Shrek the Flatulent
Coming out of Shrek the Third, I asked the two smart preteen girls I had in tow what they had liked about the picture. Projectile vomiting and multiple farts, they said promptly: Best Shrek ever. Ordinarily Im not big on poop and flatulence, but in this instance I sympathized theres not much else to get excited about in this gaseous, overstuffed, prime case of sequel fatigue. Kids have all kinds of capacities, and you can either aim low or you can tell them a story, even several stories, as most movies for kids do these days, and as the first two in the Shrek franchise did with charm and wit. I loved them both, even though Shrek 2 was so anxiously freighted with grown-up cultural references and in-jokes, it scarcely seemed like a kids movie at all.
Hes back, and smelly from head to toe. (DreamWorks Animation LLC)
Shrek the Third
is directed by Chris Miller and co-written by Miller with three other writers (bad sign) from a story by Andrew Adamson, who helmed the first two movies. Miller was in charge of story onShrek 2
, but I see no story at all here, unless you count a few haggard plotlines limping along on parallel tracks and colliding by dint of artless intercutting. As for our stinky hero, he grows flabbier by the sequel. For all their good nature, the first twoShrek
s had real bite, and Mike Myers brought a fine crankiness to the green Glaswegian. But let it be remembered that this softhearted fellow began life as the fiercely unlovable, strictly noncuddly creation of childrens writer William Steig, and though he ended up falling in love with an ogress every bit as repulsive as he, one thing the career misanthrope never got over was his profound antipathy for children. Well, forget that: Nothing more hateful than rote paternal ambivalence, culled from many a current Alternadad memoir, is on display inShrek the Third
, where we find our hero reeling not only from the death of his froggy father-in-law (and the prospect of running the kingdom of Far Far Away in his stead) but the news that the lovely Fiona is great with child.
What to do in the face of such crisis but take to the road with the usual small circle of friends (Donkey and Puss-in-Boots are back, with what little charisma this charmless movie can muster) and muscle through the action sequences while tending to a new character designed to pry the middle-school demographic loose from its iPods? I doubt it will work, even with Justin Timberlake voicing the nerdy youth whom Shrek wants to put on the throne in place of his socially retarded self. A feeble father-son dynamic ensues as the two sit by a campfire and swap tales of their own bad dads, before rousing themselves to self-help against the usurper Prince Charming, with the aid of the usual round of gingerbread men and wooden boys, plus a few new fairy-tale staples. The movie wakes up briefly when a posse of Disney princesses turn feminist toxic avengers. For the rest, when Shrek the Third isnt drowning in psychobabble, its disfigured by atonal nastiness the death of King Harold, a flawed hero very dear to the hearts of the movies youngest viewers, is handled as farce in place of the off-the-cuff gay wit that kept Shreks I and II pulsing along.
Bolstered by its fart jokes, mass marketing and a flood of tie-ins, Shrek the Third will surely take in its usual bundle at the international box office. But that doesnt make the movie an artistic success, even with millions worth of up-to-the-minute animation. Like many another shoddy sequel, this one founders not only on the difficulty of extending a franchise beyond its natural life but on the unbearable strain of juggling a bunch of target demographics at once. Blinded by avarice and all out of ideas, once again Hollywood cant tell when enough is way more than enough.
SHREK THE THIRD | Directed by CHRIS MILLER | Written by JEFFREY PRICE, PETER S. SEAMAN, MILLER and ARON WARNER, from a story by ANDREW ADAMSON | Produced by WARNER | Citywide
Question or comment? Email firstname.lastname@example.org
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.