Its the Gospel Half-Truth
|Photo by Alfeo Dixon|
Its official: The Chitlin Circuit, that modern road show of gospel plays made by black people for black people, has gone mainstream. Writer-producer Tyler Perrys Diary of a Mad Black Woman opens in movie theaters Friday, though it remains to be seen whether the niche audience that supports the live shows will also support a multiplex version, and whether that audience will broaden.
Not that that matters very much to the filmmakers: This is a movie so squarely aimed at the Christian converted, so obvious in its black family-values propaganda, its creators may not care a whit about what secular audiences or a secularist critic might think.
Broad as the side of a barn, Diary tells the story of Stepford-wife Helen (The Manchurian Candidates Kimberly Elise), married to a successful and obscenely wealthy lawyer, Charles (Steve Harris). They live uneventfully together in a marbled mansion the size of the Louvre until, on their 18th wedding anniversary, Charles abruptly announces hes done with the marriage. After introducing his stricken wife to his light-skinned vixen of a mistress, he pushes Helen out of his life and, literally, out of the house. Left with little more than the clothes on her back, Helen becomes a pilgrim in search of all those meaningful things she thought shed had all along but didnt self-esteem, family, faith, the love of a good, God-fearing man who can truly see her for herself. You know, the things that money cant buy. Along the way, she re-discovers her roots in the black ghetto (and this ones actually pretty nice, as ghettos go), nixes her complicated hairdo in favor of more down-home, ethnically correct curls, and takes an honest job as a waitress. All of this soul-searching pays off in a big exclamation-point kind of way, and while characters get exactly the redemption, or the damnation, they deserve.
Perry has made millions bringing stuff like this to live theaters across the country, a fact that at least challenges dismissals of Diary and its ilk as merely formulaic. Yes, the script is deadeningly literal. Yes, it traffics freely in stereotypes: the good wife, the pathetic crack addict, the evil drug dealer and, of course, the irascible, gun-wielding matriarch/grandma, played to hilarious effect by Perry himself, whose outrageous image is being heavily marketed to sell the film to moviegoers more interested in straight-up comedy than in sermons.
Which makes Diary not so different from hordes of other black films in the hip-hop age that are just as standardized, though often in the opposite way, as dark, violent tales from the hood. Diary is an antidote to all that. Like all gospel plays, its outrageous, but clean. There is no bloodshed or gratuitous swearing. Unlike the denizens of the black ghettos most often portrayed, more or less pornographically, onscreen, Diarys people have real families, real hopes and aspirations. Here, spirituality and inner strength triumph over chaos. Even as I cringed at Diarys predictableness and deliberate unsubtlety, I was relieved to be watching a romance blossom between two black people who were both employed, articulate and matinee-idol pretty. The pathologies of poverty were there, but they didnt dominate. White people and the racial oppression and/or tension they invariably represent in black cinema were absent altogether. As I sat listening to Kimberly Elises earnest Dear Diary voice-overs, it occurred to me once more that real equality, at least in the realm of popular entertainment, may lie less with opportunities to be great than with opportunities to be mediocre.
Black people, in other words, have as much right to produce and enjoy Diary as whites have a right to produce and enjoy paint-by-numbers films with thin plots and happy endings, geared mostly toward profitability (case in point: The Wedding Date). Once we dont have to agonize about every black film meeting impossibly high standards, or stooping to abominably low expectations, we will have truly arrived. Tyler Perry, arguably and for all that his script reflects an increasing black trend toward apolitical, if moral, conservatism has staked out this rare middle ground.
DIARY OF A MAD BLACK WOMAN | Directed by DARREN GRANT | Written by TYLER PERRY | Produced by PERRY and REUBEN CANNON | Released by Lions Gate Studios | At selected theaters
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you’ll never miss LA Weekly's biggest stories.