Prop. 8 Trial: Stanford Professor Says Obama 'Not a Reliable Ally'
President Barack Obama took a hit at the Proposition 8 trial in San Francisco on Wednesday, when Stanford University professor Gary Segura said Obama is "not a reliable ally" of the gay community.
The criticism of the president was a key legal point made by the Prop. 8 plaintiffs' lawyers, who want to overturn California's gay marriage ban, to show that gays and lesbians are not politically powerful and need legal protections from the courts.
San Jose Mercury News reporter Howard Mintz writes that "Segura had some pointed
criticism for Obama, observing that while he's spoken out strongly in
favor of gay rights, he has not taken any real steps to back same-sex
marriage or change the military's policy."
"This is not a reliable
ally," Segura said in court. "We have to look at
the disconnect between rhetoric and action."
During cross examination, Prop. 8 defendants' lawyers, who want to uphold the gay marriage ban, tried to paint a different picture of gay political power in the United States, pointing to same sex marriage victories in Vermont and Massachusetts that show gays and lesbians don't need special protections.
Prop. 8 lawyer David Thompson also asked Segura if Obama was more of a political ally to the gay community than his predecessor, George W. Bush. Segura, according to Mintz, "didn't budge" and made a somewhat astounding statement.
"I think the degree of difference is far smaller than most progressives (expected)," Segura said in court.
Segura will return to the stand on Thursday, and Prop. 8 plaintiffs' lawyers say they have only two more witnesses waiting to testify.
Contact Patrick Range McDonald at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you'll never miss LA Weekly's biggest stories.