By Peter Gerstenzang

“It wasn't the drugs and arrests and no-shows that broke Saul and Johnny up,” says Jonathan Holiff. He's the son of Saul Holiff, the manager of Johnny Cash in the 1960s and early '70s, a time that included the prison LPs, the jail stays, and Cash's reawakened fundamentalism. “It was an ideological battle that really tore the relationship apart.”

Holiff is the director of My Father And The Man In Black, which opens in New York on Sunday. (Sadly, no L.A. showings are scheduled.) In the riveting, excoriating documentary he recreates the relationship between Cash and Jonathan's driven, distant dad, who committed suicide in 2005. The agonizing story, which mixes various film stocks, recorded phone calls between Cash and Saul, and some filmed re-creations, gets all the nasty Cash stuff right. The drugs, the divorces, even — gulp — hints of anti-semitism.

In his quietly-explosive film, there is the tale of a father “who didn't love or respect me.” And there's the narrative of Saul — a Canadian Jew — and Johnny making it to the top together and then breaking up their partnership.

The story comes courtesy of a storage locker that Saul kept, full of his taped Cash musings, phone conversations, letters, which gave his troubled son some insight into his dead-eyed progenitor. Holiff's movie is poetic. But, unlike Biography Channel bullshit, this is “no hagiography.” No Johnny Cash's America, with spuds like Al Gore pontificating about a man they didn't know. Here, Cash comes across as weak, crazy, strung out, funny, philandering, and freaking authentic.

“What started this movie was people calling after Walk The Line,” says Holiff. “They said 'Managers don't quit superstars; 'they get fired!' But Saul did. It was ideological, not just religious. For instance, Saul refused to go to the White House with Johnny because he was anti-American and anti-Nixon.”

More troubling is the rift that ultimately sundered the partnership — Saul couldn't accept Jesus as his personal savior, as Cash famously did. In the film, we hear phone recordings of Cash pressing Saul about his perceived lack of dedication to a movie and album project in which Cash travels Israel and retells the Gospels.

I asked Holiff if, as the film suggests, Cash was anti-semitic.

“It was naive anti-semitism. The only Jews these guys ever met were at some trading post in some small town in Arkansas. It was really just being a good ole boy. If Saul was just a money-hungry Jew, why did he quit Johnny when he was making a fortune?”

Perhaps the most riveting part of the film is a long phone conversation between Johnny and Saul about Cash's biopic about the life of Jesus that was released in 1971. It's tense. Cash wants to do the movie. Saul tells him he will offend the Muslims and Jews in his fan base. And that “too many people tell you what you want to hear.” It may be the very moment that breaks up this odd couple.

Mark Stielper, the Cash historian selected by the star's family, found himself moved by Holiff's film. “I was there when Jonathan started on that journey. It was a torturous road. He was searching for himself. Or for his father and himself. This is a story of a father and a son. The Cash connection is the hook. But it is a very profound story. I found it heart-wrenching, and yet Jonathan took great pains not to make it heart wrenching. He tried to make it dispassionate.”

The recreations of early Johnny, shot by Rene Ohashi, are vibrantly choreographed. Here's the pilled-up Cash, onstage in socks, ever the wildass rockabilly cat. But it's the emotion of Holiff's forging a bond in death with a father he didn't have in life that gives the movie its heart. Saul Holiff, ultimately, was a broken man. One who made his son sign contracts at home, stopped talking to him, slipped letters under the boy's door.

I ask Holiff: was this excavation into his father's life, reading his letters, listening to his phone calls, a catharsis? Or is that just something that happens in movies? “It was extremely cathartic,” he said. “I did forgive my father and reconcile with his memory. Having said that, I'm a realist. There are no fairytale endings.”

In his own polite, Canadian way, Holiff ended our conversation with a hard-won moral.

“There was nothing special about my childhood,” he said. “I got to make this movie, mostly because there's a star attached. But I tell everyone, if you haven't reconciled with that parent of yours, do it now. Because you won't find a storage locker with 60 hours of audio-diaries, like I did. If I hadn't found that locker, I'd probably be dead by now. After Saul killed himself and didn't leave a note, I expected that any day a letter would arrive saying he loved me. I never got Saul's love when he was alive. And I sure as hell wasn't going to get it now that he was dead. After Saul's suicide, I was planning my own exit. This movie saved my life.”

Follow us on Twitter @LAWeeklyMusic, and like us at LAWeeklyMusic.

The 15 Most Ridiculous Band Photos

If You Don't Like Country Music You're a Blue State Elitist

Fuck Guilty Pleasures: Tim McGraw's Not Country and He's Not Pop. He's Just Awesome

Top 20 Sexiest Female Musicians of All Time/a>

Top 20 Worst Bands of All Time

Advertising disclosure: We may receive compensation for some of the links in our stories. Thank you for supporting LA Weekly and our advertisers.