Top

news

Stories

 

Stopping 2,000 Barking Dogs

Obnoxious L.A. pet owners face $250 fine

Los Angeles residents who live within hearing distance of an estimated 2,000 chronically barking dogs go through a private hell, with City Hall policies allowing the barking to continue for months. But things might change with a new law, now in effect, to fine dog owners $250 to $1,000 — that is, if anyone enforces it.

In 2009, 19,351 notices were sent to pet owners for barking, leash and cruelty violations, some 10 percent of which were believed to be persistent barking-dog violations. Then, in 2010, a bizarre series of events unfolded as City Hall tried to crack down. First, in May 2010, in a story that went national, the Los Angeles Times, Daily Breeze and CBS reported that the City Council voted 10-0 to create a $100 fine against obnoxious dog owners. Some media suggested the fines could generate up to $1.8 million annually.

Nobody at City Hall seems to know what happened to that vote. There's no record of it on the city website, and the Department of Animal Services never implemented a $100 fine — much less collected $1.8 million.

Instead, last year, one veteran animal services employee told L.A. Weekly that he had never heard of a $100 fine. And despite thousands of annual complaints, the department held only 83 formal administrative hearings to force owners to control their barking dogs.

Then, on Nov. 1, the City Council unanimously passed a new law.

It still forces the countless victims of barking dogs to attend a formal hearing, only a handful of which are held each month by Animal Services. But now, city officials promise, owners of barking dogs will pay $250, $500 and $1,000, respectively, if the first, second and third administrative hearings find them at fault.

Under current practices, "You have to follow up on your complaint before they'll even take it seriously," says Sherman Oaks resident and barking complainant Tom Materna. For him, "It wasn't even until the third case number [was created] that it finally went through. It's definitely geared toward the dog owners and not the complaining neighbors. It's not called Human Services — it's called Animal Services."

The law defines "excessive noise" as that "which unreasonably interferes with the comfortable enjoyment of life," and is "continuously audible for ten (10) minutes or intermittently audible for thirty (30) minutes within a three (3) hour period."

It adds a requirement for the victims of chronic barking as well: Their second official complaint must be corroborated by a letter — from another neighbor.

Those victimized by horrific noise problems, callous, inconsiderate neighbors and a strangely lenient city government are only guardedly optimistic.

"While I am pleased the City Council passed it, passing or amending an ordinance does not ensure there would be any further energy applied to this," says John Glitzow, a Mid-City resident whose neighbors, he says, chain their dogs to the front porch on three feet of leash, where they bark viciously for hours.

"I have been told by enforcement officials, 'Do not be surprised if the lack of attention to complaints worsens due to the current economy,' " Glitzow says. "These officials should be simply doing what they are paid to do in a day's work shift."

The wait for a hearing can be eight months while a dog barks persistently. Yet Animal Services General Manager Brenda Barnette seems to suggest that far more Angelenos should jump into the city's gridlocked system if they expect any help.

"The enforcement really is about the people filing the complaints," Barnette says. "Often, the first time they call regarding the barking dog, we do send someone out to talk with them. It's about the people actually following through — and filing a complaint."

But then what? Barnette's department employs just one hearing officer — in a city that employs some 50,000 port, airport, utility and other city department workers. That, and other signs, suggest that Animals Services is biased toward dog owners and against those who complain.

Barnette suggests that L.A. residents routinely pursue barking complaints to avenge some other hidden resentment, saying, "The way it's been, a complaint could be about dog barking — or it could be about something else the neighbor doesn't like."

But when the Weekly talked to several complainants involved in separate cases, it was clear that they had wanted a cordial connection to, enjoyed friendships with or were completely unaware of their dog-owning neighbors — until the barking started.

"Our neighbors are vindictive — they're bullies," says Highland Park resident Barbara Lopez, who, with husband Richard, lives next to a rental property that houses several dogs, including one especially loud pit bull that's permanently outdoors.

Lopez says the pit bull's owners are hostile and contemptuous toward the senior-age Lopezes. Their quiet lives have been affected in devastating ways. "Friends and family stopped coming over," Lopez says. "I walk around with earplugs in, and I sleep on the floor or in another room. It's made our lives a living hell and my husband has had two heart attacks."

She says two administrative rulings by the L.A. Department of Animal Services were in their favor, and Lopez says hearing officer George Mossman was fair and just.

But Barnette, a busy city department head dealing with frequent political headaches, found the time to intervene. Lopez says Barnette overruled Mossman.

1 | 2 | All | Next Page >>
 
My Voice Nation Help
28 comments
Jhoover
Jhoover like.author.displayName 1 Like

Anyone that knowingly allows their dog to bark outdoors, within any of the densely populated areas of LA, ought to be beaten with a stick. Not kidding. Not having it. It is so inconsiderate that it boggles the mind.

Ashrrs
Ashrrs

Barking dogs in LA is the least annoying: It's the roosters and illegal parrots that drove me insane when I lived right outside of downtown.

Leslie
Leslie

My neighbors let their mutts out to crap in their back yard. After they do that, then they want back inside so they whine, howl, bark etc ... at the back door for 30 - 55 minutes at a time. The owners ignore this. I told the male homeowner (over the fence) and asked him nicely to not let his dogs bark for so long. I suggested they install a dog door. They don't care. I bought a $100 dog silencer (those don't work, by the way). I have addressed the female homeowner with a bullhorn when she opened the door. She had the nerve to stare at me ... like I'M the one doing something WRONG! CHRIST! They KNOW they are being inconsiderate to all of the neighbors. They just don't care. I don't know how idiot, losers like this have a half million dollar home on Longridge Ave. in Sherman Oaks. I can't take naps EVER because I WILL get jolted awake when the three times a day one hour barking symphony starts. The neighbors next to them also have two mutts, and the guy next to me has one as well. It's HELL when all are out at the same time. It's absolutely ridiculous that non pet owners have to be subjected to this day in and day out.

Training Dog Leash
Training Dog Leash

Great article to read . I must say that I learned something. Thanks for sharing to everyone :D

Roy
Roy

Mÿ cö-wörkër's stëp-sistër mâkës $37/höür öñ thë lâptöp. Shë hâs bëëñ lâid öff för 9 möñths büt lâst möñth hër pâÿchëck wâs $2057 jüst wörkiñg öñ thë lâptöp för â fëw höürs. Rëâd mörë öñ this wëb sitë.... LazyCash10.c­om

Tana Scalese
Tana Scalese

Good That drives me nuts! It should be illegal to have chronic barking dogs.

Fast cash
Fast cash

@ tana Scalese .....i am also agree with u ..it is illegal to have chronic barking dogs

DV
DV

A barking dog nearly ruined my life and forced me to move. Animal control was no help. Neighbors were no help. Dog owners used intimidation and harrassment. It was a nightmare. I am an avid animal and pet-lover. The problem is the owners, not the poor, often neglected animals. Los Angeles needs to toughen up and change this system!

Guest
Guest

Those who complain about excessive barking could instead try to set an example by acting humane to the dogs and learning to speak dog. If dog owners themselves arent bothered by barking the owners must not be interested in their dog's well being. Maybe if the neighbors took time to get to know the offending dog, the barking would lessen. While no one wants to have to learn dog training, especially for a dog that is not their own, it would go a long way towards solving a problem. Or at least give the complainants something to do for the eight months until the hearing. Clearly dog owners have a responsibility towards their dogs but if it is not being met, then someone else taking responsibility by training the dog is better than no one taking responsibility. Dog barking is self reinforcing. When a dog barks it needs to be distracted or exercised so it doesnt keep barking. There are many great youtube videos on dog training - i recommend searching for 'calming signals' as they are really easy to learn. One example is to yawn and look away. Anyway t is much easier to communicate with an angry dog than an angry owner in my opinion.

Leslie
Leslie

Right. It's MY responsibility to train their dogs.

Guest
Guest

Give me a break! You truly are naive. It is not the neighbor's job to "get to know the dog" or train the dog. Pet owners should be reponsible and considerate - bottom line.

VivlianWozz
VivlianWozz

Another restaurant cliaimed to use fresh mozz arella cheese,where it's dishes were actually made with economy cheddar.the "fresh pasta"advertieshed on another meau tumed out to be frozen.--Agedate. ℃⊙M--a nice and free place for younger women and older men,or older women and younger men,to interact with each other.

maria
maria

This is becoming a very serious problem and creating animosity between neighbors. If dog owners would be considerate and do what they are supposed to do, I would not have a problem with your dogs. I love dogs. But I don't want your dogs to keep me up all night because you don't do anything about their barking all hours of the night. And you should carry doggie bags. I live downstairs (duplex) and upstairs lives the property owner's sister. She has turned the backyard into a dog bathroom. I don't even open my windows or curtains anymore because all I see and smell is dog poop. She is an older lady and owns about 6 small dogs and those are the ones that bark the most and for no reason. She has hardwood floors and her dogs scampering about sounds like a stampede. It is extremely annoying, and yes, has caused a major strain in our relationship. We are looking to move out but it is hard to find a place with a reasonable rent. Like I said, control your dogs barking and pick up their poop and the city council won't have to waste time on issues such as these and focus on the important ones, like how they dropped the ball re the stimulus money due to the city of L.A.!!!!!

medocadvikian
medocadvikian

If you get no satisfaction from the Animal Control department, take your complaint to court in the form of a small claims petition. Ask the judge for $500.00 and give hm your proof. If you win, you can file another complaint and ask for additional money each time the dog continues to bark. After a few thousand dollars in judgements, either the neighbor will actually do something or move.

John
John

I'm wondering about the law regarding vicious dogs. I have a neighbor whose dog always sneaks up on me when I'm working in the yard, and starts viciously barking through the fence and showing its teeth. It's part pit bull and scares the hell out of me every time. The neighbor usually calls it off within a few minutes, but not before I've had a near heart attack. I'm sure if the fence weren't there this dog would go for my throat.

medocadvikian
medocadvikian

Try approaching the dog quietly and giving him a treat. He is only responding to a possible threat (you) to his area. Dogs don't know what fences are. Soon, he will equate you with good rather than threat.

John
John

I have tried being friendly and offering treats, but with this dog if I take one step towards him his barking increases and he starts digging his feet in the ground and gnashing his teeth. I tried dropping the food through the fence, but he just goes crazy, very frightening.

Citizen Taxpayer
Citizen Taxpayer

Brenda Barnett obviously has her head in the right place. She loves animals and her job is to deal with people who are vindictive and use barking as an excuse to attack their neighbors that is something an animal control person has to sort out. Too many animals???? Hey ask the RESCUE community why they bring in all those foreign dogs and cats. That IS a problem. $100,000 for Beagles from Spain, do Angelenos really believe that there was NO one in Europe to adopt those Beagles and only Angelenos could have done it? Again too many dogs..........complain to the rescue community who keep trying to make themselves feel good by grabbing dogs from foreign countries because we don't have enough to rescue here.

I hate noisy dogs, so does everyone else but some people (stupid or ignorant) don't know how to control their animals nor do they understand them. They are animals and are reactive to their surroundings. Resolutions can be found if anger is set aside and talk is begun. Bark collars or training OR post solutions on their door if you can't talk to them.....

TheLight
TheLight

"horrific noise problems, callous, inconsiderate neighbors and a strangely lenient city government"Describes my experience with the problem well.Took me an entire year to resolve it. Vicious dogs barking and attacking the fence any time I went in my own back yard. The barking was at all hours. Every day. And, you better have the proper documentation/video evidence or you start all over again. It was so bad, the Judge Judy people picked it up and had me on the show. A complete nightmare...

VenturaCapitalist
VenturaCapitalist

Solution: Meatball with a cyanide pill tucked inside.

JesusRe64
JesusRe64

You, sir, are truly disgusting. I hope someone poisons you before you go killing any innocent animals.

VenturaCapitalist
VenturaCapitalist

You keep your freaking dog quiet and there won't be any problem.

JesusRe64
JesusRe64

You, sir, are truly disgusting. I hope someone poisons you before you go killing any innocent animals.

JesusRe64
JesusRe64

You, sir, are truly disgusting. I hope someone poisons you before you go killing any innocent animals.

PitVictim
PitVictim

And stupid Breeder Brenda Barnette wants to up the household limits to create more barking dogs and more cats on the streets. Get rid of her, LA, she is a joke.

 
©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city