Top

news

Stories

 

To drive the point home, he signed a pledge to serve two full terms as city attorney. He vowed not to run for Congress or district attorney, and goaded Weiss to do the same. If he violated the pledge, he promised to give $100,000 to an after-school program and take out a full-page newspaper ad announcing "I AM A LIAR."

Soon after Trutanich was elected, he dove headfirst into the political arena. One of his first acts was to threaten criminal charges against sports and entertainment company AEG over the Michael Jackson funeral at Staples Center, a major player in downtown L.A. (Those threats went nowhere.) He inveighed against billboards and supergraphics. When Councilwoman Jan Perry raised objections to his crusade, he threatened to arrest her.

Trutanich has made a point of going after protesters such as Hamid Khan, who was arrested at an immigrants rights demonstration in May 2010 and threatened with six to nine months in jail.
PHOTO BY NANETTE GONZALES
Trutanich has made a point of going after protesters such as Hamid Khan, who was arrested at an immigrants rights demonstration in May 2010 and threatened with six to nine months in jail.
Sarah Armstrong, of the Greater Los Angeles Collective Alliance, says Trutanich is "not smart enough to regulate around" medical marijuana.
PHOTO BY NANETTE GONZALES
Sarah Armstrong, of the Greater Los Angeles Collective Alliance, says Trutanich is "not smart enough to regulate around" medical marijuana.

Less than two years into his term, Trutanich broke his pledge and started raising money to run for district attorney. Everything he had done as city attorney became potential campaign fodder — exactly what front-line deputies feared from the get-go. And, indeed, when Trutanich formally announced his candidacy for DA two weeks ago, he talked up his record as a tough prosecutor.

Trutanich turned down repeated requests from the Weekly over several weeks to be interviewed for this story, although his office did make attorneys available to discuss specific issues. (Last week, Trutanich finally offered to meet for an off-the-record chat, but the Weekly refused.)

He has made himself available to a few select outlets. In an interview on KPCC, he presented himself as the most qualified candidate in the race. "We forced the billboard companies to their knees," he bragged.

That kind of rhetoric turns off a lot of prosecutors in the District Attorney's Office, who worry that Trutanich will meddle with their cases for political reasons.

"We don't want to be thugs. We don't want to push people around," says one deputy DA. "We want to prosecute bad guys and we want to do it fairly. There's a feeling that Trutanich is the kind of guy who would use his position to abuse the power we have."

The tough-guy approach doesn't always work. Nowhere has Trutanich been more aggressive, or less effective, than in his fight against medical marijuana.

The medical marijuana community supported Trutanich's campaign, believing him to be more understanding of its cause than Jack Weiss.

But shortly after he was elected, Trutanich helped organize an ominous-sounding law enforcement training luncheon: "The Eradication of Medical Marijuana Dispensaries in the City of Los Angeles and Los Angeles County."

The problem for Trutanich was that the L.A. City Council — and the city as a whole — did not want to eradicate medical marijuana. They wanted to regulate it. (In 2010, 54 percent of Angelenos voted in favor of Proposition 19, the unsuccessful state measure that would have legalized marijuana.) So Trutanich's office drafted regulations that were virtually impossible to follow.

The city ordinance granted government access to patient medical records, without a warrant. It imposed burdensome requirements for record keeping and product testing. And it imposed criminal sanctions for anyone who failed to comply.

Dispensaries had no choice except to sue. But rather than wait to see what the courts thought of his ordinance, Trutanich started enforcing it, coordinating a series of raids on "noncompliant" dispensaries.

In July 2010, LAPD raided Liberty Bell Temple, a Rastafarian dispensary in Hollywood. Eight officers in helmets and bulletproof vests marched in, shotguns drawn. They arrested the owner, Ed Forchion, along with his girlfriend, and seized two pounds of marijuana and $7,000 in cash.

Trutanich's office charged Forchion with several misdemeanor violations of the new ordinance. According to Forchion's attorney, David Welch, the prosecutors first offered the maximum: six months in jail. The offer meant the prosecutors wanted a trial — and, to Welch, it was a clear sign of political motives.

"It was an attempt to scare other people into closing," Forchion says.

The same thing happened to Lev Goukassian, who operated Nirvana Pharmacy in Westwood. He was arrested, and the officers seized $3,000 in cash. When Goukassian went to court, the deputy city attorney offered him a plea deal: He, too, could do six months.

"Even the judge laughed at that," says Goukassian's attorney, Gregory Rubel. "The response from the [deputy] city attorney was, 'These are my marching orders. I don't agree with it. But this is what I've been told to do.' "

The marching orders changed, however, when Judge Anthony Mohr struck down major portions of the city's ordinance, including the parts that allowed for criminal penalties. In his December 2010 ruling, Mohr called Trutanich's raids "most troubling" because it was not clear that anyone had actually broken the law.

After the ruling, the City Attorney's Office offered a plea deal to Goukassian. If he pleaded guilty to disturbing the peace, he would serve no jail time and would not be fined. As long as he stayed out of trouble, his record would be wiped clean after a year. He even got his $3,000 back.

"Their case fell apart," Rubel says. "They made a big deal out of these cases and then ran away from them."

As for the case against Forchion, it lingered until last October, when a state appellate court struck down an ordinance in Long Beach that is similar to the one in Los Angeles. Trutanich's office decided it could no longer defend the law and dropped charges against Forchion and two other dispensaries. Trutanich's effort to put dispensary owners behind bars ended in complete failure.

<< Previous Page | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | All | Next Page >>
 
My Voice Nation Help
61 comments
lizardleaping4
lizardleaping4

Is anyone aware of Trutanichs's role in the coervice confinement of Alisa Spitzberg from November 4th of 2009 until December 4th of 2009. Judge Maria Stratton refused to grant any bail due to malicious and false pretenses. When DA Mathew Byrne then refused to argue further as opposed to Richard Vagnozzi, Stratton went from no bail to 10k bail though OR was what should never have been taken away. As bad as this is, CASE 8CA10541 is worse. Judge Maria Stratton is a criminal who works hand in hand with Trutanich. Are you aware of the Melissa Balin and Franics Shivers's cases? Trutanich is using Soviet Era tactics to win cases and to avoid lawsuits. Judge Richard Fruin assures that no one wins against the city. Are you aware that con artists like Deputy CA's Martin Boags and Jennifer Waxler file fake charges to terrorize innocent defendants who refuse any plea deal? Are you aware the the LAPD's Threat management Unit uses the tax payers money to coordinate searches and 18 officers riot geared raids in non violent misdemeanor cases? Are you aware of Judge Samantha Jessner and her sinister role in Trutanich's regime. The role of the judges who are approving these insane bails or total denial of bail must be investigated. The schemed to use the mental health court as a weapon needs to be known to all too.

Kent
Kent

my co-worker's aunt makes $88/hour on the laptop. She has been without a job for 8 months but last month her check was $14831 just working on the laptop for a few hours. Here's the site to read more lazycash42.c()m

Eric_Apple
Eric_Apple

Why is it that personalities so unfit for power are the ones that most crave it?

http://widg.me/NbuKe
http://widg.me/NbuKe

Hi to all my friends we are in need of some new people for the expansion of our team urgently, if you are willing to do simple online work from home join us. No experience required, weekly payment, weekends off and level bonuses apply fast by clicking on the link above.

http://widg.me/NbuKe
http://widg.me/NbuKe

Hi to all my friends we are in need of some new people for the expansion of our team urgently, if you are willing to do simple online work from home join us. No experience required, weekly payment, weekends off and level bonuses apply fast by clicking on the link above.

Kelly Kettle
Kelly Kettle

We are www.12stepplanet.com and www.addictstoday.com. Please join us to fight the disease of drug and alcohol addiction/abuse. We are a driving force of individuals with one common focus to resolve and to have a quality of life without – Addiction.. It’s devastating and its life threatening but we can conquer it together. We can help our fellow man rise out the abyss of death and destruction. Together we can overcome. See how we did it. See where we began, where it took us and how and why we found the solution. It’s a WE process. Only WE can help each other. Please read our short stories of how we did it. If you have a success story that would help others please send your edited story to my12stepplanet@yahoo.com. You can help save a life today, We are the Planet. We are 12stepplanet.com. We interface on FaceBook. Join us there as well. We will support you in recovery. Kk

An LA graff head
An LA graff head

I can't figure out why revok and saber are opening their mouths and bringing this heat upon their balding heads. As far as I know Trutanich isn't even going after those two. The LASD are the ones giving them heat. Now, I have a feeling that they have just opened themselves up to some almost guaranteed shit from Trutanich. Guess 7th letter and MSK should expect an injunction thrown at them like MTA did. It would also make a lot more sense for the City Attorney to go after 7th letter and MSK, these guys actually do profit off of their crimes, it would be a lot easier to prove a case against them, and therefore win the case, than it would against MTA, since 7th letter and MSK are more cohesive as a group in using their "ill gotten fame" to benifit them financially. And opening up more doors for them as far as shows and opportunities at lucrative sponsorship deals go from spray paint companies and the like. It would have made more sense for smear to raise a big fuss in this article and call Trutanich all sorts of names, but as you can see, he seems to have let the ACLU do the talking for him. Unless the weekly didn't even attempt to contact him, but I doubt that. I suspect that revok and saber just couldn't resist having their names and their quotes in print again, even if it means that they will likely have to pay for it down the road a short ways. Ego will get you every time.

Jon
Jon

He looks like a communist era, eastern bloc dictator. Which is, it seems, what he strives so hard to emulate. Oh, and I've also heard a few of those "homo" rumors as well.

Confused
Confused

I'm so confused, a few years back the L.A. Weekly was up in arms about billboards, and ridiculed the mayor and the City Council for not doing anything about it. (http://www.laweekly.com/2008-0... Now, apparently it is a laughable issue and Trutanich is to be ridiculed for taking the issue on?

First
First

He has also flip-flopped on the no drivers license vehicle impound issue in favor of .....guess who??

Onemetaphysician
Onemetaphysician

Trutanich cares nothing about the citizens of Los Angeles or voters' rights. Trutanich is only interested in Trutanich, his own personal agenda... and what he can get for Trutanich and supporting his other criminal friends in power. How could anyone look at this guy's face and think "Now, there's a fair, honest and intelligent man."? Pure evil is more like it.

Robertlupescu
Robertlupescu

I feel for that guy Denny that Trutanich wanted to jail for the super graphic a while back. I remember reading about it and shaking my head. A fine, I can understand, but jail?

Robertlupescu
Robertlupescu

An artist as talented as Revok should never be treated the way that he has been by the powers that be.

Art collctor
Art collctor

Smear is not a member of MTA. The writer/reporter should of thrown in an "alleged" in that sentence. Sloppy, pretty sloppy. And the guy doesnt sell "photographs", he sells, from what Ive seen of his work in person and on his website, original paintings.

The bean spiller
The bean spiller

Turdtanich is pure sleaze. I've heard rumors or homosexuality too. Dig a little, it'll come to the surface. It's not buried al that deep.

marc scime
marc scime

"California historian Kevin Starr says there's a long history of corruption here, dating to the noir era and even earlier. And he says the roots of organized crime in the region are deep. But I think a better explanation for our current rot is that if you're a scheming public official in Los Angeles, stealing everything that isn't nailed to the wall is a breeze. Too many people aren't paying attention and can't be bothered to vote, which allows sleazy opportunists to easily build fiefdoms. And journalists can't bag every skunk, no matter how much we'd like to."

marc scime
marc scime

Study: Los Angeles Is Second Only to Chicago in Public Corruption

http://laist.com/2012/02/26/st...

"California historian Kevin Starr says there's a long history of corruption here, dating to the noir era and even earlier. And he says the roots of organized crime in the region are deep. But I think a better explanation for our current rot is that if you're a scheming public official in Los Angeles, stealing everything that isn't nailed to the wall is a breeze. Too many people aren't paying attention and can't be bothered to vote, which allows sleazy opportunists to easily build fiefdoms. And journalists can't bag every skunk, no matter how much we'd like to."

Don't uglify LA
Don't uglify LA

Sign blight is ruining Los Angeles. Huge signs are everywhere, including those ghastly mobile signs on vehicles. And the glaring lights that accompany some of them add to the ugliness.

Gary Coleman
Gary Coleman

You are right, trutanich has been completely ineffective at even combating sign blight.

timfromla
timfromla

Trutanich is merely in it for the party. The man is a coward, yes, a coward. If he truly was tough on crime then hey Carmen GO AFTER THE BANKS! No? Then everyone here who reads this post, please agree with me by clicking like after you read:

18 USC § 4 - Misprision of felonyhttp://www.law.cornell.edu/usc...

Whoever, having knowledge of the actual commission of a felony cognizable by a court of the United States, conceals and does not as soon as possible make known the same to some judge or other person in civil or military authority under the United States, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than three years, or both.

In other words, since Trutanich knows that Bush committed war crimes, ehich is a felony and knew that the banksters committed felony banking fraud, he has no choice but to go after them

OR

be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than three years, or both.

So please like this and make sure that this remains popular so that we could shut Carmen up

Warren
Warren

Trutanich is a liar, a thug and a bully. He would make a horrible District Attorney and cannot be trusted with that kind of power.

medocadvikian
medocadvikian

Los Angeles needs to rid itself of Trutanich and Cooley. Fortunately Cooley is termed out but Trutanich can run again. Join me in seeing him run out of the city of Los Angeles.

Timothy Chiacchira
Timothy Chiacchira

Run him out of town.. put wanted posters up all over town.. make him feel the heat.

medocadvikian
medocadvikian

Before the next election, put up some supergraphics all over the city asking voters to kick him out of office! It would be poetic justice.

alleycat
alleycat

A year in jail for non violent protestors? This guy is a lunatic!

Thephxrising
Thephxrising

Carmen Trutanich is a piece of shit. And he'll be worse as D.A..

Anonymous
Anonymous

I've met Trutanich on several occasions and I am bewildered at how he was elected City Attorney. He seemed distracted during our meeting and could not focus on the issue at hand. He was inarticulate and gruff. He was not respectful of anyone in the meeting who had a differing view. He lacks any professionalism and this article shows he lacks good judgment too

anonymous
anonymous

A hit piece based on the feedback from greedy marijuana shops and Billboard companies that are not about to give up their ill-gotten millions. Ban them all. Trutanich is anyday more ethical than each and every Councilmember and the Mayor. I'll vote for him for DA. Anyone has to be better than that useless Cooley and his cohorts in that office.

Anonymous
Anonymous

This "hit piece" had much more information than just feedback from marijuana shops and Billboard companies. You are completely discrediting yourelf by putting Trutanich on the top of the ethical ladder above "every single Councilmember, the Mayor, and Cooley." Trutanich is a proven liar based on him reneging on his pledge to not run for D.A. Then he fails to take out the "I am a Liar" ad or donate to the after school program even though HE was the one that contrived the terms of the deal as penalty for breaking the pledge. Remember, HE is the one that said over and over throughout his campaign that he would fulfill his full term as City Attorney and not seek higher office. No one forced him to promise this, he chose to make this the platform of his City Attorney campaign. He is not credible and cannot be trusted. We CANNOT have a District Attorney without credibility, the job is just too important for that. There are many other qualified District Attorney candidates that are not proven liars from which voters can choose. ANYONE would be better than a liar.

anonymous
anonymous

I will repeat that Trutanich is anyday more honest than the crap we have in City Council. Have you forgotten that the Mayor promised to serve his full term as Councilman of the 14th District & jumped into the Mayoral race & won. We all have freewill at the ballot. Don't vote for Trutanich. And yeah! let's hear about the accomplishments of the other "qualified" candidates.

marc scime
marc scime

Your arguments here are unimpressive... Much like Trutanich's record as LA City Attorney.

David W.
David W.

The Mayor didn't sign a pledge promising not to run and the comparison to City Council is neither here nor there because Trutanich is not running for City Council. Trutanich is running for the top law enforcement post in the County which is not appropriate for a bullying lying thug.

Commentgirl1950
Commentgirl1950

I supported Trutanich in his campaign for City Attorney because I believed him when he said "I am not a politician." I believed him when he said he would not use the City Attorney's Office as a stepping stone to higher office. He has lost all credibility with me and he will not have my support in his campaign for District Attorney. As City Attorney he has shown bad judgment and proven to be unethical and unprofessional. It is very scary to think of Trutanich as District Attorney. The District Attorney must be someone with the highest ethics and with the sole goal of promoting justice. It will be a sad day indeed if Angelenos allow a power hungry bullying thug to be our District Attorney based on nothing more than name recognition. Wake up Los Angeles.

marc scime
marc scime

Q: How do you know when someone is a politician?

A: When they're campaigning to be elected.

Q: How do you know when a politician is lying to you?

A: They tell you that they aren't a politician when they're campaigning to be elected.

Trutanich is a train-wreck.

Jose
Jose

The more and more the US becomes like Mexico with government corruption, the more likely it will be that we are going to see prison breaks, etc.

Rick Abrams
Rick Abrams

I think massive corruption brings us more serious troubles than prison breaks

Jose
Jose

I was envisioning convicts on the loose looking for revenge against against a corrupt district attorney.

What "more serious troubles" do you see?

guest
guest

Quick message for Revok: Anyone who skips out on a criminal court date or fails to pay the clerk gets a bench warrant, the judge, not a prosecutor, has authority over that. Next time just show up when you're supposed to...

Rick Abrams
Rick Abrams

Some commenter posted that if LA Weekly had mentioned all of Carmen "The Thug" Trutanich's misdeeds, it would have room for nothing else. I agree, LA Weekly's excellent article just begins to uncover the horrors that Trutanich has brought to the City Atty's office.

When Hahn was City Atty, the office was one of the most professional in the entire city. I never encountered a personal vendetta, unlike the corrupt D.A.'s office which has been a scourge on Justice for decades. Then came Rocky -- and ethics went out the window along with many of the honorable City Attys. Evidence was destroyed, city atty's vouched for clients, city atty submitted perjured declaration to the court, there were special visits to judges -- but the opposing side never got to heard what was said behind closed doors.

At first, Nuch looked like he might live up to his promises. A few of the more deceitful attys left the office, but then came the slow turn by Trutanich and his descent into a dark place foreign to truth, justice and the American way. City Attys who do his biding can have no self-respect.

Perhaps those of us who know more about Trutanich's sleazy practices should forward everything we know to LA Weekly for a follow up piece.

What would Los Angeles do with LA Weekly, CityWatchLA (a tad timid), Ron Kaye, City Maven, SaveHollywod.org, Zuma Dogg, Matt Dowd, However LA Weekly stands tallest among the supports of an L.A. without corruption.

Jenny
Jenny

Amazing how so many people who work for Trutanich are prepared to speak up about all the mistakes that he has made, like wasting resources on his political agendas which end up failing because they are based on unlawful and unconstitutional principles.

Warren
Warren

David Berger, who was Carmen Trutanich's Special Assistant City Attorney and served on his Transition Team, was one of the first people to realize that Trutanich was a liar, a cheat and utterly unfit for public office. He started speaking out about Trutanich two years ago, finally the people of Los Angeles are listening and realizing what a grave mistake it was to trust this ponced-up ambulance chaser. Trutanich is the worst type of lawyer. He is the reason why there are so many bad lawyer jokes. He can look you in the eye and lie through his teeth without batting an eyelid.

marc scime
marc scime

Yep... Anyone paying attention should have been able to figure out that Trutanich is unfit by now.

med head
med head

Trutanich is an obstructionist -- he needs stop closing dispensaries that the people of the state of California voted to allow!

Davidhernandez17
Davidhernandez17

this article is such typical LA Weekly bullshit. not even an attempt to fake some sort of balance. I am not a trutanich fan or critic, but I do know that he is better than Jack Weiss would have ever been and he is aggressive - sometimes to his own detriment. did you search out every single critic of trutanich and throw them into this article? seriously..

Warren
Warren

Bullshit? No, I don't think so. There is so much evidence of Trutanich lying and cheating and basically behaving like a tinpot dictator that no amount of comparison to Jack Weiss or Antonio Villaraigosa can make Trutanich look good. He is lair who has no regard for his own word. He uses the power of his office to bully people, but as soon as anyone stands up to him, he falls apart like a cheap suit. He is a nothing, a nobody, a complete coward who will not even answer phone calls from the press. Instead he hides behind the skirts of secretaries who have to make up lame excuses for him. Jack Weiss would have made a bad City Attorney, I agree, but even Weiss would not have been as bad as Trutanich.

Daphna
Daphna

If the LA Weekly got every critic of Nuch the thug, then there wouldn't be enough room in the paper for any other news. The fact is that Nuch has so many people against him that his special interest millions don't matter. Nobody who voted for him in 2009 is willing to vote for him again. Thanks to all the people in his own office who leak information about his shady dealings and filthy ethics, Nuch will create a new record for the shortest political career in LA. He ought to move to Chicago where his talents would be appreciated.

marc scime
marc scime

I'm from Chicago originally and I've lived in LA 8 years. I'm already quite convinced that LA is at least as corrupt as Chicago. The only difference is that the Feds and the news media haven't been looking for it here like they do in Chicago, Cook County and Illinois in general.

marc scime
marc scime

Speaking of the devil:

"Study: Los Angeles Is Second Only to Chicago in Public Corruption"

laist dot com

Rick Abrams
Rick Abrams

Chicago, you say? Chicago is cleaner than L.A. At least in Chicago, they periodically put the crooks in prison, but never in L.A.

Three cheers three times over for LA Weekly !!! !!! !!!

 
©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city