Top

music

Stories

 

Henry Rollins: The Column!

Plastic fantastic: why vinyl still matters

Last week I was at El Compadre, sitting across from my editor, one Gustavo Turner. He handed me an Amoeba Records bag and said the contents was a gift that he hoped I would like. I reached in and pulled out an LP by the Argentine tango master Astor Piazzolla. The LP, titled Suite Troileana, was one I had never heard before. I looked forward to the evening to get that platter spinning.

Hours later, there I was, sitting happily in front of my Wilson Sophia 3 speakers, soaking up every drop of this exquisite album. It was a perfect experience. At some point during side 2, I remembered what Gustavo asked of me. Memo from Turner: Deliver some writing on music, something that captures your enthusiasm. By the time the Astor LP had come to an end, I had the idea for what to write about.

Wonderful readers, pardon me while I wax euphoric about the simple and complete joy of listening to music from a vinyl source.

As I write to you now, I am listening to a pristine Canadian pressing of Television's absolutely perfect Marquee Moon album. It is, to me, as good as music gets. The title track is one of the best things ever committed to magnetic tape. While the recently remastered CD version is excellent, there is but one way to truly enjoy the utter magnificence of the songs contained on this album and it is from the LP. Those of you who know what I'm talking about know exactly what I mean.

Yes, yes, y'all, it's not hipster, elitist hype — vinyl sounds better. Much better. There is actual music in those grooves. Technically speaking, there is no music whatsoever on a CD. Lots of information but no music. Digital technology has made great strides to deliver a series of numbers to be read by a laser to emit that which is doing its damnedest to replicate its analog and sonically superior master. There are some very good CD players out there that sound incredible. I recommend the Rega Isis valve version, but even that cannot capture the full-bloom soundscape of your turntable interacting with an LP or single.

As an LP spins, your needle goes on the musical journey with you, traveling great distances as it deftly picks up the analog information and delivers the sonic message to you in real time. Vinyl is the people, a CD is The Man.

Oh! Do you know that guitar breakdown right before the snare comes back in at the very end of Marquee Moon to end side A? That moment never fails to move me. It just happened. Tom Verlaine, one of the great guitarists of all time. What a moment!

Since I was very young, the playing of the vinyl has been one of the most enjoyable rituals of my existence. It was Beatles records at first and, as I grew older, Zeppelin, Hendrix, Isaac Hayes, Aerosmith, Nugent, Van Halen, Stones and the like.

And then, in my very impressionable later teenage years, in came the noise that would start a revolution in my mind that I have never been able to quell. The Clash, Ramones, The Sex Pistols, Buzzcocks, Devo, The Saints, The Damned, The Adverts and many others, all fitting somewhat together under the umbrella of punk rock and independent music. It was these bands that turned me into the record store–haunting album obsessive that I am now, decades later.

Some of these albums, I have no idea how many times I have played them. Their digital descendants don't sound the same and leave me wanting. I have had some of these LPs for well over half of my life. I know every crack and pop on them. Those surface noises are, to me, as much a part of the music as the songs themselves and give the music some textural perfection that digital sterility simply cannot achieve.

I am now listening to Hawkwind's Doremi Fasol Latido LP, released on United Artists in 1972. Amazing! A masterpiece. I don't know how I am going to get to sleep tonight. I just want to stay up and listen to music.

I have a lot of compact discs. I need them for radio play, and convenience. Many bands and artists I am a fan of don't always release their work on vinyl, so I take what they feel like giving me.

Sitting in a room, alone, listening to a CD is to be lonely. Sitting in a room alone with an LP crackling away, or sitting next to the turntable listening to a song at a time via 7-inch single, is enjoying the sublime state of solitude.

To burn a CDR of music you like to give as a gift to someone you wish to become closer to is a cold, moist-palmed, mouth-breathing bummer. A tape made from albums and singles, constructed in real time, every track representing a separate and careful needle drop, says a real heart indeed beats inside this body and, baby, it beats for you.

There may be, at the back of one of your closets, a stack of your old and forgotten albums. I suggest you rescue them from obscurity and reconnect with your inner analog self. The brain remaps, the ears quickly adjust, all of your cells wonder what took you so long.

1 | 2 | Next Page >>
 
  • 08/11/2011 8:56:00 AM

    Are you the same I.Miller that plays Bass up in Norcal? The bass player I am talking about reminds me of Sid Vicious. You know?/! Best heard when not ''plugged in''.

  • Princess 07/12/2011 9:22:00 PM

    ipods for american idol lovers .....lol i take my vinyl anytime .just got the new double lp from thievery corporation and on my clear audio turntable with benz needle it sounds like i am with them in a studio .CD's dont even sell anymore ! and to that hick ian miller - go screw yourself !lol

  • Audiomaven 04/10/2011 3:59:00 PM

    Amen Henry! People who are criticizing you have never set foot in a studio and understand what goes on-or ever heard an LP played back on a top notch table thru a real high end system. These people sound like they're listening to a $100 table with a cartridge that should have been replaced 10 years ago. Not only that, but very few have ever heard a 15 or 30 ips master tape (and I have a bunch at home that play back through a SOTA R2R) and know what that analog medium sounds like. For if they had, they could never listen to digital. So much information missing. Everything is flat and dimensionless. And it still sounds hard. OK it's more convenient. But that's no excuse. If you take care of your LPs and clean them properly, they will last forever. I have fifty yr. old LPs that sound great. Can you say you'll be able to play you're CDs in 10 years. Probably not since they'll change the technology.

  • 03/03/2011 11:55:00 PM

    Hahah, old people.

  • 03/03/2011 10:53:00 PM

    Every word in this piece is specious and utterly ridiculous. Henry, do you even believe your own bullshit these days?

  • 03/03/2011 3:27:00 AM

    What's in the vinyl grooves is scratches. It's no more music that the ones and zeroes of a CD are. Both are models -- they need equipment to translate them into sound. Any medium of reproduction is a compromise, and all media have their limitations. "It just sounds better" is not an argument; it's assertion. 99.9999999% of the people in the world can't tell the difference between a high bitrate mp3 and a CD in a blindfold test. And surface noise is the only way 99.9999999% of the people in the world could identify a sound source as vinyl. In other words I'm calling bullshit on this, and unless you're a professional mastering engineer shut up about this hipster bullshit.

  • Guest 02/18/2011 5:59:00 AM

    Thank you Henry. When can we expect your back catalog to come out on vinyl from Rollins Band?

  • Tonepub 02/07/2011 1:32:00 AM

    As always, you hit the nail on the head, Henry. It's amazing and awesome that vinyl is still doing as well as it is in 2011. Who would have guessed? Now if only I could get a copy of Shatner's "Has Been" on LP....

  • Beefsurgeon 02/04/2011 11:53:00 PM

    I have to agree that records which were originally recorded on a tape machine and more importantly, mixed for the vinyl format, sound inarguably better on a record player. I think that music which is recorded digitally to begin with (almost all new music) tends to sound best in its native digital format. It's a matter of appreciating each piece of art within its original context.

  • BigTurtle 02/04/2011 2:56:00 AM

    Love the article. Not sure the CD is that lonely as there has been some very wonderful stuff not available on LP and some mind-boggling compilations we would have never seen in the day or now. But there is wonder in both. MP3 however, is a drag. Even good sounding ones sound weak.

  • dagny t 02/04/2011 12:38:00 AM

    Even more important, LP's were meant to be listened to as a WHOLE. No picking & choosing tracks, just 'Side 1, track1' to 'Side 2, track 13'. No one does that with CD's or mp3's. Even the bands recording them never expect people to listen to every song in order. Shame. There'll never be another 'Ziggy Stardust' or 'Dark Side of the Moon' & that really is a disgrace to music.

  • Tim 02/03/2011 11:02:00 PM

    One more thing...you've inspired me to check out Television. I'm embarrassed to say I've never heard them.

  • Tim 02/03/2011 10:58:00 PM

    Seriously...this is the best thing I've read in ages. Thank you Henry! A lot of us feel the same way you do. I have slowly come around to appreciating MP3s for what they are, which is basically an approximation of the music, for the sake of portability and convenience. That's fine for the gym, as they won't let me bring my turntable in, but damn I wish they would. I've always been a vinyl guy but after upgrading my turntable a couple of years ago I'm crazier than ever about records. My old records sound better than ever and I'm finding some amazing stuff in record stores and thrift shops. No format will ever surpass the record, as far as I'm concerned.

  • 02/03/2011 8:45:00 PM

    I don't dispute much of what is being argued, however steeped in romance (very). I find the swipe "Sitting in a room, alone, listening to a CD is to be lonely" unfair. I assume the disdain for listening to this format only extends/intensifies in re mp3s. And my experience is that to listen to mp3 files via quality headphones (gasp!) is to enjoy the "sublime state of solitude" that he experiences with vinyl. This way of listening, at least to me, is the ultimate in creating hermetic psychic space for oneself. More preposterous, though, is the idea that in the year twenty-eleven one might set about constructing mixes on compact cassette. All mixes made for others by this commenter for the past fifteen years, whether on magnetic tape or polycarbonate, are constructed with the same meticulous care and love. It's about the message, not the medium. The turntable, to the best of my knowledge, does not handle the irregularities of the aging 110 freeway so well. And sadly the laws of gravity currently prevent its smooth operation when worn as a backpack while I clean my bathroom and clothes. However I have found that my tampon-sized digital player with its iniquitous compressed content is well suited to these tasks. So when it comes to convenience, immediacy and portability, I will take the simulacrum over the real thing any day. Just one woman's opinion.

 

Most Popular Stories

Find a Concert

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy