Tuned In, Turned On and Locked Out
Photo by Virginia Lee Hunter
Anyone who thought radicalism was dead should have been in Berkeley over the last several months, as dozens of activists got arrested in the course of round-the-clock protests and sit-ins. It was the 60s all over again. But the progressives arent at war against the religious right, the CIA or the military-industrial complex. These lefties are at loggerheads with other lefties, and apparently taking no prisoners.
Ground zero is Berkeley radio station KPFA, which was founded in 1949 by local pacifists and became the springboard for the Pacifica Radio Network and its five affiliate stations that have, for decades, provided both an alternative and a tonic to commercial radio and middle-of-the-road politics.
The conflict flared with the March firing of popular station manager Nicole Sawaya, then quickly escalated when Pacifica Foundation board members tried to enforce a gag rule regarding on-air discussions of Sawayas dismissal. One of the first to be fired over the matter was newsman Larry Bensky, one of Pacificas most respected and honored contributors. Another host, Dennis Bernstein, was ordered out under guard in the middle of his program. Since July 14, the entire staff has been locked out, with the station subsisting on network feeds and tapes of old programs.
Its a dispute rife with ironies. The radicals who decry network management are launching their missiles against a Pacifica Foundation board peopled with minorities, women and civil rights activists. It is not your average board of directors. At the same time, the Foundation has fallen into the role of villain with remarkable dispatch by resorting to tactics entirely at odds with the ethos of an organization that has been, historically, an anti-corporate beacon of unfettered speech and ideas.
The current struggle grew out of years of tension between local-station staff and the Pacifica Foundation. By 1993, the group Take Back KPFA had already formed in response to increased local tithing to the network required by Pacifica and to changes in programming viewed as hostile to the stations mission. These changes have included the dismissal of longtime radio personalities Bill Mandel, who discoursed on the Soviet Union, and jazz aficionado Phil Elwood. Some observers applauded the removal of these hosts and other related moves as an attempt to bring life to an ossified lineup. But both men had their loyalists, and any revamping of the station brought out critics who accused KPFA of becoming too mainstream or trying to ape National Public Radio.
KPFA has for years been the C-SPAN of radio. Where else was there 24-hour-a-day coverage of the Free Speech Movement, or gavel-to-gavel broadcasting of the Clarence Thomas confirmation or Bill Clintons impeachment? That unique programming, along with shows featuring non-mainstream music and quirky or talented hosts, is what KPFA has meant to many. (Famed movie reviewer Pauline Kael hosted a KPFA show before becoming famous; Jerry Brown had a gig here between government jobs.)
Like National Public Radio, Pacifica relies on federal funds for a portion (about 15 percent) of an estimated $10 million operating budget (making Pacifica a favorite target of conservative politicians for years). And this tie to federal money, with its evolving requirements, helped set off the current furor. The Corporation for Public Broadcasting, the federal funding agency, asserted last year that the board members of local stations could no longer serve on Pacificas national board, further reducing KPFAs autonomy and reversing what had been common procedure. When Pacifica executive director Pat Scott (a onetime KPFA manager who has since left Pacifica) received the advisory, she queried whether Pacifica was in compliance. The answer was no, putting Pacificas federal funds at risk. KPFA was told that Pacifica stood to lose $1.4 million should the network not rectify matters.
KPFA station manager Nicole Sawaya was asked to draw up prospective budget cuts in anticipation of a possible cutoff in funds. But Sawaya refused to slash salaries or positions a stance that endeared her to staffers and, instead, defiantly stated that shed cut the 17 percent of locally raised funds that is automatically transferred to Pacifica to offset parent-organization expenses. For this rebellion, apparently, Sawaya was canned, although the Foundation has never offered an official explanation.
All of the other firings, and the July 14 lockout of the entire local KPFA staff (they remain on paid administrative leave), have arisen from defiance of a so-called gag rule (long in place, but never enforced) that forbids discussing the stations internal matters on the air. Hence the rebels cries for "Free Speech Radio" and their depiction of Pacifica as a dictatorship.
For a station founded on the principle of airing alternative opinions, the decision to fire Bensky et al. was ill-advised at best. Protests over the firings are now playing out almost nightly in the streets. A tent encampment of demonstrators has risen outside KPFAs headquarters, and on one evening, Joan Baez headlined a fund-raiser at the local Berkeley Community Theater, a reconvening of the protest culture that was birthed here in l964. On another night, a burst of gunfire shattered a small plate-glass window at the station. So far there have been nearly 100 arrests, compelling Pacifica to spend a small fortune on private security and saddling the city with $160,000 in police overtime costs which prompted a mediation offer from Mayor Shirley Dean.
On July 16, 18 members of local Pacifica station advisory boards across the county filed suit in Alameda County against the Foundation. They seek to nullify bylaws adopted in the wake of the federal advisory on national-board membership. They claim that the new bylaws make the national board self-perpetuating and would illegally harm the interests of station subscribers. Outside of court, demonstrators are calling for the reinstatement of all KPFA staffers, local control for the station, and the resignation of Pacifica board chair Mary Frances Berry and current executive director Lynn Chadwick, the acting head of KPFA. Last week, the litigants agreed to federal mediation.
The conflict has the potential to spread to Los Angeles and Pacifica network affiliate KPFK (90.7 FM). On Saturday, more than 200 Angelenos crammed a North Hills church to hear KPFA veterans critique Pacifica. After two hours, the crowd was responding with lusty cheers to calls for "democracy and accountability," and more than four-fifths of them raised hands when asked if they would put next years station pledges into a protester-controlled escrow account instead.
KPFK station manager Mark Schubb although not invited by the sponsoring Pacifica Accountability Committee was in the audience and worried afterward that the Berkeley conflagration might spread southward. And on Tuesday, 50 demonstrators showed up outside KPFKs studio in the Cahuenga Pass. They were more focused on network issues than on KPFK itself, but the embers of local discontent are already aglow if burning low stoked by several ex-programmers and members of the stations local advisory board.
Echoing the issues at KPFA, critics accused KPFK of "mainstreaming" or "NPR-ization" for terminating such public-affairs shows as Green Perspectives, American Indian Airwaves, and Focus on the Americas with professor Blase Bonpane, a veteran of volunteer broadcasting since 1969. They asserted, too, that in music and news theres been a little "whitening," with less ethnic content on the air. As at Berkeley, station loyalists are suspicious about moves to broaden the audience base. To them, such talk verges on corporatization.
These feelings are only enhanced by Pacifica missteps, as when an e-mail from a Houston board member was mistakenly sent to Pacifica critics. In it, the member explored swapping the potentially lucrative commercial band of either KPFA or New Yorks WBAI for a weaker, cheaper signal, then using the proceeds as an endowment to secure better financial footing for the parent organization. A management source at Pacifica, speaking off the record, vigorously denied any such intent: "One guy suggested it. No one was for it."
And Pacificas recently hired public-relations firm, Fineman Associates, has stumbled over self-defeating paranoia, refusing to answer questions, for example, unless this reporter could "prove" she was a bona fide journalist by faxing in past articles. And then questions had to be submitted in writing. Greeting the watching world with the suspiciousness of a backwoods sheriff is hardly going to get Pacifica out of this mess.
But is Pacifica the enemy? Former executive director Pat Scott, for instance, castigated as a "snitch" for asking the feds about board-membership requirements, can boast of years of left-wing involvement, including the struggle to win the liberty of onetime black militant Angela Davis, a personal friend. Scott, an African-American, said she gravitated to Pacifica to enable "poor people and people of color to have access to the airwaves." She asked the federal funding agency for clarification, she said unapologetically, "because that was part of my job." Ironically, she claims it was Sawaya who first drew her attention to the issue.
But at the moment, Scott is being defined more by her role in management than by her left-wing credentials, which are easily the equal of many demonstrators. To Scotts chagrin, Angela Davis along with novelist Alice Walker has expressed solidarity with the ousted staff.
"Angela and Alice have been my friends for ages," said Scott in an interview. "Weve partied together, but neither bothered to call me about this. People dont want to know the truth. They just want to be bumper stickers without knowing the facts."
Scott contends that shes frustrated by a culture of the left that is suspicious of good ratings and professional production values. "The left gets pissed off about anything that works," said Scott. "Its a whole culture of losers. I spent 12 years of my life trying to strengthen this institution, and I dont want to see it torn down."
Bensky echoes that sentiment from the other side of the barricade. Recalling the start of his KPFA career as a volunteer programmer in l969, he sounds weary but determined: "I didnt ask for this at 62 years old. I tried to remain aloof for a bit because its the last thing I need. But theres no way Im going to let this organization get killed."
Research and additional reporting by John Seeley.