By Anthony D'Alessandro
By Catherine Wagley
By Amanda Lewis
By Catherine Wagley
By Channing Sargent
By L.A. Weekly critics
By Amanda Lewis
By Catherine Wagley
There have now been at least four attempts by theatrical producers to stage Randy Newman's songs as a cabaret-revue. Among the reasons for Newman's appeal to theater producers is the character-driven essence of so many of his songs, creating a kind of bridge made of rope between pop and musical theater. Yet his most piquant, probing and soulful songs are not those that made him famous, which is more a comment on us than on him. Newman's fame comes from a combination of his music-industry family (three uncles who were film-score composers); his soundtracks for such films as Ragtime, Awakenings and Disney's Toy Story series; and a couple of pop hits, "Short People" and "I Love L.A." — both of which are testosterone-fueled parodies of, respectively, bigotry and absurd civic jingoism. The ironies were lost on entire swaths of adoring fans, including the L.A. City Council, which named "I Love L.A." the city's official song — despite lyrics, cheerfully shouted, such as: "Look at that bum over there/He's down on his knees/Look at these women! ..."
When he's at his best, Newman conjures and compresses just a handful of perfectly crafted lines spoken by characters who may be too delicate, too multifaceted and too filled with internal contradictions for a culture bent on reduction. On his album Good Old Boys, dedicated to the mind-set of the Deep South, a song called "Wedding in Cherokee County" summarizes the apprehension of a groom staring adoringly at his soon-to-be wife:
"Her papa was a midget/Her mama was a whore/Her granddad was a newsboy 'til he was 84 (and what a slimy old bastard he was)/Man don't you think I know she hates me/Don't you think I know she's no good/If she knew how she'd be unfaithful to me/I think she'd kill me if she could/Maybe she's crazy, I don't know/Maybe that's why I love her so."
Newman sings this plaintively and without a glimmer of judgment. Without a stage setting or a libretto swirling around it, the song shines a laser beam onto one character's soul, a character who could have been plucked from any number of plays by Tennessee Williams, or any number of novels by William Faulkner. No wonder theater producers salivate when they hear such music.
Paradoxically, more often than not, when musical-theater actors start crooning Newman's songs, they follow bigger-than-life instincts, which lead to parodies of such characters. At least, this is what happened at the Roxy in the early 1980s, when Des McAnuff staged a revue of Randy Newman songs as a warm-up for La Jolla Playhouse's 1983 revue, The Education of Randy Newman.
It also happened to a lesser degree in 2000, when South Coast Repertory gave its stage to the Newman oeuvre, in a show that borrowed one of the songwriter/composer's typically sardonic titles, Maybe I'm Doing It Wrong.
(A recent L.A. Times story miscredited these shows at the wrong theaters — misinformation that's now been picked up by numerous websites and blogs.)
After hearing the title cut from Newman's recent album Harps and Angels, musical theater scholar Jack Viertel pitched the Mark Taper Forum a revue, named after that album. The smart and absorbing result, just opened at the Music Center and directed by Jerry Zaks (musical staging by Warren Carlyle), is a huge relief for the potholes it avoids. The game ensemble (Ryder Bach, Storm Large, Adriane Lenox, Michael McKean, Katey Sagal and Matthew Saldivar) hits more moments of authenticity and of Newman's looming perspective than in prior Newman revues, thanks in large part to Zaks' empathy for the songs' narrator-subjects, the cast's restraint and intelligence, and the terrific eight-piece orchestra (conducted by pianist Michael Roth; orchestrations by Roth and David O). The musicians sit parked elevated behind the stage, while moving panels expose or conceal them behind projections (by Marc I. Rosenthal) that are sometimes abstract, sometimes literal — streetscapes of New Orleans and Los Angeles. (Stephan Olson designed the set.)
Large's deft and wistful rendition of "Real Emotional Girl" — so plucked from the marrow — reveals how underused she is through the rest of the revue.
The production's strengths come from wry understatement, particularly by Newman stand-in McKean, who croons later songs that reflect themes of mortality, the pathetic humor of a guy humiliating himself ("Shame") by trying to buy back his lost youth from a stripper (Large), and the long-view wisdom that comes with age. In safari dress (costumes by Stephanie Kerley Schwartz), McKean's nicely modulated rendition of "Sail Away" is a pitch by a slave trader to Africans on their continent (whose projected faces loom overhead) on the virtues of a new life in America. ("We will cross the mighty ocean into Charleston Bay.") The music is unutterably, swooningly romantic, juxtaposed against his unutterably barbaric agenda. The vision comes from the horrifying intersection of the music and the lyrics, and McKean knows well enough to leave it alone. Ditto the glorious Lenox, who sings a reprise; her being black doubles the irony.
Also scintillating is when Newman's original intent gets reversed with an updated insight. For example, "You Can Leave Your Hat On" reveals the sexual fetish of a man ordering a woman to strip. Here, it's gender-reversed so that the sex object is a woman's boy-toy.