Hollywood Joins Union Bill Drive -- Too Late?
A new online ad promoting the Employee Free Choice Act (EFCA) has been posted by a coalition of Hollywood labor guilds and the reviews (all right, my reviews) are mixed -- both as to the spot and the chances that Congress will pass the legislation this year in anything but a watered-down form. EFCA, which has been the subject of intense lobbying by American unions, would allow workers at a company to form a union simply through a "card check" of employees. If a majority sign cards express a desire to form a union, then it's a done deal and the next step is the negotiation of a contract. This method would replace the the present system, which relies on what employers like to call a "secret ballot" method -- which, in fact, leaves workers at the mercy of company threats and misinformation campaigns prior to balloting.
The ad, written by Writers Guild members Tim Carvell and
Luvh, and produced by Artists for Workers Choice, features 47 actors, including Amy Brenneman, James Cromwell, Elliott Gould and Esai Morales, explaining EFCA. In the video, each actor delivers a sentence or simply one word from the text and is replaced by a shot of the next performer to continue the reading.
It's hard to imagine this being broadcast on TV. Little longer than three minutes, the spot is an eternity for the hummingbird-like attention spans of modern couch potatoes. And the format, featuring rapid cuts of talking heads that often repeat a previous line or word multiple times, is a little incongruous, as though the producers tried to apply rap-video aesthetics to a political speech.
Radio listeners to Dodger games have by now become familiar with an ad
campaign that at least is not confined to the Web. This one, paid for
by the Los Angeles County Federation of Labor, will have a game
announcer, such as Rick Monday, read some neutral-sounding copy about
the goodness of baseball, military service, union jobs and the freedom to chose. There's no hard
sell involved, but then, there's no indication that "freedom to chose"
is code for EFCA, much less what EFCA is all about.
question about these ad campaigns is, "Why now?" The passage of EFCA
was labor's number one priority going into 2009. Unions began the year
with an If Not Now, When? spirit, figuring, not unreasonably, that if
they couldn't get EFCA passed with Barack Obama in the White House and
a commanding Democratic Congressional majority, what hope would there
be of getting the job done in the future? Then the not-so-unthinkable
happened: Key Senators waffled and then caved, notably California's
Diane Feinstein and Pennsylvania's Arlen Specter. Without their
support, EFCA seems doomed for this year. Feinstein, ironically, has
been a promoter of EFCA incarnations in the past -- when there was no
chance of its passage. She is the only member of the California
Congressional delegation opposed to the current version of EFCA.
Even now, union members continue to hold vigils,
meet with Feinstein staffs throughout the state, and flood her office
with letters of support for the bill -- to absolutely no avail.
Feinstein's official position is that the economy is too fragile to
help the country's workers secure wage and medical benefits through the
unionization of private companies. Maybe what she needs is another
video -- perhaps call it The Miracle Worker.
Get the ICYMI: Today's Top Stories Newsletter
Catch up on the day's news and stay informed with our daily digest of the most popular news, music, food and arts stories in Los Angeles, delivered to your inbox Monday through Friday.