selling his recordings on burned CD's. 

After releasing five albums and becoming a familiar figure within the Seattle music scene, he was asked to join Fleet Foxes as their drummer. Though he doesn't have any regrets about his time with the band, Tillman hints that the constant touring was starting to wain on his aspirations as a solo artist. His decision to finally leave originated from a simple moment of self-reflection. “It was like that part in The NeverEnding Story where he looks into the mirror that shows him what he really is,” Tillman says. He makes it clear his departure wasn't out of any ill will towards other members of the band. “I like those guys and I really like the music. I wish it could've been a shitty band full of dumb dudes, because that would be way easier.”

Fear Fun suggests Tillman's intent to appeal to a wider audience. “What I perceive to be an effective song is something that straddles that line between a sentiment that's universal and also deeply personal,” he goes on. In effect, “Hollywood Forever Cemetery Sings,” strikes a perfect balance between the two. The idea for the song originated from a romantic encounter at the famous graveyard, which took place just after Tillman returned to L.A. from his grandfather's funeral in Baltimore.

The actual sentiment of the song, however, is much more universal. “What I was doing with this girl was more of a dignified memorial to his life than anything that had happened at this funeral, something that everyone has to go through. It's weird to mention your grandpa and a girl cumming in the same song, because people are conditioned to separate those experiences.”

Tillman is constantly seeking to balance his sense of humor with weighty topics, both in his music and in conversation. With his first release as Father John Misty, we see him finally bringing the two in to harmony. After learning the literal meaning behind “Hollywood Forever Cemetery Sings,” it's difficult not to laugh when I hear it on public radio weeks later. All I can hear in the back of my head is Tillman laughing wickedly and exclaiming, “I bet the thing my grandfather loved most about life was fucking my grandmother, at least I would hope so.”

Follow Aaron Frank on Twitter at @franknbeats and for more music news follow us at @LAWeeklyMusic and like us on Facebook.

Advertising disclosure: We may receive compensation for some of the links in our stories. Thank you for supporting LA Weekly and our advertisers.