Dodger Divorce: Despite What Bill Plaschke Says, It's Too Soon To Celebrate | The Informer | Los Angeles | Los Angeles News and Events | LA Weekly
Food & Sports

Dodger Divorce: Despite What Bill Plaschke Says, It's Too Soon To Celebrate

Comments (0)


Thu, Dec 16, 2010 at 1:27 PM

click to enlarge Frank McCourt will cling the Dodgers with every legal argument at his disposal.
  • Frank McCourt will cling the Dodgers with every legal argument at his disposal.
There was much rejoicing over last week's ruling in the McCourt divorce case, which made it more likely that the Dodgers will be put up for sale. Bill Plaschke started rounding the bases. T.J. Simers wanted to put a statue of Judge Scott Gordon outside Dodger Stadium.

Hate to be a grinch about it, but the celebration is premature. In the words of, Frank McCourt is not dead yet.

Consider the following timeline of events, which nobody has paid the slightest attention to before now, but which will loom large in the next phase of the Dodger divorce proceedings.

June 9, 1977: Frank McCourt, a single man, incorporates the McCourt Company in Delaware. He is the sole stockholder.
Sept. 15, 1977: Frank McCourt incorporates Broderick Properties, Inc., a subsidiary of the McCourt Company, in Delaware.
March 10, 1978: Broderick Properties, Inc., signs an option to buy 24 acres of Boston waterfront land from the Penn Central Railroad.
Nov. 3, 1979: Frank and Jamie McCourt get married.
So why is this important? For the moment, the Dodgers are presumed to be community property. That's to say, unless Frank proves otherwise, the team will be split 50/50.

To keep that from happening, Frank will have to go to court with some evidence that the team was acquired with "separate" funds that predate the marriage. This process, called "tracing," will entail a lot of forensic accounting, which will be costly and time consuming. (He can afford it.)

Boiled down, the argument will look like the above timeline. Frank will contend that the Dodgers were acquired by the McCourt Company with funds secured by the Boston waterfront land. Since both the waterfront land and the McCourt Company predate the marriage, the Dodgers should be considered his separate property. (The story of how Frank acquired the waterfront land is much more complicated than it's presented here. If you want to read more about that, check out this July cover story.)

If you look back at Jamie's divorce pleadings, she has already begun to rebut this argument. She writes:
When Frank and I married we were young and had no significant assets. Everything we own today we built together during our long marriage. Indeed, I gave Frank the first $1,000 to start up his first company.
Who knows if any of that is true. But, barring a settlement, you can see where this is headed: back to Boston, and back to the late 70s.

(Incidentally, Frank's side says you don't have to get into all this because the title to the Dodgers is in Frank's name. Whether you find that persuasive or not, that's their argument.)

To be clear, Jamie certainly has the upper hand in the next round. The community property presumption is in her favor. But that's no guarantee of anything, especially in light of that timeline. Absent a granular understanding of how the McCourts financed their business over 20-plus years, it's simply impossible to predict how this will end.

So for now, Plaschke and Simers should keep their champagne in reserve.

Related Content

Now Trending

  • DUI Checkpoints Come to Hollywood, Echo Park This Weekend

    Fall DUI checkpoints have returned to Los Angeles with a vengeance. With Halloween approaching, don't get spooked by that black-and-white in your rear-view. You better drive sober, or not at all, the Los Angeles Police Department warns. To that end, the LAPD wants you to know that its officers will...
  • 1 in 4 Californians Is Straight-Up Poor, Feds Say

    We recently told you that California is America's "richest state," which is true. Now we're telling you that, for the third year in a row, California has been named as America's poorest state. That's also true. See also: California Is America's Richest State How can both statements be accurate? Well, unfortunately,...
  • Dorian Nakamoto Is Crowdfunding His Fight Over Newsweek's Bitcoin Article

    Almost as soon as it appeared, a March Newsweek article that called L.A's own Dorian "Satoshi" Nakamoto "The Face Behind Bitcoin," faced questions about its veracity. See also: Language Doesn't Point to L.A.'s Satoshi Nakamoto as Bitcoin Inventor Chief among the critics was Nakamoto, who said the piece was downright wrong:...
Los Angeles Concert Tickets