The benefits of yoga and stretching are well known. However, while both activities can help you relax, strengthen your body, and reduce stress levels, they also have specific differences that make each beneficial in different ways. This article will explore the differences between yoga and stretching to help you decide which one is right for you!
The History of Yoga
The origins of yoga remain unclear; however, historians believe that yoga began in India over 3,000 years ago. The time frame for the creation of yoga remains relatively uncontested because it is mentioned in texts dating back to 300 B.C.Yoga was created as a means to unify body and mind, which made it an integral part of Hindu philosophy during the Vedic period (1500-1000 BC).
Modern Western societies have embraced yoga in its various forms, including:
- Hatha Yoga (physical postures),
- Iyengar Yoga (poses held 5-10 seconds)
- Ashtanga Vinyasa Yoga (combination of poses)
- Viniyoga (adapts poses for each individual’s physical needs and abilities)
- Bikram Yoga (poses are performed in a heated room and done twice for 90 minutes)
Benefits of Yoga
- Yoga has been shown to provide the same benefits as aerobic exercise, increasing your heart rate and strengthening your cardiovascular system. The breathing techniques used in many types of yoga also help improve lung capacity so that more oxygen can be delivered to vital organs. Regular practice of yoga can also slow down the age-related decline in cardiac function.
- Yoga has even reduced fatigue associated with some chronic diseases, such as multiple sclerosis (M.S.). One study on individuals with M.S. showed that those who practiced yoga for eight weeks had lower fatigue levels than those who did not participate in any type of program.
- Yoga builds muscle strength, but it also increases flexibility by stretching muscles. Yoga is also effective in reducing anxiety by promoting mental awareness and relaxation.
Introduction to Stretching
Stretching is a form of physical activity that has been practiced throughout the world for thousands of years. It was popularized by Roger Bannister, who in 1954 became the first man to break the four-minute mile.
In addition to its physical benefits, stretching provides psychological benefits as well. In one particular study on children with mental disorders, researchers found that daily stretching exercises improved symptoms such as sleeplessness and hyperactivity.
Unlike yoga, which aims to balance the body’s opposing muscle groups (i.e., flexor/extensor), stretching helps increase your range of motion by lengthening muscles and tendons after they have contracted from a vigorous workout or a long day at work. This process is often referred to as “breaking the muscle pump” because the size of your muscles can appear to decrease as they relax.
People who play sports, such as runners, gymnasts, and swimmers, have credited stretching with improving their performance by increasing lean body mass and recovery from intense workouts. In fact, many athletes stretch before a workout to warm up their muscles and improve flexibility.
Benefits of Stretching
- Stretching is easy to learn and can be practiced anywhere. All you need is enough space to lie down or stand comfortably and five to ten minutes of free time.
- Stretching exercises also do not require prior knowledge of the specific poses, allowing almost anyone to benefit from this low-impact workout. Stretches can help increase posture by improving muscle strength and flexibility in all areas of the body. They effectively release tension in your muscles after a long day at work or travel because they can be done anytime and anywhere.
- Resources to learn stretching are abundant, especially online. Apps like StretchLab or even a quick YouTube search for “best stretching videos” not only provide video demonstrations of stretches but also help track your progress.
Yoga vs. Stretching, Which One is Right for You?
The difference between stretching and yoga is a topic of debate among many health professionals. On the one hand, they have similar physical benefits, but yoga provides additional mental and spiritual components not typically found in most forms of stretching.
Some researchers even say that the two complement each other since yoga helps build lean muscle that is stretched during a stretch routine. Either way, both can provide many health benefits if done consistently over time.
In the end, it comes down to which one you will enjoy practicing most often. If you’re looking for an at-home workout or low-impact activity to ease daily stressors, try a simple stretch sequence before bed or after you wake up in the morning.
Try yoga if you are more competitive and want to become more flexible and build lean muscle through a challenging workout.
Yoga vs. Stretching for Kids (<12)
While both yoga and stretching practices have many benefits for children’s physical, mental, and spiritual health, age does play a factor when deciding which one would be best.
For example, very young children can benefit from yoga to build strength and concentration through daily at-home practice. They also learn self-awareness by practicing the poses under the guidance of an instructor during weekly classes.
Stretching is typically recommended for kids over the age of five because they will need more specific instructions on doing each pose properly to avoid injury or muscle contractions that may cause long-term damage later in life.
Yoga vs. Stretching for Teenagers (13-18)
Teens will also benefit from a yoga practice because of the focus on self-awareness and learning how to use their body’s natural energy. In addition, this age group may find it beneficial to include yoga and stretching in their weekly workout routine since they begin to develop lean muscle through puberty.
Since teens are at risk for injury due to the rapid bone growth during this period, stretching helps increase flexibility while yoga builds strength to act as dynamic stabilizers for growing muscles.
Yoga vs. Stretching for Adults (19+)
Both yoga and stretching provide many benefits for all adults when practiced regularly over time. So whether you’re looking for something low impact that creates overall wellness or you prefer a mind/body approach that eases daily stressors, yoga or stretching can help you get there.
Perhaps the most significant difference between the two practices is how they impact your life. If you are someone who prefers to feel challenged by an activity that helps you forge mental toughness while strengthening your muscles simultaneously, then try taking a yoga class to gain multiple benefits in one workout.
If you’re more of a laid-back person who wants to increase your overall flexibility and release tension throughout the day, start with some easy stretching exercises before bed each night or try using apps like StretchLab or Yoga Studio for guided stretches right from home.
In the end, both yoga and stretching provide many health benefits if practiced regularly over time. When it comes to deciding which is right for you, be sure to consider your needs and what you feel most comfortable doing on a regular basis.
Advertising disclosure: We may receive compensation for some of the links in our stories. Thank you for supporting LA Weekly and our advertisers.