B as in Betrayal
Beatrice Dent couldnt quite remember whether she voted for county Measure B two years ago. It was a brief moment in a crowded life of 79 years. Measure B, which passed in November 2002, raised property taxes to help pay for the countys endangered trauma-care system.
As she pondered, Dent was standing in the front yard of the Willowbrook-area home she bought in 1946 for about $6,000. Its not like shed favor higher property taxes shes a retiree with medical bills, and with a daughter and grandkids crammed into her diminutive, well-kept home. In the distance, in front of her, rose the King-Drew Medical Center. The main building, with its bland, 70s-style architecture, dominates the landscape.
Yes, she decided, she must have voted for Measure B. We dont need more taxes, she said. But to help the needy and the poor, I think I would have probably voted for it.
Dent is among those in neighborhoods served by King-Drew who now feel uneasy, if not betrayed. County officials have begun a process to close the hospitals trauma-care unit. They say the moves necessary to save the rest of the troubled institution. Trauma patients, they insist, can be cared for elsewhere.
Some 73 percent of county voters supported Measure B, accepting it as very much a matter of life or death. Around Dents neighborhood, theres no doubt which trauma-care unit they thought they were voting to preserve. King-Drew handles some of the regions most violence-plagued areas. Only the huge County-USC Medical Center deals with more trauma cases which are defined as patients in immediate, life-threatening danger from falls, car accidents, shootings and stabbings. These are cases where every second matters, including the minutes it takes to ride to a hospital.
We worked hard to pass that measure, said John Jackson, a community organizer with ACORN, a grassroots activist group. Jackson and crew walked precincts, manned telephone banks, and drew up lists of targeted voters to visit a second and third time. They held rallies on the lawn of King-Drew.
On Saturday, Jackson recounted ACORNs efforts as he stood just outside Grant AME Church in Watts, about a mile north of the hospital. He was awaiting the imminent arrival of Congresswoman Maxine Waters, who had called Saturdays gathering. Waters was running late, but some 100 residents and activists waited patiently in the churchs basement meeting hall. Some filled the time with testimony, offering counterevidence to recent disclosures about gross malpractice that have made headlines. These failings have put the hospital itself on life support.
Johnnie Simmons talked of how her son had entered the emergency room about two years ago with a severe headache and nausea. Doctors quickly recognized serious risk. After an examination, she recounted, they wheeled him into an operating bay. The surgeon, she said, used a newly developed technique and carried things off flawlessly. King-Drew doctors also had treated her son years earlier, after he was stabbed.
My whole thing is, when they had bad doctors and bad nurses a long time ago, they got rid of them, but they kept the hospital, said Simmons. So if you got somebody who is not doing the job at a hospital that we need in this area, get rid of them. Get new ones. But leave our hospital.
When she arrived, Representative Waters joined the chorus, vowing that any attempt to close the trauma unit would meet organized resistance.
COUNTY OFFICIALS say theyve kept faith with voters on Measure B. This is a medical issue, said County Supervisor Zev Yaroslavsky, author of Measure B. Im surprised, frankly, that people arent outraged by the quality of service at King, including in the trauma center. When we all voted for Measure B, you werent voting for any one trauma center, we were voting to keep the trauma system.
The trauma center is 4 percent of the hospital. If the whole hospital closes because of the lack of quality of care, trauma will go with it, and so will the emergency room and so will everything else.
Supervisor Yvonne Brathwaite Burke, who represents the King-Drew area, acknowledges risk to the entire hospital, but added that the health departments trauma-care alternatives proved less comprehensive, less satisfactory than senior staff led her to believe. Community members who question the countys promise-keeping on Measure B have a good argument, she said. And it must be recognized.
The measure taxes buildings at 3 cents per square foot. For a 1,000-square-foot home, the tax increase, for example, works out to $30 a year. The ballot statement pledged that the dollars would maintain and expand the trauma-care network, improve responses to other medical emergencies, and deal with the threat of chemical and biological terrorism. At the time, the last bit seemed like a shameless ploy for the scared of terrorists vote, to help push the measure over the two-thirds approval threshold. Measure B was fundamentally about saving emergency medical services, including trauma care.
Measure B has one year of spending history. Some $140 million went to county hospitals. County-USC claimed the largest share: $86.6 million. Then came Harbor-UCLA at $27.5 million and King-Drew at $18.5 million. If K-Ds trauma center closes, most of its money could go elsewhere. Patients formerly served by King-Drew will not be shortchanged, said Carol Meyer, director of emergency services for L.A. County. The money will follow the patients, she said. The county wont save money by cutting trauma at King-Drew, because those patients will still require care elsewhere, she added. The goal of closing the trauma center, said Meyer, is to take pressure off King-Drew, so the hospital can improve other services, including those in its emergency room, which handles about 25 times as many patients as the trauma unit.
About $18.6 million in Measure B funds went to private hospitals. And $2 million went to pay for helicopter trips for patients from the Antelope Valley, which lacks a trauma unit. Terrorism prevention soaked up only $383,000, but this looks like a growth area. That money paid for a speakers bureau that sent nurses to senior centers to warn them about the West Nile virus. And researchers also are preparing emergency information in the event of an outbreak of anthrax, botulism or smallpox. In addition, environmental-health specialists are developing improved blueprints for tracing food contamination.
Back in Beatrice Dents neighborhood, its almost impossible to find a household without someone who was treated by the King-Drew emergency room, the trauma center, or both.
Contractor Maurice Slaughter recalled the day a circular saw cut his knee to the bone. His partner Phil rushed him to King-Drew in the back of his pickup. He needed 98 stitches, he said, pointing to the scar.
A few doors down, painters David McKulin and Jason Coleman were working on the brake booster and taillights of Colemans 88 Cavalier. Both pointed in the direction of places nearby where thered been shootings. McKulin, like many area residents, has followed the hospitals travails in the newspaper. I wouldnt necessarily want to go to Martin Luther King for a stomachache, he said. But for a stabbing or a shooting, take me to Martin Luther King. Straight out, because they deal with this daily. They know how to fix you. That hospital saves a lot of lives. This is a violent place out here.
A few years back, McKulin was rushed to the trauma unit after his brother stabbed him in the neck: Martin Luther King patched me up pretty proper. If they close them down, where do they want people to go, just fall out dead in the street or what?
The county can argue all it wants about good intentions, about adequate trauma care elsewhere, and even about saving King-Drew, but the community sees this episode as an attack on the hospital and on them.
My real belief is that because its in a black and brown community, nobody gives a damn, said McKulin.
Dents rhetoric is softer, but her roots with the hospital run deep. She was active in the local homeowners association when county Supervisor Kenny Hahn worked tirelessly to build the hospital in the wake of the Watts riots. She proudly keeps a picture of the late Hahn holding her infant daughter. She was there for the groundbreaking, there for the dedication. And just recently, she hobbled there for therapy on her leg.
I definitely dont want the hospital or the trauma unit to close, she said. Its really, really needed.
Get the Weekly Newsletter
Our weekly feature stories, movie reviews, calendar picks and more - minus the newsprint and sent directly to your inbox.