Does Sugar Ray Actually Suck?

Bethany Cosentino at California's Wax Ltd Studios
Bethany Cosentino at California's Wax Ltd Studios
Courtesy of the Artist

Bethany Cosentino of Best Coast writes sunny indie-pop that traditionally has drawn from bands like Fleetwood Mac and the Beach Boys. Right now, however, she's feeling inspiration from a more unlikely source. 

"As cool as I want everybody to think I am, I don't care: I think Sugar Ray has written some really great songs," said Cosentino, in a recent interview with Spin

Sure, Newport Beach's own Sugar Ray is mostly remembered for popularizing frosted tips with chin goatees, and making aggressive gestures next to swimming pools. (That and their dopey 1997 smash hit "Fly.")

But you know what? We respect Cosentino, and therefore decided to dig deep into the Sugar Ray catalog. Here, then, are their five best songs. 

5. "Answer the Phone"
After the lame Creed-tinged intro, "Answer the Phone" has a nice pop-punk flavor that could be confused for another Best Coast influence: Blink 182. The roaring chorus is catchy, and, hey, the song also mentions roller coasters, which is never a bad thing. Maybe Cosentino's onto something!

4. "Mean Machine" 
This one is different! It's one of Sugar Ray's "hardest" songs, and includes a Mick Mars-influenced guitar intro. So that's something!  

3. "Under the Sun" 
Hmmmmm. The more we listen to this one, the more we can't recommend it. Sorry. Let's see if we can find a number two. 

Sugar Ray in 1999EXPAND
Sugar Ray in 1999
Promotional Poster


...OK, sorry, we're letting you down here. We can't find a number two either. We thought about maybe "RPM" but that's a gawdawful abortion. 

1. Bethany what were you thinking? 

Well, at least she explicitly denies that we have anything to fear on the next Best Coast album. "The record is not going to sound like a Sugar Ray record," she said in the Spin interview. "But it's definitely something we were talking about a lot while we were in the studio."

Like us on Facebook at LAWeeklyMusic

The 20 Worst Hipster Bands
The 20 Worst Bands of All Time
Top 10 Awkward Coachella Dance Move GIFs

Sponsor Content


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >