If you go searching for “best butt plugs” online, you’ll see a bunch of articles from women’s magazines that quite frankly don’t have a clue what they’re talking about. They recommend bad sex toys and butt plugs made from cheap toxic plastics.
However, I’m a professional sex educator who’s been doing this for years, so allow me to guide you through the valley of anal plugs… whether you’re an expert or brand new to anal play. Anal play is fun for all genders and should be enjoyed!
Here we’ll be looking at the best butt plugs from high-quality manufacturers. All the toys on this list are 100% body-safe.
Let’s get to it!
The 21 Best Butt Plug and Anal Toys
- Best butt plug for beginners – B-Vibe Snug Plug
- Best for intermediate players – LoveHoney Classics Silicone Butt Plug
- Best vibrating plug for discreet public play – Lovense Hush Vibrating Butt Plug
- Best for temperature play – NJoy Large Stainless Steel Butt Plug
- Best for subs & roleplay – LoveHoney Jeweled Metal Plug
- Best prostate plug – Fun Factory Bootie
- Best for anal training – B-Vibe Butt Training Set
- Best for BDSM – Temptasia Slut Pig Silicone Plug
- Best for very, very rich people – Lelo Earl Luxury Gold Butt Plug
- Best for experienced anal fans – Aneros Peridise
- Best b-vibe butt plug – B-Vibe Texture Aqua
- Best cheap buttplug – LoveHoney Butt Tingler
- Best small buttplug – Pipedream Mini Silicone Plug
- Best anal beads plug – CalExotics Booty Beads Anal Probe
- Best glass butt plug – Pipedream Icicles No. 48
- Best for prostate massage – Doc Johnson Silicone P-Plug
- Best for long distance – We-Vibe Ditto
- Best butt plug on Amazon – Pure Love 4.5 Inch Anal Plug
- Best cheap butt plug kit – Funejoy Butt Plug 3-Pack
- Best large butt plug – Tantus A Bomb
- Best for sci-fi roleplay – Butt Bolt
1. B-Vibe Snug Plug – Best butt plug for beginners
- Weighted at 55 grams for “full” feeling
- 3 inches of insertable length
- Beginner size
If you’re a beginner and you want to work your way up to anal play and butt plugs, then the B Vibe Snug Plug is an excellent high-quality toy to start with.
Made from high-grade soft and flexible silicone, this anal toy is designed to be comfortable and give the user that feeling of “fullness” that many people desire from butt plugs.
2. Silicone Butt Plug – Best for intermediate anal play
- 100% silicone
- 5 inches of insertable length
- Tapered tip
The classic butt plug design, this classic from LoveHoney is perfect for anal players who have some experience under their belts.
5 inches long with a tapered tip and flared base, this butt plug is easy to insert and has a nice feeling of fullness that makes for great sex or masturbation.
3. Lovense Hush – Best vibrating butt plug
- Control vibrations with your phone
- 2 different size options
- Wear it in public discreetly
If you like discreet public fun or you just like the idea of a high-tech vibrating butt plug, allow me to introduce the Lovense Hush. This well-designed vibrating butt plug has 3.8 inches of insertable length and a unique spiralled neck that’s designed to trap lube inside the sphincter, making all-day wear more comfortable.
The Lovense smartphone app also allows long-distance couples to tease each other, so you could wear this vibrating plug to work while your partner activates it remotely on their phone via Wi-Fi and Bluetooth. Just make sure you’re not driving or waiting for a Latte when those vibrations strike suddenly!
4. NJoy Steel Butt Plug – Best metal butt plug
- High-grade stainless steel
- 310 grams weight
- Very firm sensation
NJoy is a renowned sex toy company that produces sex toys made from high-grade stainless steel, and this excellent metal butt plug is no exception. Heavy and extra firm, this plug weighs in at 310 grams, so it’s ideal for people who have experience with anal toys in their sex life.
Oh, and it’s nearly 4 inches long!
Because it’s made from steel, you can also explore temperature playing here too. Place the toy in a bowl of warm or cool water for a few minutes and then slip it inside you – the toy will retain the cool or warm temperature for a few minutes, producing a very unique anal sensation.
5. LoveHoney Jeweled Metal Plug – Best jewel butt plug for subs & roleplay
- Blingy gemstone base
- 2.5 inches insertable length
- Ideal for hands-free wear
Made from metal and weighing 144g, this cute butt plug has a bulbous head and a long, slim neck that makes it very easy to insert and comfortable to keep inside without slipping out.
The gemstone base gives this tiny LoveHoney butt plug a charming aesthetic – it’s often used by subs and bottoms in roleplay who are given it by their top or daddy. Fun stuff!
6. Fun Factory Bootie – Best prostate plug
- Made in Germany
- 3 different size options
- Unisex pleasure
Fun Factory is an excellent German sex toy company that makes all of their toys on-site in Brehmen, Germany. And you know, those Germans are really good at engineering and sex stuff. Any products purchased from here are guaranteed to be awesome.
Okay, enough fangirling.
The Bootie is a simple-yet-effective silicone butt plug available in 3 sizes – 3 inches, 3.65 inches, and 4.37 inches. The curved shape is designed to stimulate either your prostate or G-spot, especially if worn while having sex with a partner. Sold!
7. B-Vibe Butt Training Set – Best butt plug kit for anal training
- Anal sex education kit
- 3 butt plugs of different sizes
- Douche, lube shooter, & more
If you’re new to anal play, then this anal kit has got you covered. Designed for a beginner, this kit from B Vibe comes with 3 different butt plugs, an anal douche, and an anal lube shooter for adequate lubing.
If you don’t know how to prep for anal play or you’re not sure how to use these plugs, there’s even a guide to anal play that helps you use everything in the kit like a pro. It’s anal made easy!
8. Temptasia Slut Pig – Best butt plug for BDSM
- Great for roleplay & BDSM
- 2.5 inches insertable length
- Smooth satin silicone
Great for couples who are into power exchange, this plug has “SLUT” written across the base, putting that little whore of yours in their place.
Intermediate-sized and made from silky silicone, pop some water-based lube onto this thing and show that sluts who’s boss.
9. Lelo Earl Gold Butt Plug – Best for very, very rich people
- 24-karat gold
- It’s made of fucking gold
Okay, so like most people reading this, I live in the real world and can’t just drop a few grand on a buttplug… but I had to include this toy here because I’m kind of happy that a solid gold buttplug is a thing that exists in the world.
Made from 24-karat gold, which is apparently body-safe (I’ve never had to check before) the Lelo Earl is perfect if you find yourself in some kind of Fifty Shades situation, I guess.
10. Aneros Peridise – Best for experienced anal plug fans
- Prostate & G-spot pleasure
- High-quality toy
- Firm body-safe plastic
Made by Aneros, who are known for their prostate massagers, the Peridise is a 4-inch long butt plug with a unique shape designed for any gender.
By training your muscles and relaxing, you’ll feel involuntary twitches that are VERY pleasurable. If you’ve ever used an Aneros product, you’ll understand.
11. B-Vibe Texture Aqua – Best b-vibe butt plug toy
- 6 vibration modes
- Unique bumpy texture
- USB charging
With an unusual texture, 4 inches of length, and USB charging, the B Vibe Texture Aqua is a great pleasure toy for anyone who may want to start using anal vibrators.
Convenient, comfy, and cute, this plug has everything going for it!
12. LoveHoney Butt Tingler – Best cheap buttplug
- 3.5 inches of insertable length
- 2 vibration speeds & 3 patterns
- Use solo or with a partner
A good cheap vibrating butt plug, the LoveHoney Butt Tingler is a 3.5-inch silicone toy that comes with 6 possible vibration settings, helping you explore the world of anal vibes!
With a T-bar flared base to keep it in place, this toy is brilliant for solo play or spicing up sex with a partner!
13. Pipedream Mini Silicone Plug – Best small butt plug
- Tiny size for a beginner
- Narrow neck for easy wear
A tiny butt plug designed for beginners, this silicone anal toy is awesome to play around with if you’re new to bum stuff.
At just 1 inch wide and with 3 inches of insertable length, this toy also has a narrow neck that makes it easy for your muscles to close around the toy and keep it in place!
14. CalExotics Booty Beads Anal Probe – Best anal beads plug
- Anal beads style
- 100% silicone
- Easy retrieval ring
Interested in trying anal beads as well as butt plugs? Why not try both at the same time!
This unique hybrid sex toy is 4.5 inches long and 1.25 inches at the widest point, so it’s actually quite manageable if you’re new to this stuff. With 4 beads that get progressively bigger, you may want to stock up on lube.
15. Pipedream Icicles No. 48 – Best glass butt plug
- Stunning glass
- 3 inches long
- Temperature playing possible
Made from stunning pink-colored glass, this cute glass butt plug is the perfect gift for a partner or a sub. With just 3 inches of insertable length, this plug is also good for temperature playing thanks to the borosilicate glass construction.
16. Doc Johnson Silicone P-Plug – Best for prostate massage
- 4.4 inches long
- P-spot play
- Made in the USA
Made right here in the US, the Doc Johnson silicone p-plug is perfect for prostate massage, with the platinum-cured silicone plug resting nicely against your anal pleasure zone.
This small plug is one way to discover the pleasure of anal play, especially for those assigned male at birth.
17. We-Vibe Ditto – Best for long distance
- Remote control ass plug
- 100% waterproof
- 10+ vibration patterns
A rival to the Lovense Hush, the We-Vibe Ditto is a remote control ass plug that can control with either the dedicated remote control or the We-Connect app, giving you more than one way to control the vibrations of you or your partner.
Get creative with it.
Available on LoveHoney with discreet shipping, this vibrating plug comes with 10+ vibration settings to explore, as well as convenient USB charging. It’s even 100% waterproof, so you can take the fun into a naughty bath or shower!
18. Pure Love 4.5 Inch Anal Plug – Best butt plug on Amazon
- Good for a beginner
- 4.5 inches insertable length
- Long, slim design
Designed to be long and slim, this plug is an excellent place to start if you’re exploring anal play and don’t mind dealing with a fair amount of length.
Made from 100% silicone with a tapered tip and flared base for easy insertion, this relatively small plug is available on Amazon complete with the standard Amazon-branded plain packaging for your privacy.
Keep those nosy neighbors guessing.
19. Funejoy Anal Plug 3 Pack – Best cheap anal plug kit
- Very good price
- Three different size options
- Move up the sizes
A steal of a price and available on Amazon, this pack of three silicone butt plugs is ideal for a beginner who is getting used to butt stuff.
The small plug is 3.25 inches long, followed by a 4-inch plug and a 5-inch plug. If you want to get your butt used to this stuff, this kit is a brilliant start.
20. Tantus A Bomb – Best large butt plug
- 5.5 inches long
- 2.4 inches wide
- Ultra-premium silicone
Made from super high-grade body-safe silicone, this large butt plug from Tantus is perfect for fetish play and moving the plug in and out of your butt, like a dildo.
Side note: Mike from Tantus is also super cute. He has the aura of a wholesome trucker who really likes sex toys.
21. Butt Bolt – Best for sci-fi roleplay
- Bolt-style design
- Great for sci-fi & steampunk scenes
- Three size options
Coming in three size options – 3.75 inches long, 4.75 inches long, and 5.5 inches long – this unique butt plug from Mr Hankey’s Toys is great for niche fetish and roleplay, especially if you’re into sci-fi and steampunk.
It’s got a very Jules Verne vibe to it, if you’re into that.