Top

news

Stories

 

School Reformer Yolie Flores Departs LAUSD to Fight From Outside

She forced through the most radical idea in recent lausd history. So why’s she leaving for a Bill Gates start-up?

For the final March 8 Los Angeles City election results, please see laweekly.com.

To understand the nightmare that comes with trying to fix public education in Los Angeles, consider the situation at Huntington Park Senior High, one of the district's oldest schools. Only 24 percent of its students are meeting California standards in English; just 5 percent are up to par in math.

"If I was a parent at that school, I'd be having a fit," says Beth Fuller, principal at nearby Jaime Escalante Elementary School.

In fact, many parents at Huntington Park — or HP, as it's known — are very upset. They say some teachers are rude, angry, even racist. One constantly talks on her cell phone while kids are asking for help. Another was caught shouting at mentally disabled children. Some parents say that when they complain to the principal, Al Castillo, he doesn't want to hear it.

"He doesn't want parents involved," says Sonya Espinoza, an HP parent.

Espinoza says that when she tried to volunteer at the high school, Castillo laid down certain conditions. "He said, 'You can participate, but your child is going out of the school if you discover anything bad.' " (Castillo didn't respond to multiple requests from L.A. Weekly for an interview.)

Espinoza was hesitant to give her name or even discuss the school's problems for fear that her child would be punished by administrators. But she's fed up.

Still, no one may be more fed up than Yolie Flores, a Los Angeles Unified School District board member who has made it something of a personal mission to reform HP. Flores graduated there in 1980. She's the child of immigrants, like many at HP, and was the first in her family to attend college. But after being elected to the school board, Flores found out that her alma mater was graduating only 55 percent of its freshmen in four years.

"My heart sank," Flores says. "I was concerned and sad and outraged."

A few months ago, she held a meeting with parents to discuss a few proposals being floated to change how HP was structured — and led. Dozens of kids showed up, along with several teachers.

Before long, Flores found herself on the defensive. The kids, it turned out, saw Flores not as an ally but as the enemy.

One student demanded, "Why are you gonna force us to change if we don't want to? We're here because we want the education to stay the same."

One of the teachers shouted at Flores. The students hollered and applauded.

In this Kafka-esque setting, Flores was being harangued for encouraging change at a failing school, where only 14 percent of the students earn C's or better in their college-prep classes — and that doesn't count the persistent, districtwide practice of grade inflation, in which many teachers mask the fact that B's are C's, or even D's.

Welcome to the forbidding world of education reform in Los Angeles.

Long before data became a prickly buzzword in the national debate over public schools, Flores was examining the numbers. For two decades, while heading several nonprofit and government organizations with the words child, family or education in their names, and during her year studying education systems as a fellow at the Annie E. Casey Foundation, she pored over statistics that measured how much (or, in most cases, how little) kids were actually learning.

"In the world of social services, too often it's just about doing 'good' things and not paying attention to results," explains the 48-year-old Flores, whose small stature belies her toughness.

Appointed in 1993 to the little-known L.A. County Board of Education, which, independent of the LAUSD board, oversees schools for juvenile camps and programs for pregnant teens, Flores took a closer look at LAUSD's success rate.

"I thought, 'No wonder our kids aren't getting out of poverty — they're not even getting out of high school,' " she says.

In 2007, after nearly a decade running the nonprofit Children's Planning Council, Flores ran for an open seat on the LAUSD board. She'd run eight years before but lost to incumbent David Tokofsky. This time she won with the backing of Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, who was eager to find reform-minded players for the school board.

When Flores stepped inside the school district's downtown skyscraper headquarters on Beaudry Avenue, she discovered the situation was worse than she expected. "Nobody was outraged that half our kids are dropping out, or that only 30 percent of our third-graders can read at their grade level. I remember going into Beaudry every day, thinking, 'Why isn't everybody upset about this?' Like meeting every day, strategizing, tying to figure this out?"

After two years of "pure frustration" on the school board, which was and still is led by President Monica Garcia, Flores decided to change the game.

Her chief inspiration was a documentary about a school on Chicago's West Side, which is the equivalent of South L.A.'s roughest neighborhoods. The Providence Effect chronicled an independent, nonprofit high school that for 30 years has miraculously sent to college 100 percent of its graduates — almost all of them poor and African-American.

1 | 2 | 3 | All | Next Page >>
 
My Voice Nation Help
32 comments
Guest20
Guest20

What total horse manure. To even pretend like Yolie's Orwellian-named "Public School Choice" effort was the product of some lone range reformer that had an idea, and not actually the major and most significant battle of a long war waged by Riordan-Broad and Co. to take these major public assets for their the corporate charter industry is blatant journalistic Crap.

You quote Ben Austin and don't even attempt to disclose the amount of money he makes leading one of the chief corporate charters in the Southland, and the fact that he worked for Villaraigosa, the most prominent lackey in the Riordan-Broad & Co. crowd. Mendell offers not a mention of Austin's role in the "Public School Choice" effort.

Mandell spent 3 pages and couldn't bother to mention the guys behind the curtains pulling the charter movement strings, yet he was all too happy presenting a picture of union leaders playing politics.

This is raw politics. And while I recognize that unions and teachers deserve to be as critically assessed as the other elements of our current failing school district, pretending like there's nothing but good intentions among the leaders of the current and most recent reform effort is Crap, with a capital "C."

zqxz
zqxz

Finally (48 hours) time limit to buy.

LV Muffler $ 5.99LV Bags $ 19.9 LV Wallet $ 6.55Armani Glasses $ 5.99LV Belt $ 6.9

Buy addresses---- tntn.usTips (48 hours after the special product is invalid)

rdsathene
rdsathene

What a cowardly and despicable article this is.

K. Osobesso
K. Osobesso

http://la.indymedia.org/news/2...

Is anything this guy says about Ms. Flores true? I don't understand these people. The more they hide behind phrases like we're doing it for the kids, the more they're doing it for the cash.

Cferrb
Cferrb

If the LA Weekly can't get a simple fact like where Huntington Park High School is located, i.e. the independent city of Huntington Park, I'm not sure how much else of this article I can believe.

spectatus
spectatus

so, teachers union fight the idea for her school plan, but then give in. Flores gets what she wants, and then leaves for a fancier gig.

Why is the whole slant of the article that the teachers union was the major obstructionist, when there's as yet no basis to believe Flores' plan and implementation is a godsend?

mwalimu
mwalimu

Yolie Flores' inspiration, St Mel's with its 100 % college acceptance rate merits some deeper examination.

First of all what is St. Mel's rejection rate? Shouldn't the number of students a charter school rejects count as its rejection rate. If a successful charter graduates 100 % of its students, but rejects 75 % of the students who apply, its drop out rate is not 0 % - it's 75%. While a school like HP has a disturbing drop-out rate, bear in mind that it HP is accepting everyone, including the students charter schools don't want to teach.

In addition, since St. Mel's is or was associated with the Catholic church, are gay and lesbian students welcome there? Might St. Mel's practice its own version of Jim Crow. In addition, how many students with "special needs' does St. Mel's accept? Or does St. Mel's simply dump the students with special needs on to the near-by public schools? Is it fair for St. Mel's to crow about its successes and trash public schools, when in fact public schools accept all of St. Mel's rejects?

Finally, has it occurred to Yolie Flores that some students don't want to go to college? Has it occurred to Yolie Flores that some students might do better as plumbers, electricians, or even garbage collectors or custodians? And before any one sneers too much, let me ask you how long LA would survive without garbage pick-up? Yolie Flores seems to forget what Martin Luther King, Jr. said about custodians. She also forgets that Martin Luther King die fighting for collective bargaining rights for trash collectors.

. As a board member, Yolie Flores is partially responsible for LAUSD's high dropout rate - simply because she is fixated on every student getting college diploma - whether these students want to go to college or not.

All this said, we really need to rethink educational reform and charter schools. We don't need more college preparatory academies. Magnet programs have existed in 1979. Many of these programs are quite successful. Why should charter schools compete for the same pool of students.

Instead, let LAUSD, members of labor unions and the business community conduct a survey to determine with fields will have the greatest demand for skilled workers, vocational fields that require more technical training, but not a college degree.

Once this is done, let's shut down all the college-prep charters and replace them with vocational prep charters. Perhaps some could offer journeymen programs supervised by unions. Let's create charter schools for students who are not doing well in academic programs and not performing well on standardized tests. Let's provide these students with viable and rewarding alternatives to the A-G UC requirements.

Everyone would profit from this suggestion. By transferring lower performing students to charters, public schools could lower their drop-out rates and raise their AIP scores. Students in vocational charter schools would have reasons for staying in school and would be rewarded with promising, quality careers.

Yolie Flores' failure to understand my proposals prove the incompetency of both Yolie Flores and Ramon Cortines. It also proves that both the charter schools and the school reform movement are frauds.

Hgrosenbloom
Hgrosenbloom

Excellent points. One of the biggest mistakes LAUSD made was that in fall 2003 they got rid of Basic Math in high school and made Algebra One mandatory for graduation (along with geometry!) This was supposed to be compensation for all those decades in which Latinos were allegedly funnelled into woodworking instead of academics. But you don't alleviate an historical injustice with a second bad decision. Now you have the grotesque spectacle of Algebra One classes in which 33 students have no background or motivation and three students actually could learn algebra but get little instruction because the teacher is managing the 33 recalcitrants. I know this happens because I was that teacher last year.

rdsathene
rdsathene

I direct your attentions to the video featuring the individual of your obsequious attentions in this piece at the end of my article:

http://rdsathene.blogspot.com/...

Let your readers decide if Flores was, as you say "harangued," by the Huntington Park HS community, or if Flores was being evasive, obtuse, and dishonest.

Anyone watching the video will immediately realizes it's the latter, not the former. To write a piece lauding this woman, who has caused so much damage, goes beyond irresponsible, it's insidious.

K. Osobesso
K. Osobesso

Why are Ms. Flore's critics so vehemently against her policies and seemingly very mean-spirited?

Have you seen this guy's articles on her? http://j.mp/i1NHZS

What do people have against corporations taking over schools anyway. They do lots of things well, look at the housing market. Anyway, I wish people would stop judging Ms. Flores on her actions and just listen to her words.

Carol Perry
Carol Perry

Huntington Park High School is in the City of Huntington Park, not in East L.A.Carol Perry

K. Osobesso
K. Osobesso

Why are Ms. Flore's critics so vehemently against her policies and seemingly very mean-spirited?

Have you seen this guy's articles on her?

http://j.mp/i1NHZS

What do people have against corporations taking over schools anyway. They do lots of things well, look at the housing market.

Anyway, I wish people would stop judging Ms. Flores on her actions and just listen to her words.

Dsievers
Dsievers

As a teacher at Huntington Park High School who also sympathizes with the feelings and frustrations of Ms. Flores, I wrote the Huntington Park Community in Partnership plan, one of the three plans currently under consideration for H.P.

Teachers and administrators and plans come and go, but the community will always be there. That's why I wrote a reform plan to give H.P. to the parents - and the parents love the idea. That's the only way H.P. will truly get fixed: when there's a board of directors for H.P. and parents are on that board and can cast votes that mean something. The Huntington Park Community in Partnership Plan is the only one that does that. You can read all three plans here: http://publicschoolchoice.laus...

If you are an H.P. parent, guardian or community member, come out and cast an advisory vote for one of the plans in the cafeteria on Thursday, March 17 from 3-8 p.m. and Saturday, March 19, 9-12 a.m.

rdsathene
rdsathene

Had the author done any research, like a real journalist, they wouldn't have made the erroneous statement about "explicitly prohibited for-profits" in trying to defend the vile Flores-Aguilar against "The argument was that [she] was giving away schools to the private sector."

Since 501C3 non-profits, are corporations by definition (that's what the C in 501C3 stands for), they are the private sector. Every time a public school is handed over to a CMO (Charter Management Organization), or other 501C3, they are be given to the private sector.

Now she is moving full time to her current employer, The Gates Foundation. Your gushing servile mention of the convicted predatory monopolist, Bill Gates, doesn't paint an accurate picture of what the plutocrat's role has been in school privatization circles:

Gates Document Details Plans for Influence Peddling and Propaganda War for Corporate Edhttp://www.schoolsmatter.info/...

Who's striking out and who's sliding home?http://nycpublicschoolparents....

The repugnant member of Broad/Gates/Walton Triumvirate's (http://dissentmagazine.org/art... agenda, like that of the like minded Phillip Anschutz and the Koch Brothers, is clear. Flores-Aguilar serves that agenda, and no amount of spin about "putting children first" vapidness you write.

A perfect example of Flores-Aguilar's duplicity and mendaciousness can be found here:

http://rdsathene.blogspot.com/...

The best part of this "article" is how it ends with a quote from the racist poverty pimp Ben Austin. How much of a pariah is the wealthy Austin in our communities? He recently made the "Crooks and Liars" website.http://crooksandliars.com/john...

Mazusc
Mazusc

why is jill stewart commenting. what kind of objectivity does the la weekly have when they staffer and bosses publicly congrats each each other

Hgrosenbloom
Hgrosenbloom

"Gutsy reformer." More like "Betrayer of a trust." Her official title is "trustee." The people of Los Angeles trusted her with their schools, and she gave some of them away! The analogy: My dad asked me to feed and water his cat while he went out of town for four days. If I were Yolie Flores, he would come back to find the cat gone, and my explanation would be that a friend of a friend decided he really wanted a cat and could give the cat a better home, so there went the cat! From cats back to schools: we keep hearing cries for "reform," but the subtext is that if the teachers feel insecure enough they will work their hearts out. I teach intermediate algebra in an LAUSD high school and potential job threats are not making me a better teacher for students who are put in algebra without background or motivation. They are making me angry, frustrated, cynical, and open to ways to game the system. Teachers are a beautifully convenient scapegoat for a society that imported a prolific, non-academic population and does not know what to do with it and is afraid it will overrun us. That's what needs to be discussed, not further envisioning of charters in which willowy 23-year-old girls will work miracles while burning themselves out.

kafka
kafka

Yolie is not a reformer. She destroys schools without even stepping on campus. She is a bully who likes to bully just because she can.

Richard Lavin
Richard Lavin

I know Al Castillo, the principal of HP, and can not believe he said the words attributed to him by your reporter. Did anyone ask him for a comment before going to print?

Mandell Jason
Mandell Jason

Hi Richard. I'm the reporter and I want to answer your question. Yes, Al Castillo was asked to comment for the story. He chose not to. In case you missed it, the fifth paragraph of the article says:

"Castillo didn't respond to multiple requests from L.A. Weekly for an interview."

-Jason Mandell

Steve Scanlan
Steve Scanlan

The History lesson is a bit akimbo in this fairy tale. Jaime Escalante, like many teachers, had success in Garfield before there was a huge influx of low-functioning ELL students at that school, and left when kids stopped paying attention to his lectures and Washington beckoned with new opportunities. As the Church Lady would say, "How convenient." You can look it up or talk to teachers who were at Garfield and knew the man and the economics of the neighborhood. Before you put a laurel wreath on Ms. Flores' head, note that the students who met her with at the Parent Center were largely academic successes at the school. Many who spoke in the teachers' defense are bound for UC schools and were defending the teachers who helped them get there. Ms. Flores passion for improving education in HP is I'm sure heart-felt, but like many of the wonderful reformers we see dotting our landscape like toad stools after a Summer rain, she never spent a day in the classroom. I do. I taught in Mexico and in the US, and believe me, there are many excellent and committed teachers at HPHS who care very much about the kids who try to overcome a tough background in a poor neighborhood where English isn't even a necessity. Ms. Flores earned her enmity by making lightning visits to our school, spending as little time as possible in front of the teachers, and returning to the safe confines of Beaudry to make plans and recommendations for the school's restructuring. Ironically, the quality of teachers has declined in recent years due to the incredible scrutiny, pressure and pig-headedness of the LAUSD leadership, who has seen fit to punish without reward. Anybody who knows anything about education knows that the carrot is mightier than the stick. By the way, Ms. Flores will be earning far more money than any teacher can conceive of with the Gates Foundation. It's easy to preach from above.

Jill Stewart
Jill Stewart

Thanks for your comments Steve. One factual correction about the history at Garfield, however: Jaime Escalante did not leave when "kids stopped paying attention to his lectures."

Escalante and Ben Jiminez, both left in 1991 when the calculus program they had built over a decade's time was still going strong. The classes were packed, and high numbers of kids were passing the AP exam, when Escalante and Jiminez quit.

For a few more years after the two left, the math program at Garfield survived with impressive results.

Teacher Angelo Villavicencio, who modeled his work on Escalante's, taught all 107 of Garfield's advanced calculus students. Villavicencio was excellent, though not quite at Escalante's level: 76 of Villavicencio's students took the AP exam and 47 passed. Still a major achievement for both the students and the teacher.

But when Villavicencio asked the new Garfield principal to add a third class so he could get his class sizes below 40, the principal refused -- yet also tried to move Villavincencio from from the big Music Hall class where he was teaching 55 kids at a time. Villavincencio quit Garfield, and went on to build a strong math program in Chino.

Escalante, meanwhile, built a strong calculus program at a school near Sacramento, but by that time Escalante did not have a decade (as he enjoyed at Garfield, under the support of talented principal Henry Gradillas) to reach the levels seen at Garfield.

Thanks for reading, Steve.

-Jill Stewart, LA Weekly news editor

mwalimu
mwalimu

Yoli Flores forgets Miller's law, named after yours truly: The success of a charter school is directly proportional the number of students it rejects plus the length of the waiting list.

This rule applies to St Mel's school in Chicago. This rule would definitely apply to the school that Flores proposed for Huntington Park. In addition to hand-picking its students, Flores charter would evaluate its students on the basis of projects that students complete, not test scores. This is not a luxury that regular high schools enjoy. Even if test scores rise, if they do not rise high enough, schools are turned over to charters and teachers lose their jobs. This might be one reason for union opposition.

In an article by Howard Blume pubished today in the Los Angeles Times, Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa exorted charter schools to accept more "hard-to-educate" children. However, once charters do this, they simply become public schools with another name.

Let's face it Yolie Flores is all about the Benjamins, student's really don't count very much

mwalimu
mwalimu

Jason Mandell's article is a text book case of bad journalism. I saw little attempt to interview Julie Washington, teachers at HP High School, the principal, or Jerry Duffy. Why? Also, Mandell fails to check out the enrollment of Hunting Park High School, or whether it's a single track school or a multi-track monstrosity. How many teachers have their own classrooms? How many techers have to float or rove from classroom to classroom? Perhaps over-crowding might have something to do with the drop-out rate.

In any rate, if teachers at HP are so lousy, why Yolie Flores face an angry confrontation by students. Were they afraid that Flores would fire their favorite teachers?

Mandell's article is an excellent example of the shoddy journalism that has transpired ever since L A Weekly changed ownership. Why should we believe anything L A Weekly has to say?

Mandell Jason
Mandell Jason

To respond to your comment, mwalimu, I made plenty of attempts to interview A.J. Duffy, Julie Washington, and the principal at HP, Al Castillo. None of them wanted to be interviewed. I made this clear in the story, but in case you missed it, here are some quotes from the article:

"Castillo didn't respond to multiple requests from L.A. Weekly for an interview."

"[Duffy] didn't respond to the Weekly's request for an interview, and his PR rep responded that teachers union officials are tired of talking to the press.)"

And while this story did not attempt to explain everything that's happening at HP, I'll try to answer some of your other questions about the school.

-Yes, overcrowding is an issue at HP. That's one reason many think the school should be divided into smaller academies. Yet, despite the problem of overcrowding, lots of teachers and students at HP are opposed to the idea of dividing up the school.

-I didn't hear any students express a concern that their favorite teachers will be fired. The different plans being discussed for HP do not involve firing teachers. And as a school board member, Flores would not be directly involved in firing specific teachers anyway.

I hope that answers some of your questions.

-Jason Mandell

Philip Keller
Philip Keller

Yolie's ideas about small schools will do NOTHING about overcrowding. To relieve overcrowding you need more space not more divisions of existing space. It will probably aggravate the problem by creating more expensive administrators who need their own space for offices.

Mandell's article is an extremely distorted picture of HPHS. It isn't journalism at all, but more of a love poem to Ms. Yolie Flores who deserves no adoration. I talked to him for forty minutes on the phone about our situation at this school, but he chose to use none of the information I gave him. I believe Ms. Flores was probably the final editor here.

Anthony Krinsky
Anthony Krinsky

Yolie, you rock. It must be utterly exhausting being an advocate for children on the LAUSD school board. I wish the whole board would resign and every school would be become independently run and competing for students. PSC is wonderful but still depends on the political process that is its nemesis, for life.

P.R. Keller
P.R. Keller

A brave and lonely warrior? Wasn't that Don Quixote chasing windmills? Ms. Yolie Flores is an amazing woman - undaunted by her own ignorance of educational issues and blindly committed to an ideology that blames teachers for the problems of urban schools. The district would have faired better with Joe the Plumber in her place. Joe probably would have had the even minded temperament to ask the people who are at the schools what their problems are rather than trying to waltz in and tell them what to think. What degrees does she have in this area? What teaching experience does she have? Absolutely none.

Bill Gates abandoned the idea of small schools as the solution for troubled urban schools many months ago. I guess the news never reached Ms. Flores. Poverty and all the problems that come with it - that's the problem. If you replace all the teachers, nothing will change.

David Lyell
David Lyell

This glowing, one-sided article fails to mention a sixth component contributing to the lack of student achievement: poverty. 60 Minutes did a story Sunday night about how 14 million children in the US are now living in poverty. That number will shortly jump to 16 million. It is poverty, and not teacher quality, that is holding our students back. But these supposed "reformers" don't have any innovative ideas on how to address any of this, other than to put the schools up for sale to the highest bidder.

UTLA Members, If you want change in this election, vote for Warren Fletcher for UTLA President, Ana Valencia for NEA Vice President, Juan Ramirez for Elementary Vice President, Scott Johnson for Treasurer, and David Lyell for UTLA Secretary. Fighting for your pay, fighting for your benefits, protecting your job, and protecting your retirement. For more information, www.davidlyell.blogspot.com. Thank you for your consideration. David

The information herein represents the views and opinions of the candidate and does not necessarily represent or reflect the opinions of UTLA.Paid for by the Committee to Elect David Lyell

 
©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city