If Your Band Sucks, a Manager Isn't Going to Help
Are you a musician? Is your group having issues? Ask Fan Landers! Critic Jessica Hopper has played in and managed bands, toured internationally, booked shows, produced records, worked as a publicist and is the author of The Girls' Guide to Rocking, a how-to for teen ladies. She is here to help you stop doing it wrong. Send your problems to her - confidentiality is assured, unless you want to use your drama as a ticket to Internet microfame.
Dear Fan Landers:
We've been a band and putting out music for just over two years now and have played a few received local gigs, but we're struggling with finding a way to take our band to the next level. We've all come to the conclusion that without some kind of representation - manager, booking, etc - our band's career will probably stagnate at the "lets play a show for 150 people in our hometown" level. Any advice that you have on trying to land a connected and dedicated manager or a booking guy that can actually get us some shows?
Most bands will be lucky to stagnate at that level, including yours. Sorry to start with the bad news.
One of the great myths of bandhood is that other people can just "make" things happen for you. You find the right "booking guy" (or gal) and suddenly your future is just handled or you have a manager who cashes in favors because they believe in you and there is a sudden, bountiful 15% to cut them in on. And it's just a matter of the right person seeing your band at the right time and then it all falls together.
The myth of management or other people working for you is that it will automatically translate into "results". But any publicist or manager can tell you there is little they can make happen if people are not inherently interested in your band, and if your band lacks the ability to attract people's attention.
Your band is what makes the whole thing go, not third party connections and gladhanding. Something you see a lot of in the music industry is a band done in by chasing this elusive idea: first they just need a manager and when that manager doesn't catapult them into a deal and line their pockets with money, they urgently need a more high powered manager or one that understands them better. Then all they need is that manager and a booking agent, or all these people and publicist and a label with a street marketing team. They are no longer holding themselves accountable. They are no longer focused on their music. They are focused on intangible metrics and living in the future, living for some version of the band being "easy" or "not a hassle" when that is basically all a band is.
Like the saying goes: The obstacle is the path. The work of being a band and the quality of how you connect with people through your music is success, not the achievement.
Before you seek out the manager of your stardust dreams, try doing everything that you'd want them to do for you - but for yourselves and on your own terms. Book a national tour. Get friendly with promoters. Send your local rock critic an edible arrangement. See if you can prove on your own. At the very least, it makes you a more appealing prospect for handlers.
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene each week with music news, trends, artist interviews and concert listings. We'll also send you special ticket offers and music deals.