Truth and Beauty
|Photo by Will Hart|
The series was clearly not made to please anyone. It is not pleasant, though its sometimes funny. Its often hard to watch, and yet its just as hard to look away not from morbid fascination but rather from a sort of awakened brotherly curiosity. Directed with a sure, never-heavy hand by actor Charles S. Dutton and adapted by David Mills and David Simon from a book Simon co-authored with ex-cop Edward Burns (Simon also wrote the book that inspired Homicide: Life on the Street), the series dramatizes the intertwining true stories of Gary McCullough, Fran Boyd and their teenage son DeAndre (T.K. Carter, Khandi Alexander of NewsRadio fame and Sean Nelson, respectively), with plenty of attention paid to a host of other characters who stumble, stride or sashay through their lives. (None of the actors, of whom mention must also be made of Toy Connor, Tasha Smith, Clarke Peters, Tyra Ferrell and Glenn Plummer, are any less than remarkable.) They steal, lie, cheat, shoot drugs, snort drugs, smoke drugs, sell drugs, shoot guns, skip school and break faith, and yet they are even at their worst sympathetic, because The Corner takes the time to show them at their best and all the stops in between. It is not in a hurry; it lets you hang. Time is the great luxury of television The Corner runs about as long as the first two Godfather films combined albeit a luxury largely squandered on material whose substance may be grasped entire by the first commercial break.
That Fran and Garys story in broad terms resembles The Days of Wine and Roses may be excused, since it actually happened that way, but Dutton, who grew up in the vicinity and knows his subject well, takes pains to avoid melodrama no underscoring, no fancy camera angles, goofy lenses or unnatural lighting and polemics. Certainly the series has a point of view you will likely not leave it wanting to run out and score some smack, and you may pay your taxes a little more graciously this year but it makes its case more by example than assertion. Shot in the documentary style reminiscent, not too surprisingly, of Homicide (which is not at all the nervous documentary style familiar from NYPD Blue), the series has the intimacy and pace and engaged repose of cinéma vérité; its slow and somewhat repetitious and, in the Hollywood sense of things, uneventful. When they are not hurrying through the frame looking for junk or money or something to steal or stealing something or making a stab at keeping a job and keeping straight, the characters take it slow. They lounge. They shoot the shit. They shoot hoops. They shoot up. Working the open-air drug markets that dot the neighborhood intersections is largely a matter of standing around, and when the cops show up, its a matter of standing around with legs spread. When something bad something worse than the usual bad, that is happens, it happens fast and is over fast, and is likely as not glimpsed from a distance, as by a passerby. In the series one gun battle, the enemy is unseen and possibly imagined. Theres an almost pastoral quality to some scenes film tends to soften and prettify the ugliest, most broken-down subjects so long as the lights good and this is not entirely inappropriate, since even in the ghetto there are sometimes palmy days.
Yet the tension rarely lets up; and when it does, in the aerobic release of a dance party or the ordinary calm of a Thanksgiving dinner, its almost shocking. As for the fate of the characters themselves, as already written in real life by the characters themselves, well, change is usually a matter of increments, of last straws, and of often barely perceptible steps into or out of the mire, and the filmmakers have opted not to freight their drama with false fire and a big finish progress and regress is embodied here in the slightest adjustments of attitude, in the cock of a head, the focus of the eyes, the slope of a shoulder. None of it leads toward a resolution, because the story doesnt really end. Some of the players survive, some even thrive, but the corner is still there.
As things stand, The Corner could only have been made in the unbeholden realm of noncommercial premium cable the money you pay to watch HBO or Showtime indemnifies the network against your possible outrage. (A public broadcasting system less subject to the bluster of partisan windbags might have produced something like this, but we dont have one of those here.) MTV, which runs ads, pitches itself to kids and comes gratis with most cable subscriptions, doesnt operate with quite that freedom, but its advertisers are far less likely than the family-car and baby-powder manufacturers of America to object to unconventional content indeed, theyre paying to share in the networks aura of jiggy-with-it youthcult edginess and as a result things over there sometimes can get a little out of hand. Freedom has its downside.
All that MTV hath wrought in terms of audio-visual overexcitement and adolescent mind control has been applied to its second made-for-TV movie, Jailbait!, in which a dimwitted 18-year-old high school jock senior (Kevin Mundy) is put on trial for having sex, lots of sex, with a not significantly brighter 15-year-old trailer-trash sophomore (Alycia Purrott). Though described as a satire, it is essentially a Britney Spears video stretched to feature length, to similar soft-porn effect; directed by Allan Moyle (Empire Records, Pump Up the Volume) to reflect the house style, its all fancy camera angles, goofy lenses and a big-rock soundtrack Blink-182, Sugar Ray, Bush and their like to be issued on CD, naturally, in yet another display of the fearful synergy that increasingly deforms the content of our media. That MTV is also airing a video promoting a song from that compilation (All My Fault by the band Fenix TX) featuring Purrott and clips from the film should not surprise you. (Kurt Cobain is so very dead.)
Satire, says my dictionary, means trenchant wit, irony, or sarcasm used to expose and discredit vice or folly, but setting aside the films near-total lack of trenchant or any other sort of wit and its failure to marshal more than a handful of tired stereotypes and straw villains even the networks own related Web page admits the unlikeliness of the courtroom scenario its never really clear what if anything is being satirized (apart from the media, again). If it means to question age-of-consent laws, it does a good job of undermining its case: These are poster children for chastity belts, for castration. Occasionally, as in a zany trying-to-induce-abortion sequence (the girl gets pregnant, twice), the picture seems to me frankly irresponsible, and more especially so in light of the proficiency with which it has been shot and edited. As with a wink it pats its hump-mad leads on the head and sends them off into a happy ending, the picture ultimately reads as a defense of MTV itself, its sexualized aesthetic, and its audience, which no doubt includes more than a few deflowered 15-year-olds, and many many more whod like to be. Who hasnt screwed a sophomore? someone rhetorically asks.
Oh shut up, I rhetorically reply.
THE CORNER | HBO | Premieres Sunday, April 16, 10 p.m.
JAILBAIT | MTV | Premieres Sunday, April 16, 9 p.m.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.