Garry Marshall, Risible Genius
Garry Marshall gives you what you came for. "A dollar's work for a dollar's pay," is how Marshall mainstay Hector Elizondo puts it in The Flamingo Kid. Although he started as a TV joke writer alongside Mel Brooks and Woody Allen, this 77-year-old Bronx baby never blossomed into an auteur or ideas man, even if he has been a brand name since Happy Days became a national institution in the mid-1970s.
Director of such massive crowd-pleasers as Beaches and Pretty Woman, Marshall's an entertainer of the old school, still plugging away in Hollywood, hitting his marks and making the audience laugh or cry on cue. There's an economy to his filmmaking (Beaches is one lean, mean emotion machine ... ), but also a vacancy ( ... with a sole purpose of making you weep when Bette Midler sings "Wind Beneath My Wings"). Which made him the ideal helmsman for last year's Valentine's Day and this week's New Year's Eve, stunt-cast films that fulfill the promise of their posters and cram too many movie stars into too tight a space.
Watching Marshall's late-career movies is like watching a jigsaw puzzle snap together, one cameo at a time. In that spirit, let's take a look at the pieces that make up a Garry Marshall movie.
Rich Man, Poor Man
Overboard, in which a carpenter (Kurt Russell) makes a rich bitch suffering from amnesia (Goldie Hawn) into his personal slave, is uncommonly crass for a Marshall movie, but its exaggeration of upper-class entitlement has echoes in everything from Pretty Woman to The Princess Diaries. Every polo pitch, country club, tennis court, luxury yacht or marble-floored mansion is subject to fish-eyed ridicule and populated by people who learned diction from Mr. Belvedere. Conversely, Marshall makes a working-class hero of anyone with a union card. Elizondo, who has collected a check for every Marshall joint to date, often serves as the film's blue-collar conscience, whether he's playing a benevolent hotel manager in Pretty Woman, a Slavic postal worker in Dear God or a straight-talking limo driver in The Princess Diaries. (My favorite is the outlier: his turn as a cross-dressing gangster in Young Doctors in Love.) Yet Marshall's films always manage to reinforce the status quo, appreciating professionalism but not ambition (the latter's a bitter epithet in Beaches) and pitting career against family (Nothing in Common, Raising Helen). Excellence can be admired in small doses, but relatability is always paramount. (We're drawn to Juliette Lewis' innocent, unpretentious Carla in The Other Sister, not Diane Keaton's tony, judgmental mom, and feel our allegiance shift the moment Bette Midler moves into a fancy apartment in Beaches.) It's like he has read our middle-American minds.
Life Is a Fairy Tale
Several of Marshall's movies have riffed on the fairy-tale form — Anne Hathaway is a worthy protégée of a regal Julie Andrews in The Princess Diaries, and Julia Roberts is more commitment-phobic prince than princess in Runaway Bride — but none as fascinatingly as Pretty Woman. A modern mash-up of Cinderella and Pygmalion, the film is most compelling as a fantasy of Los Angeles, where Beverly Hills and the Sunset Strip represent mirror opposites of the same dream. But first there's the pickup. Atypical for a filmmaker who likes to hustle between hot spots (character and scene development be damned), the opening scene of Pretty Woman progresses unhurriedly, letting its actors acclimate themselves to each other (and us) in what seems like real time (30 minutes — a quarter of the film's running time). The fairy tale begins the morning after, when Richard Gere's morose business tycoon makes Roberts' streetwalker a princely offer but not before she services him while chewing gum and watching I Love Lucy. (Have I mentioned that Disney bankrolled this film?) Of course, the sexual politics are dicey, but between its oddly frank first act and two charismatic lead performances, it's actually pretty marvelous.
Thou Shalt Be Moved
Marshall's not much of a visual stylist, nor is he a particularly fluid storyteller; he's too eager to get to the really sappy stuff to enjoy the telling (in Beaches, Bette Midler meets, courts and leaves Spalding Gray in less than three screen minutes; in New Year's Eve, Marshall shaves Sarah Jessica Parker's climactic rendezvous down to about 12 seconds). But he will make you feel something. Whether it's when Julia Roberts shows up in that red dress, when Al Pacino, in Frankie and Johnny, lets out a tender orgasmic roar during sex, when Bradley Cooper reveals his secret in Valentine's Day or when a marching band plays a wedding at the end of the otherwise pandering The Other Sister, he will get to you, whether or not you trust, like or admit it. The hoarier Marshall's act becomes, the more his films feel like remnants of a lost form — risible, yes, but comforting.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.