All the basic ingredients of director Ang Lees understated 1994 domestic comedy, Eat, Drink, Man, Woman -- a family in generational flux, the culinary rituals that help hold it together and a four-course love story -- have made it into director Maria Ripolls remake, Tortilla Soup. Ripoll and writers Tom Musca, Ramon Menendez and Vera Blasi have added a few touches of their own: Theyve shifted the setting from Taipei to East Los Angeles, and the films all-important cuisine is now Latin-American rather than Cantonese. But almost everything else -- plot, dialogue, visual style -- has been lifted wholesale, and the result is about as appetizing as microwave flan.
As in the original film, the story revolves around a widowed master chef (Hector Elizondo) who commands his three live-at-home daughters (Jacqueline Obradors, Elizabeth Peña and Tamara Mello) to regular Sunday dinners. Always a riot of intoxicating dishes -- cactus salad, suckling pig, tortilla soup -- these family get-togethers invariably descend into a riot of domestic chaos as each of the daughters seizes the moment to assert her defiance of Dad. All in turn have decided its time for career, for love, to see the world or just to leave the nest. In the films single underplayed comic touch, Ripoll (as did Lee) pays lingering, sensuous attention to the fathers preparation of the bountiful Sunday menus, only here the familys discord keeps anyone from actually finishing a meal.
Ripoll takes a fast-food approach with hardly a sweet or sour moment. Her film runs faster than Lees two hours, but Ripoll hasnt trimmed the storys fat; shes just cut out its heart. Within minutes of Tortilla Soups first dinner-table flare-up, after Carmen (Obradors) announces shes moving out, the sisters are playfully dancing in the kitchen as if the familys stability hadnt just been shaken to the core. Its a reconciliation which, for all its good cheer, plays false. Ripoll wants us to take these characters seriously, but never puts anything on the line. It is, however, Tortilla Soups cultural transposition that feels most phony. Where Lee brings depth and subtle observation to his middle-class ensemble piece, Ripoll has simply added a thin Latino glaze. (Appropriately, the food is by acclaimed celebrity chefs Mary Sue Milliken and Susan Feniger.) She whets the bland appetites of the art-house audience with a little cultural spice, but has forgotten to add the soul.
A family at the crossroads is also at the center of director Syd Macartneys A Love Divided, only the roads dont meet over the dinner table but in an ideological minefield. Set in rural Ireland in 1957, this BBC production tells the real-life story of Sheila Cloney (Orla Brady), a Protestant woman in a mixed marriage who defied her husband (Liam Cunningham) and the Catholic Church when she refused to send her children to a Catholic school. After threats from her local priest (Tony Doyle), she fled the country, children in tow, and touched off a sectarian firestorm that quickly engulfed the nation. Brady narrates all this in a voice-over that lets us in on Sheilas overwhelming fear and isolation. Unfortunately, hers is the only fully drawn character in a film in which every other character is a brute or a victim (with Sheilas husband wavering between the two), in an all-too-familiar world of intolerance, mob violence and religious hypocrisy. In the end, Macartney and screenwriter Stuart Hepburn decide that love conquers all, which may have been the way it happened but doesnt leave the film with much going on.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.