The Betrayal (Nerakhoon): Scenes From a Parallel Life
Some 23 years in the making, cinematographer Ellen Kuras’ first film as a director is a portrait of Laotian refugee Thavisouk Phrasavath. The Betrayal (Nerakhoon) is also a haunting flashback to the lush green and fiery orange phantasmagoria of wartime Indochina. The son of a Laotian army officer, and a baby when the first U.S. advisers arrived in neighboring South Vietnam, Phrasavath grew up in the zone: “I thought killing and dying was only a normal thing.” (He’s first seen as a tough-looking kid with shoulder-length hair and a dragon tattoo.) Phrasavath escaped Laos by himself at 12, swimming across the Mekong to Thailand, where he lived for two years on the streets of Bangkok, until his mother and siblings joined him. Long one of the independent film movement’s leading cinematographers, Kuras had yet to shoot anything, when she discovered Phrasavath and his family living in a Brooklyn housing project and embarked upon their epic collaboration. (Her subject is credited as co-director, co-writer and editor.)
Although she documented Phrasavath’s life for more than two decades, Kuras seems particularly fascinated by things that could not be filmed directly. The Betrayal eschews straightforward chronology, incorporating photographs of colonial Laos, TV footage of JFK, newsreels of the Ho Chi Minh Trail, bombs falling, towns burning and clips from a Pathet Lao propaganda movie, as well as incidents from Phrasavath’s subsequent return to his birthplace. The mode is free-associative, but the movie’s blunt, accusatory title fits multiple periods of its subject’s life. He was abandoned by his protectors (“The U.S. just left in the middle of the war”), by his liberators (Pathet Lao’s victory was “a beautiful moment,” with music everywhere, until his father was arrested), by the relief agency that brought his family to the U.S., and by his father, who reappeared after 15 years, before, as Phrasavath puts it, “our heart was broken again.”
The Betrayal is refined, even delicate, filmmaking. Continuous destruction is accompanied by continual string music. Subtly off-speed and suffused with late-afternoon light, the movie weaves through time. Which is the dream, America or Laos? The landscape is typically onrushing — Kuras often shoots from cars or trains — and Buddhist ceremonies add to the free-floating displacement. Life seems a blur. Impressionistic and lyrical, as well as somber and gripping, The Betrayal conveys a ceaseless flow. It’s as if the filmmaker has opened a window onto a parallel world traveling beside our own. (Music Hall)
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.