Near the beginning of MTVs Be Heard: A Global Discussion With Colin Powell, a beaming Norwegian girl asked the secretary of state how he felt about representing a country perceived as the Satan of world politics. Powell leaned back slightly in his dark suit (his military bearing a bit softer than usual) and replied that he rejected her premise. He explained how the U.S. has fought for freedom all over the globe, how after World War II, it didnt claim Japan or Germany but helped those countries build themselves back up. The only land we ever asked for, he purred, was enough land to bury our dead.
Boy, is that man good. And as he cruised through tougher-than-usual questions about AIDS and Israel, al Qaeda and condoms (he freaked out Americas nitwit right by endorsing their use), I could only admire his fabled steadiness. Before September 11th, Powells cautious multilateralism had made him something of a wallflower in a Bush administration notorious for a foreign policy about as delicate as a Pamplona bull run. Time put him on the cover with the headline, Where Have You Gone, Colin Powell? Even after we began bombing Afghanistan, most public attention went not to the former head of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, but to rootin-tootin Donald Rumsfeld.
But Powell has a knack for outlasting flashier or more bellicose colleagues. He did so after the Gulf War, when people suddenly grasped that Stormin Norman Schwarzkopf was actually a glory-hogging gasbag. And hes doing so now. As Rummys cowboy outfit begins to fray -- revealing Dr. Strangelove, not John Wayne -- Powells charismatic calm once again has come to the forefront. He still doesnt fit comfortably into the administrations right-wing agenda, nor does he get to make the big foreign-policy decisions (though he surely deserves some credit for Americas measured response to the terror attacks). But faced with a world increasingly skeptical about the War on Terror, hes become the Bush teams best and most plausible mouthpiece -- not least because hes black.
Watching Powell offer the worlds teenagers an embodiment of the Bush administration far more sensible and humane than the real one, I remembered covering the 88 and 92 Democratic conventions when Jesse Jackson was trotted out to articulate the dreams and aspirations of a party that was about to betray them. As Jesse spoke, the crowd would whoop and weep and applaud -- he had the Omni swooning -- and then once the euphoria had died down, the convention would go about its business of nominating bloodless Michael Dukakis or Bill Clinton. For Jacksons power lived and died with his words. The party wanted his passion and biblical cadenzas, not him. (Curiously, Jacksons Paleo-Con counterpart is also black: Alan Keyes manic vim, loony smile and eyelash-batting flirtatiousness make him the most entertaining presidential hopeful in decades. If the Christian right had forgotten about color and voted its heart, he might well have been the Republican nominee. As it is, Keyes now merely leaps into the mosh pit of his talk show on MSNBC.)
Although black eloquence clearly appeals to white America, it carries far less clout than its visibility might lead you to think. Aside from Martin Luther King, who turned the streets into his power base, the African-Americans whove gained national power are those skillful at working behind the scenes: Condoleezza Rice, the late Commerce Secretary Ron Brown or silky presidential confidant (and corporate-board denizen) Vernon Jordan, whose career puts a sly spin on the term invisible man. Like them, Powell is a superb bureaucratic operator -- he thrived in both military and civilian organizations -- and has mastered addressing the public in a cool TV style. Not for him the rolling biblical sentences of Dr. King or Barbara Jordan; not for him the grinning snake-oil patter of Al Sharpton or J.C. Watts. No, with his quiet stolidness and enormous head, Powell has a gift for being reassuring. This, as much as his obvious intelligence, has taken him to the highest public office ever reached by an African-American. Hes trusted by the country -- you dont think hell blow up the world to prevent the axis of evil from doing it -- and by a Republican administration to whom hes proven as loyal a company man as Tiger Woods.
A classic bootstrapper, Powell exudes competence, decency, discretion. And he provides racial cover for an administration not exactly hailed for caring about people of color, inside or outside our borders. Can you picture Dick Cheney trying to convince MTV viewers in Cairo or the Bronx that the U.S. government has their interest at heart?
Conservatives often accuse African-Americans of playing the race card, but there are plenty of cards in that deck, and theyre available to white people, too. One favorite trick is to use prominent black figures as a way of suggesting that the system is working. Such thinking was present in the post--Rodney King hiring of Willie Williams and Bernard Parks. It was there during my years teaching at Georgetown University, when looming basketball coach John Thompson and his five black starters provided camouflage for an expensive, nearly all-white Catholic university in a District of Columbia that was 70 percent African-American.
The same dynamic emerged in the recent skirmish at Harvard, when new president Lawrence Summers reportedly chastised professor Cornel West for ignoring his scholarly duties and making a jazzy, hip-hoppy music CD called Sketches of My Culture. Taken as a sign of disrespect for the whole African-American Studies Department, Summers rebuke prompted talk of a migration to Princeton by the programs so-called Dream Team, which includes West, the fine poverty scholar William Julius Wilson and Henry Louis Gates Jr., who is at once black cultures Ken Burns and its George Steinbrenner. Such an exodus would naturally cause a humiliating loss of face for Harvard, which needs a high-profile African-American Studies program to salve its own liberal conscience and persuade the outside world that the universitys not the training ground for white elites it so obviously is.
Almost instantly, the controversy became a mudslinging jamboree. The Economist mocked cornelwest.com for dubbing West one of the most preeminent minds of our time while misspelling the name of Nietzsche. The New Republic Web site dredged up an old Leon Wieseltier piece that called Wests writing almost completely worthless. The Wall Street Journal ran an article sneering at Wests scholarship and accusing the Dream Team of using white guilt to achieve black power. By the time Al Sharpton started talking about lawsuits, a writer in Slate had termed the whole thing a feast of victimization.
It was equally a smorgasbord of high-octane careerism. In fact, the West kerfuffle said as much about changing academic mores as it did about race. Were long past the days (if they ever existed) when modest, donnish souls spent their whole lives Mr. Chipsing their way around the university quad. Todays high-profile professors are marquee names, who jump around like baseball free agents, sometimes package themselves together like Hollywood talent and get away with all this because their names serve as drawing cards for any university that has them. Offend them at your peril. West is one of Harvards undeniable stars, which makes it odd that Summers so thoroughly missed the point of what he does. I dont know anyone who thinks West is a great thinker, but hes a mesmerizing speaker, whose rhetoric blends Jesus and Marx with the riffing, improvisational exuberance of a Muddy Waters or John Coltrane. Hearing him in full flight, youre reminded of Albert Murrays line about the blues: What counts isnt verbal precision but musical precision. It doesnt really matter that his books are mediocre because, like so many legendary teachers, hes there to inspire his listeners to action, to fill them with intellectual excitement. And this he does. He opens up the world for them, one of the classic functions of a university professor.
The problem with Sketches of My Culture is not that its insufficiently academic. The problem is, it sounds bad. If anyone should be maligning this excruciating CD (which Wests Web site modestly labels a watershed in musical history), its not the president of Harvard, but Ornette Coleman and Chuck D.
I once interviewed former Reagan-Bush speechwriter Peggy Noonan and found her as nice as can be, but put her at a keyboard and, man, she turns as nasty as Goofy behind his steering wheel. After seeing Black Hawk Down, she wrote a column rhapsodizing about the scene in which a sergeant whos been ordered to drive a jeep tells his colonel, But Im shot. The colonel snaps, Everybodys shot. Get in and drive.
Declaring everybodys shot to be great metaphoric words, Noonan takes aim at her ideological enemies:
Just after the movie, I picked up Ellis Coses latest book, The Envy of the World, about the daunting challenges that face black men in 21st-century America. I read and thought, Earth to Ellis: Everyone faces daunting challenges in 21st-century America. Because everybodys been shot.
Earth to Peggy: For millions of Americans, many of them black men, the idea of being shot isnt simply a metaphor.
Get the Weekly Newsletter
Our weekly feature stories, movie reviews, calendar picks and more - minus the newsprint and sent directly to your inbox.