Top

news

Stories

 

Bone Bungling at Old Cemetery

Native Americans get short shrift as LA Plaza downtown opens under a cloud

Gary Stickel, the Gabrielenos' volunteer archaeologist, says Sapphos made the egregious error of denying that Gabrielenos even exist: "Under page 3.3-11 ... it's the height of insensitivity to claim that the very people you'd be dealing with are extinct. The presumption is if they're extinct, why should we worry about their burials?"

LA Plaza spokeswoman Katie Dunham tries to deflect the anger, saying the parties involved are trying "to reach a consensus on respectful plans for the remains as we move forward. Mr. Stickel, it seems, chooses to look backward and make allegations."

But Molina admits: "There's probably gonna be plenty of blame to go around on all of it. For us, we probably didn't have as thorough an EIR as we probably should have had."

On March 15, Sapphos requested a Sacred Lands File search and a Native American contact list from the Native American Heritage Commission — something Singleton says should have happened in 2008. He also says ground-penetrating radar was not used until March 31.

On April 9, the Gabrielenos led a protest at an opening gala.

Today, thousands of bones from 118 people are being stored in bags and buckets at the Natural History Museum. The Gabrielenos want them back in their original resting place, with a "prayer park" to mark it.

But first, they want L.A. County to fire Sapphos Environmental.

"What's so outrageous to me and the Native Americans is not only did Sapphos write this nonsense that contributed to what happened," Stickel says, "but who does the county hire to restore the cemetery with sensitivity? The same outfit. This is just completely unacceptable."

Reach the writer at abcooper@cox.net.

<< Previous Page | 1 | 2 | All
 
My Voice Nation Help
13 comments
mndogez
mndogez

I would like to give my DNA to see if it is my g.g.Grandfather skull they found. RE: my other comment they died 12-05-1831.

mndogez
mndogez

My great greatgrandfather Cristobal Palomares was buried in front of the Plaza church along with Jose Avila and Capt. Pacheco. Avila & Pacheco died at the battle of Cauenga Pass.I was told thier bodies are under concrete. You would think the Church or the City of Los Angeles woud discover thier remainsor put up a plaque remembering them.This is a matter of record.

Chloee Baby
Chloee Baby

If you are true reporter do your job and research the problem and report the facts look at the EIR and the group who did the monitoring of the project...

Merlo
Merlo

Wouldn't common sense kick and tell you to stop the excavations and construction? Read all the reports you want, but this is molina doing what she does best.

Guest
Guest

It surprises me that none of the journalists reporting on this so far seem to have even looked at or quoted from the environmental documentation (all of which is readily available online). They've just relied on a few quotations & called them facts. This leaves me with the sense that I only have half the story. I find this subject interesting and did locate several of the original documents done for the environmental compliance work. Even though consultants always provide an easy target, the documents you can find online do point to the possibility of finding human remains. Everyone wants to then point a finger--at the county, the Plaza foundation, the consultants. But the consultants did what they were supposed to do & included an appropriate, responsible mitigation measure in the EIR. It looks like the mitigation measure might not have unfolded quite the way it should have...

In any case, the topic of the Plaza is important for our city, and it deserves much better reporting than it's received so far, in the Weekly & elsewhere. I for one would like to see more actual *reporting* (i.e., reading some of the actual documents & doing some research) and much less empty finger pointing.

Nativetola
Nativetola

It has been a year and I was wondering if you were able to read some of the actual documentation since your last post. Alot has changed hands since the first reporting has taken place. There is still pending issues from the county who has taken over since they are said owners.

Jacklovaglia
Jacklovaglia

"all human remains previously on-site were relocated" away from Old Cemetery." If you had read the article more carefully, you would've seen this quote taken directly from the EIR.

mndogez
mndogez

You arewrong see my post.

Guest
Guest

The sections of the EIR dealing with archeology are more extensive than just this quotation--and, like I said, that's a major problem with the reporting. The other troubling aspect of articles like this is the lack of understanding about how environmental review works in the first place; in particular, there seems to be very little understanding of what mitigation measures are & what the mitigation measure was in this case. This is troubling because CEQA is supposed to be all about citizen review...

Lilaraqhqfukg
Lilaraqhqfukg

Has the reporter done her homework and actually read the EIR? I've seen it and it clearly warned that human remains, including Native Americans, were probably still interred in the cemetery, and would be disturbed if there was any digging in the area. And doesn't campo santo just mean "cemetery" in Spanish?

Mikijackson
Mikijackson

Unacceptable is a nice word for the typical practice by government agencies of hiring the same bad contractors over and over with no real consequences for shoddy work. These outfits usually contribute to elected officials and are politically connected. They often hire retired and ex government bureaucrats to work and consult for them. It's a merry go round of tax payer fund abuse and bad work. I wondered when the Native American and Mexican conflicts would really start to bubble up. You could say it's an old skeleton rattling in the California closet.

Merlo
Merlo

This is a very disturbing story. gloria molina will push her agenda no matter what the cost. I can't believe what this lady does and then she plasters her name on it and tells the world what a great thing she has done for the community. There are many more places that she could have put this museum, how many abadoned buildings does she have control over? Totally disgusted by her actions and this is one "Mexican-American" museum I will not be visiting. I am extremely embarrased by her, she puts all Mexican-American's behind the eight ball for her own benefit!

Maria G Benitez
Maria G Benitez

LOS POBLADORES 200. We are the descendants of the founding families of Los Angeles,and we too are involved as we also have our ancestors which were buried there. I myself found 18 ancestorw including 3 Great Grandmothers and 1 Great Grandfather and the rest Great Grand Aunts and Uncles. We are UNITED with Andy Salas and the Gabrieleno Band of Mission Indians. We together with the Gabrielenos want our ancestors remains reburied with dignity and a Memorial Park in the location. I am President of Los Pobladores Maria G Benitez

 
©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city