In Christopher Nolans fiendishly clever thriller, Memento, a young man named Leonard Shelby (played by the Anglo-Australian actor Guy Pearce, who cut his American teeth as the ambitious young police detective in L.A. Confidential) suffers from a short-term memory deficit severe enough to reduce to embarrassed silence any and all graying boomers who bray about no longer being able to put a name to a face. Not only can Leonard not remember the names of people hes just met, he cant recall having met them at all, or for that matter anything that happened earlier than a few minutes ago. Leonard wouldnt know a close friend from a chance acquaintance, which makes him terrifyingly dependent on the ambiguous kindness of strangers, two of whom -- a friendly barmaid called Natalie (The Matrixs Carrie-Anne Moss) and a nervously jovial fellow named either Teddy or John (Joe Pantoliano, of same) -- appear to be vying to help him avenge himself on the unknown enemy who raped and murdered his wife and left him with the head injury that brought on his condition.
On one level, Memento, which Nolan (whose second outing this is after making a funky little indie in 1998 called Following) adapted from a short story by his brother Jonathan, is an audacious murder mystery that rests on a neat inversion of the amnesia formula that has propped up so many films noirs. Where your average movie amnesiac has lost his past but creates a new self while waiting to recover it, Leonard remembers, or says he does, every detail of his past up until the trauma. He has an old self -- which he relates in periodic black-and-white sequences to an unknown listener on the phone, and which has an eerie relevance to his current predicament -- but cant make a new one. Incapable of creating or sustaining new memories, hes left without the tools to groom a more or less viable identity, of the kind that allows most of us to get through the day without succumbing to gibbering paranoia.
Like anyone who finds himself overwhelmed by indeterminacy, Leonard is desperate to establish hard facts. He takes Polaroids and writes endless Post-its to remind himself of whom he meets and the name of the dingy motel where hes staying, and swears by cryptic messages he finds tattooed onto his body in his own handwriting. But without knowledge or a basis for trusting others, he has to gamble on instinct, which may, Nolan implies, be as unreliable as memory. Leonard has to work overtime just to run in place -- exhausting for him, but enormous fun for his creator. While Memento may bear the marks of the usual noir obsessions with alienation and mistrust, conceptually the movie has more in common with Harold Ramis Groundhog Day than it has with Alfred Hitchcocks Spellbound. And though Leonard doesnt have the implacable routine of Bill Murrays endlessly repeated day to order his existence, he, too, is marooned in an eternal present -- and Nolan gleefully maroons us right there with him. To those of us with a Dorian Gray complex, this may sound like a peak experience, but its maliciously replete with diffuse anxiety. For most of this exquisitely structured disquisition on the unstructured life, were kept as much in the dark about Leonards true identity, and those of his adversaries, as he is. It takes a while to realize that Nolan has his way of feeding us a meta-story, not necessarily in the right order.
In common with many committed stylists, Nolan has trouble getting you to care about his characters. (It seems no accident that two of his actors are cast from The Matrix, a frigid formal exercise if ever there was.) Theres a flashback in the movie in which Nolan clearly means to cement our sympathy for the trap in which Leonard, or someone very like him, finds himself. But then the ball is immediately dropped in favor of mere flash artistry. Without Pearces taut, radiant presence to project the pathos -- and the euphoria -- of a man hanging on to coherence moment by nerveless moment, Memento would leave you emotionally dry as a bone. Still, for the philosophically inclined, I doubt whether anyone -- even in the glory days of film noir -- could have come up with a tale as vertiginously relativistic as this one. If nothing else, Memento is a savvy comment on the queasy uncertainties of the postmodern condition, in which history goes no further back than yesterdays news, and knowledge is supplanted by information from a tumult of spin-controlled, unreliable narrators.
Like Leonard, the young heroine -- if such can be called a woman whos capable of killing a policeman over a traffic violation -- in Volker Schlondorffs The Legend of Rita has to reinvent herself over and over. Only its not her biochemistry thats out of sync, but the divided soul of postwar Germany after the Berlin Wall went up. Schlondorff means to probe that schism through the rise and fall of the West German anarchist group RAF. The groups subsidiary -- known outside Germany as the Baader-Meinhof gang -- managed to get in a whole lot of ideologically motivated carnage, much of it devolving upon innocent bystanders, before becoming the property of the East German intelligence agency Stasi, which tried simultaneously to disband the group and shelter those of its members who were left standing.
The first half-hour of The Legend of Rita is parsed as an action movie. Though Im not at all sure that the actual Baader-Meinhof gang could have burst into a bank yelling, Down with capitalism! and Venceremos! without drawing giggles all round from the tellers, the dialogue here is, like much of Schlondorff and Wolfgang Kohlhaases screenplay, a thrifty piece of shorthand designed to give you the drift of the groups intellectual influences. Thereafter the film veers sharply away from politics, a baffling departure for the director of The Lost Honor of Katharina Blum (1975) and The Tin Drum (1979). A strong case could be made that the RAF, for all its vaunted anti-Nazism and advocacy of the working class, was in important respects a continuation of German absolutism by other means. In The Legend of Rita, Schlondorff approaches his material with the gingerly timidity of a man who cant fully commit to a shift in his views on that branch of the German left. Instead, he opts to put the proverbial human face on terrorism by telling the story of one of its members, a composite figure, presumably, called Rita Vogt (Bibiana Beglau), who senses the groups imminent collapse and, under the wing of a sympathetic Stasi apparatchik (Martin Wuttke), disappears into a new life as an upstanding East German proletarian.
The movies eye-poppingly reductive, not to say condescending, thesis is that Rita is a tender, vulnerable soul who does whatever she does -- from joining the group through an affair with its leader, to saving the bruised soul of a fellow worker at the East German factory where she works -- for love. In fact, Rita seems to do little but fall in love, not least with the German Democratic Republic, where, amazingly, she fails to notice that just about everyone but she and her handler wants out of the dreary parsimony of life behind the Iron Curtain. The story of Ritas successive incarnations as an enthusiastic Communist, and her fall, symbolically timed to coincide with the fall of the Wall, is absorbing enough, due in large measure to Beglaus vibrant performance. Yet Rita seems to be a woman with little noticeable inner life, and absolutely no capacity for reflection on her deeply compromised past activities. So much so that you begin to feel that youre watching some earnest television drama more properly named I Was a Terrorist Love Junkie: The Rita Vogt Story.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.
More Film News
- I Never Liked the National Lampoon's Vacation Series, and This New Version Is...
- Five Reasons to Enter the Silly, Sad World of Netflix's BoJack Horseman
- You Will Learn Exactly Three New Things From the Chris Farley Documentary
- Jason Segel Had His Book Club Read Infinite Jest Without Telling Them He Was...