Sales Go Soft. Shins Go Limp. Rock Critics Go Limper.
Hips Dont Matter: If James Brown was the godfather of soul, Prince is certainly his successor. If he needs hip-replacement surgery, though as was reported prior to his gig at Super Bowl XLI the question beckons: Whos next in line? Uh, Justin Timberlake? Id worry more if it werent for Princes outstanding Miami performance, where he proved beyond a shadow of a doubt pun intended that hips dont just lie, theyre unnecessary. All you need is a phallus-shaped guitar, and a spotlight projecting your image on a large sheet. Yes, it looked like he was jacking off during his performance of Purple Rain, but Im uncertain it was intentional especially given his alleged status as a Jehovahs Witness. Either way, he deserves a round of applause for keeping mystery alive. After Janet Jacksons wardrobe malfunction, Fall Out Boy Pete Wentzs leaked cock pics, Paris Hiltons entire career and Timberlakes dick-in-a-box, we need artists who understand that banal, bare-it-all provocation is less compelling than subtler forms of sexy.
Caetano Veloso: Cê (Nonesuch): Sixty-four-year-old Caetano Veloso is the closest thing Brazil has to Bob Dylan though some might retort that Dylan is Americas answer to Veloso. Both men spoke truth to power in the mid-60s though only Veloso was actually exiled for it. Both published erudite memoirs in recent years Dylans elliptical, poetic Chronicles and Velosos intellectual, academic Tropical Truth. Both have made humanizing stumbles Dylan throughout the 80s, Veloso when he resorts to overly schmaltzy arrangements and smooth jazz vox.
Still, most agree Velosos art has aged like fine wine. (For a prime example of his mature delivery, download his 1996 live take on CuCurrucucú Paloma. Witness how the bossa nova rhythms that his music builds on benefit from the poise of middle age.) This is what makes the youthful energy of Cê (translation: You) so unexpected. Produced by Caetanos son, Moreno, its a dignified, South American take on indie rock: dry production, farting bass lines, and a garage-y sonic nakedness that would shame Jack White. But theres also an unleashed sexuality (sample lyric: I only envy longevity/and multiple orgasms) and a shuffling rhythmic complexity absent from the music of more demure, melody-focused American indie rockers. Theres no standout track, and, honestly, some of its just bizarre (Rocks reminds me of the Strokes), but for late-career cojones (I know, Brazilians actually speak Portuguese), Cê is unmatched.
The Shins: Wincing the Night Away (Sub Pop): Unfortunately, the Shins newest rates no better than a solid B. Bandleader James Mercers distinctive melodic gifts remain intact, but therein lies the problem. Try as they might to build upon their well-honed formula, their experiments mostly fail (e.g., a short fuzz-bomb Pam Berry; the Morrissey-meets-trip-hop of Sea Legs). More interesting are smaller efforts at tweaking their sound the bleeps and bloops of Red Rabbits; the lyrical clarity of Turn on Me; the modern rock-radio feel of Split Needles. But even those arent entirely successful. The album goes down smooth, which is to say, it doesnt really stick with you like their earlier material or, for that matter, other key records in the yindie canon Postal Services Give Up, Death Cab for Cuties Plans, Iron & Wines Our Endless Numbered Days, Sufjan Stevens Illinois.
The music business has fun with problems: The most impressive thing about the Shins new album was its blockbuster first-week sales 119,000 copies, an indicator that todays indie renaissance runs deeper than previously thought. More profoundly, it showed that Mainstream Popular Culture is no longer quite so mainstream. In the weeks before the Shins debut, the Dreamgirls soundtrack sat atop the charts, but its weekly sales hovered at around 60,000 the lowest for a No. 1 album in the SoundScan era (1991 to present). In our fractured moment, indie hype and props in a Natalie Portman movie (Garden State) carry more influence than Oscar buzz.
But Dreamgirls sales demonstrate a deeper phenomenon. At press time, sales in January and February are down 15 percent from the same period last year. It's a precipitous drop compared to the single-digit declines of recent years, and it now appears that physical sales are truly beginning their death spiral. Blame the iPod: Apple sold 22 million of them in 2005, 39 million in 2006 an increase of about 75 percent. Add in the 21 million sold over the holidays and it would appear consumers kicked off 2007 by trying to fill their new devices then quickly discovered that ripping individual CDs is like trying to drink the ocean with a straw. Downloading songs or borrowing a friends hard drive simply works better.
Apple CEO Steve Jobs heightened this tempestuous climate by posting his Thoughts on Music on his companys Web site. In the memo, he essentially blames the major labels for iTunes proprietary file format, a system thats been subject to recent legal challenges in both France and Norway. Jobs manifesto positions itself as a reformatory tract in the tradition of Martin Luthers 95 Theses or MLK Jr.s Letter From Birmingham Jail. Only, you know, hes talking about how Apple is going to make buttloads of money.
Ill readily champion Jobs as the only visionary effectively tackling the music/technology conundrum, but his open letter is clearly insincere. Presented as a populist manifesto for open standards, his thoughts are actually a strategic document single-handedly parrying Apples European legal challenges, dismissing the possibility of Apple sharing its digital rights management system with competitors, and putting more stress on already embattled major labels. Nice move, Steve, but kind of sneaky.
The Death of Rock Criticism: Music critics havent been tastemakers for a long time, and what relevance they do have now seems destined to fade entirely (a point Ive been making since 2002). For more proof, note the recent jousting match between two year-end critics polls The Village Voices long-running Pazz & Jop and Gawker Medias derivative and lamely named Jackin Pop. Each poll had a similar number of voters (around 500) and a similar number of voters exclusive to each poll (around 300). Even though Pazz & Jop skewed slightly older and more traditional, eight of the same artists were featured in each polls individual Top 10 list for both singles and albums. This critical alignment tells us that consensus reigns like never before, and that critics picks are largely determined by forces they dont acknowledge (blogs, radio, other critics) or understand (advertising and marketing campaigns). Personally, I didnt bother creating a Top 10 this year, and didnt submit to either poll. I urge others to join me not so much in protest, but to point out that the value of criticism is explanatory, not masturbatory or competitive.
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene with music features, additional online music listings and show picks. We'll also send special ticket offers and music promotions available only to our Music Newsletter subscribers.