No Room for Cheap
Photo by Anne Fishbein
Loews luxury Santa Monica Beach Hotel is undergoing a facelift. Guests who can afford the $365-a-night tariff enter the four-story atrium lobby through a scruffy tunnel lined with green plastic sheeting and lighted by bare bulbs hanging from yellow cords. This renovation is due to be completed soon. But workers at Loews where the hourly wage for most employees is less than the average glass of wine at the hotels posh Lavande restaurant are looking to make more fundamental changes.
With 30 of the hotels 300 workers ready to go public as backers of the union, Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees (HERE) Local 814 kicked off an organizing drive Thursday with a spirited beachside rally of more than 400, backed by several local religious leaders and Santa Monica City Council members. The Loews campaign is merely step one in a drive to organize the upscale hotels in Santa Monica, where only one Fairmonts Miramar is unionized.
A leaflet passed out Thursday highlighted some of the contrasting working conditions at the two hotels, citing such benefits as a pension plan and free family health insurance at the Miramar, as well as job security, grievance arbitration, guaranteed hours and a stable work schedule. Loews staffers cited several of these points in explaining their need for representation: Jose Colato, a 10-year employee in the restaurant, says he is often sent home before the end of a shift if things are slow, and he cant count on earning 40 hours wages; room attendant Alicia Castrejon complains that After seven years on my job, I cant even plan for what days off Ill have.
On the wage front, mere murmurs of union sentiment were enough to spur a sudden management re-evaluation of workers worth. After several years of hourly raises in the 15- or 20-cent range (and two years of frozen rates), raises of between $1 and $3 were given this spring. In April management also rescinded a recent $40 a month increase in employees health insurance costs. While happy to have the extra money, says housekeeper Vera Miranda, most workers understand that it came only because of the union drive, and expect that more substantial gains will come with recognition. Despite free massages and gift certificates to the restaurant that also were suddenly given out recently, waiter Favian Gonzalez says, I want to be respected, not bought off. The recent victories in the janitors strike, he added, were a positive example of what unions can do to improve workplace conditions.
They are handing out money like weve never seen before, but its too little, too late, said union organizer Kurt Petersen. Its an insult to the workers. Everyones asking, Where was the money before? Why now? And the answer is the union.
Its a great victory, Petersen said. We havent even stepped inside and we have our first victory. Its not about wages. They underestimate peoples intelligence. What they give away today, they can take away tomorrow. Workers want to be treated fairly and with respect.
Mayra Rodas, a housekeeper, said the hotel hiked her salary from $7.75 to $9.50 an hour in the past two months. Rodas said she cleans 15 rooms a day changing the linen, scrubbing the bathroom, vacuuming the floor and dusting the furniture in rooms that sometimes go for more a night than her $510-a-month apartment.
But Rodas says the struggle is not about money.
They dont respect us, Rodas said. The supervisors scream at us . . . I was afraid. They follow us to the bathroom, check how long were on break. Im not afraid anymore. Im already tired of so much abuse.
Management would not engage in any discussion with Mayor Ken Genser or others in the delegation from Thursdays rally, reading instead a statement from its New York City public-relations department. In the brief response, Loews struck a posture of neutrality vis-à-vis unionization, maintaining that under its longstanding policy, the decision to organize a union is made by the employees at each individual property and promising to fully support whatever decision the employees themselves make. But on Saturday, two days after the demonstration, management had tossed neutrality aside and was gearing up its anti-union drive in earnest. Mandatory meetings were launched, in which workers were shown videos exposing the perils of labor representation. The message they were pushing was, You dont need a union, you can talk for yourselves, said Miranda.
The campaign is likely to spill over this summer into downtown Los Angeles, where HERE Local 11 represents workers at the four largest hotels, but several others, including the Marriott, Omni Intercontinental and New Otani, remain unorganized. Locals 814 and 11 will be supporting one another as the campaign evolves. Some of the hotels may be the scene of labor action during Augusts Democratic convention, said one union staffer, posing awkward choices for party officials and pro-labor delegates staying there.
The campaign which coincides with a hotly contested battle over a pioneering living-wage proposal for Santa Monicas hotel and restaurant employees comes one month after the local Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees Union signed a contract with the new owners of the Miramar Fairmont Hotel. But unlike the Miramar vote to retain the union, a union election at the Loews would not be conducted under the auspices of the National Labor Relations Board, Petersen said.
Its not a fair process, he said. Workers get fired and nothing is done. The NLRB gives some protections, but not enough. Instead, union leaders hope management agrees to hold a tally supervised by a priest or a judge. Similar elections have been held at duty-free shops at LAX and at the new Staples Center downtown, as well as at some Las Vegas casinos, Petersen said.
He said the workers will get the union to agree to similar elections through marching, through organizing. Lets hope they get their senses soon. We dont want another Miramar, Petersen said, referring to the nasty four-year battle with the previous owners of the citys only unionized hotel. But were ready to go as long as it takes. Well be back.
Jorge Casuso contributed to this story.
Get the Weekly Newsletter
Our weekly feature stories, movie reviews, calendar picks and more - minus the newsprint and sent directly to your inbox.