Mom Domingo Gets It Wrong
I have seen the operatic future -- part of it, anyhow -- and it makes me nervous. I view the L.A. Opera under the Domingo dynasty as a grandiose mom n pop operation. Pop Placido nurses his aging voice, transposing the arias downward when necessary, and keeps his right arm in shape with a little stick-waving that might pass for conducting if you dont listen too carefully. Mom Marta, whose career as a professional stage director only goes back to 1991, makes up for lost time by rewriting and then restaging the repertory classics, tacking happy endings onto the tragedies and death scenes onto the comedies.
We have ample chance to sample the perfectly adequate ordinariness of Placidos conducting over the years; it fits into the pattern of podium mediocrity that has haunted the company from the start. (His announced Aida next fall looks from here like more of the same.) Right now its the diminutive Marta who looms large, in the colossally misguided version of Puccinis three-legged puppy of an almost-operetta, La Rondine, currently sullying the air at the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion, that she not only directs but has also extensively revised in the name of correcting faults that she (and she alone) has detected in the standard version.
Puccini himself had his troubles with La Rondine. In one early version, never performed and later disowned, the reformed prostitute Magda, denounced by tenor Ruggero as he learns The Truth, faces the wreckage of her one true love alone and abandoned at the final curtain. Its not hard to understand why the final version, with the parting of the mismatched lovers both wistful and inevitable -- as in Der Rosenkavalier, which Puccini admired -- harmonizes far better with the rest of the work. Marta Domingo, however, has chosen to impose her own gloss onto the rejected version; her Magda, more Joan Crawford than Strauss Marschallin, walks out into a handy nearby ocean and sinks out of sight. Designer Michael Scott has provided a terrific tidal wave.
Martas editorial hand falls elsewhere as well. Like a fond momma scattering tchotchkes, she has littered Puccinis perfectly respectable score with useless bits: a scrap of text from Godknowswhere stuck onto an orchestral passage, a newly contrived add-on to a duet for Magda and her sugar daddy there. From another Puccini reject she has exhumed a first-act tenor aria, with a gut-busting high some-note-or-other at the end on which tenor Marcus Haddock foundered most ignobly. One should be polite about people unfortunately named, but Mr. Haddocks Ruggero was decidedly cold fish. And so was the Magda of Carol Vaness -- wreathed in whore-frost, you might say -- as a soprano still admirable in the classic repertory tries once again (as in her previous Violetta and Tosca here) to remake herself as an Italian romantic. Greg Fedderly and Sari Gruber managed the juvenile roles with charm and ease; newcomer conductor Emmanuel Villaume did some furious arm-waving that was fun to watch without significantly mitigating the overall gloom, the unshakable sense that none of this should really be allowed to happen -- least of all at a $146 top ticket.
On this matter of wrong-head-edness, you might want to rummage around in your imaginations darkest reaches in search of other deplorable musical ideas. A rewrite of Aida with a new score by Elton John? A parcel of Bob Dylan lyrics newly set to the typically shiny, slick, faceless music of John Corigliano? Neck and neck for wrong-headedness, wouldnt you say?
Well, the new-fangled Aida is doing okay, if not great, on Broadway, and the much-admired American soprano Sylvia McNair is traipsin the countryside with Mr. Tambourine Man: Seven Poems of Bob Dylan, its attraction not at all impeded by its composers recent Oscar (for more of the same typically shiny etc. music for The Red Violin). The crowd at McNairs recent Dorothy Chandler Pavilion recital was on the paltry side, smaller than the splendor of McNairs proven artistry deserves, larger than the prospect of the evenings major work held forth. Word does, after all, get around.
Coriglianos program note has it that he hadnt heard a note of Dylans songs until the Carnegie Hall commission (awarded to McNair for a song cycle, who then chose the composer) came his way; that, for a red-blooded American born in 1938, getting his own name around New York in the very time of Dylans glory days there, takes some doing. Whether from ignorance or malice, he has been keenly successful in circumventing the Dylan essence, the gritty insinuation that goes out from all the great lyrics to shape an inescapable, elementary kind of melody, simplistic but insistent. He has chosen his texts well: Mr. Tambourine Man, Blowin in the Wind, All Along the Watchtower, all faves, and stifled them all under a suffocating blanket of Art.
The earth didnt move very far under the Japan America Theater during the most recent Green Umbrella concert, but it quivered agreeably in place even so. Donald Crockett led his USC Contemporary Music Ensemble in a nicely varied program that included intricate, responsible music by Crockett himself and his faculty colleague Stephen Hartke. There was, as well, a nicely designed, exceptionally attractive work called Labyrinth by another academic not yet known here but obviously deserving: Indiana Universitys David Dzubay; remember the name. At the end came Randall Woolfs Motown-tinged Shakedown, the kind of easygoing modernness you put at the end of a new-music program to reassure audiences that they havent been witnessing the end of the world. The three major music compositional outlooks hereabouts are easily distinguishable: UCLA for its marketable blandness, CalArts for its winnowing of art forms out of chaos and the avoidance of marketable blandness at any cost, USC for its academic solidity. Taken together, they offer fair reassurance that music will be around for a while.
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you’ll never miss LA Weekly's biggest stories.