QUESTION: I must ask you a question that has been bothering me for quite some time now. Last year I had dinner at Valentino with three other people. When our waiter took our order, he addressed me with the Italian Mrs., and possibly because he found the other woman in our party attractive (a doctored-up gold digger, if you ask me), he addressed her as Miss. We had earlier been speaking of marriage with our waiter, and he knew I wasnt married, and I said to him calmly, Im not married. And the waiter looked at me and said, I thought you were married to yourself. I was dumbfounded. I didnt know what to say. I didnt know how rude he really had been; I just knew I was terribly hurt.
Months later I wrote a letter to Valentinos owner, Piero Selvaggio, but I got no response. The sad thing about this incident is that Im not a chef groupie, but I do like good food, and since then Ive been reluctant to venture out and eat at restaurants. Im from a working-class family (my mom was a maid for an actor a B-level actor), and Ill never forget my first great meal at La Toque. Please tell me your thoughts regarding this horrible incident at this so-called fine restaurant.
Shirley, Los Angeles
ANSWER: Rest assured: The waiter was a sleaze. But in Italy itself, I gather, signorina basically applies only to girls in their teens; high school kids. Women are almost automatically called signora, which seems to be more of an honorific than a statement of marital status it would be something of an insult to call a woman in her mid-20s signorina as it would be here to call a woman Miss instead of Maam. Unless the waiter was hitting on your friend, in which case he was laying it on pretty thick, or was engaging in the expensive-Italian-restaurant version of what we used to call minimum-wage attitude. His unamusing retort was, of course, inexcusable.
Personally, Im not sure where I stand on the basic issue. On the one hand, I am rarely happy to be called dude by a man to whom I am paying $120 for a plate of white-truffle risotto, while on the other, being called sir makes me cringe. Still, I suspect the original signora was meant as no insult to your no doubt spectacular beauty. Monica Bellucci is probably called signora, too.
If you like this story, consider signing up for our email newsletters.
SHOW ME HOW
You have successfully signed up for your selected newsletter(s) - please keep an eye on your mailbox, we're movin' in!
Got a burning culinary question? Try us: firstname.lastname@example.org