Loading...
Food Fight

Chili Cheese Dog Fight: Pink's Vs. Carney's

Comments (0)

By

Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 2:00 PM

We're not sure who really came up with the idea of taking a processed tube of (potentially cancerous) mystery meat, then pouring a thick stew of heavily cooked-down meat on top of it -- but they should probably be congratulated, or yelled at, or both. Now you can order chili dogs almost everywhere, topped with onions and cheese, and all precariously contained within a bun that you can press down to the size of a golf ball. Two local restaurants take great pride in their versions, with one, Pink's, sporting perhaps the most consistently long lines in local food purveyor history.

click to enlarge Pink's chili cheese dog - N. GALUTEN
  • N. Galuten
  • Pink's chili cheese dog

We began there, trying to beat those lines by arriving painfully early, at 10:15 a.m., and barely succeeding. The menu is surprisingly large, mainly due to the numerous possible topping and dog combinations. Celebrity head shots line the walls, and there are even some celebrity hot dogs too: Martha Stewart, Huell Howser, and Patt Morrison have their own, yet thankfully, Michael Vick does not.

The Pink's chili cheese dog, despite its success, remains fairly affordable at $3.75. It is an exercise in simplicity compared to the rest of the menu, and not too difficult to handle. The best part of the dog is that much-loved "snap" when you bite down. In a surprising twist, the slice of cheese may be the most dominant flavor, as the hot dog itself gets a bit lost in the shuffle.

click to enlarge Chili cheese dog from Carney's - N. GALUTEN
  • N. Galuten
  • Chili cheese dog from Carney's

At Carney's, the train car-turned restaurant on Sunset Boulevard, their titular dog with cheese ($3.95) is actually quite different, despite the many similar ingredients. The primary difference, and the one most immediately apparent, is that there are two thick, half slices of tomato placed right on top. When you try to lift the hot dog, you'll find a surprising weight to it, half-expecting the entire thing to rip through the middle of the bun like a cup of sand through a wet paper towel. Is it a knife-and-fork chili cheese dog? Does such a thing even exist?

You'll find a little less "snap" than at Pink's, but the dog actually keeps its texture as you continue eating it. You can taste the hot dog too, which is juicier, and stands out despite the strong, fresh taste of tomato. You will also leave a debris of tomato, bun, and chili.

If eating the Pink's chili cheese dog is like working out against a punching bag, Carney's is like stepping into the ring with a sparring partner. For us, Carney's is the superior chili dog, with the taste of the hot dog itself pushing it into the winner's circle. But if it's the messiness that puts you off, well, you probably shouldn't be eating a chili dog in the first place.

Pink's Hot Dogs: 709 North La Brea Avenue, L.A., (323) 931-4223‎, Carney's Restaurant: 8351 West Sunset Boulevard, West Hollywood, (323) 654-8300‎.

Related Location

Related Content

Now Trending

Slideshows

  • Malibu Pier Restaurant and Bar
    Malibu Pier Restaurant and Bar, with chef Jason Fullilove at the helm, is in the two buildings at the pier’s entrance that used to be Beachcomber Cafe and Ruby’s Diner. Those buildings, which have been overhauled completely, reflect both the pier’s 109-year-old history and the cultural import of Malibu itself.
  • The Tasting Menu Trend
    In Los Angeles especially, but increasingly across the country, restaurants are either switching to tasting menus, putting a greater focus on a tasting-menu option (while offering à la carte items as well), or opening as tasting-menu operations from day one. The format that used to be the calling card of only the fanciest of restaurants is becoming ubiquitous, even at places where the waiter calls you “dude” and there isn’t a white tablecloth in sight.
  • Milo's Kitchen: A Treat Truck for Dogs
    Milo's Kitchen, a part of California-based Big Heart Pet Brands, is taking its homestyle dog treats on the road this summer with the "Treat Truck." The dogified food truck is making stops all over the country, ending up in New York early September. The truck stopped at Redondo Beach Dog Park Friday morning entertaining the pups with treats, a photo-booth and play zone. Milo's Kitchen Treat Truck offered samples of the line's six flavors, all with chicken or beef as the first ingredient, and all made in the U.S.A. with no artificial colors or preservatives. All photos by Nanette Gonzales.