Top

news

Stories

 

When White Writers Do “Latino” Issues

Crime and Punishment
It was chaos this week in the Weekly’s virtual mailroom, which received a deluge of reactionary attitude in regard to Christine Pelisek’s cover story “Chaos in the Casitas: Lawless, south of the border–style speakeasies get a grip on L.A.” (Nov. 4). The piece details the growth of small clubs called casitas in areas like South Gate that allegedly parlay a rather relaxed sense of morality — drug use, prostitution, the usual.

One young “B-girl” associated with a particular casita was murdered. And when law enforcement raided that club, the Weekly was invited along. A number of readers were not amused, but for differing reasons.

Someone signing themselves L.A. Weekly=RACISM writes in very large letters: “THESE STORIES ARE WHAT HAPPEN WHEN THE L.A. WEEKLY HAS NO LATINO WRITERS OR STAFFERS. ‘SOUTH OF THE BORDER–STYLE’? GIVE ME A BREAK!!!” No need to yell, L.A. Weekly=RACISM. Or is there?

“This article is disgusting,” adds Bob from L.A. “I am shocked that the L.A. Weekly allowed it. [It reflects] a complete lack of understanding of the culture and status of illegal aliens and Hispanics in this country. These bars are illegal, but it is an issue for zoning and the state beverage control, and not the LAPD, state and federal agents. These cops should be protecting good citizens instead of busting illegals for minor drug offenses.

“This country encouraged the illegals to come here and fails to properly deal with them now. Using military-style police for this issue is crazy. The decriminalization of drugs, the deportation of illegals and the proper cleanup of our city would [make for] a better article than trying to justify the police raids that accomplish nothing.

“The reporter tried to connect the horrible murder of the lady to the bars. The real story is the failure of the government in being able to identify aliens in this country and track them and control their deportation.”

Illegal from Costa Mesa piles it on: “Oh, geez, how come this white girl doesn’t write about her ‘white sisters’ getting gangbanged on video for porno out in San Fernando Valley? What about all the social decay that creates? Oh, yeah, I forgot it’s okay when whites do it.”

But several readers were more disturbed by the casitas themselves.

“The issue with the casitas as I see it isn’t that folks go there to drink and hang out in a culturally appropriate way,” writes Marc from Los Angeles. “It’s the trafficking in women, guns and drugs — the associated violence and murders.

“Whatever your cultural background, those make it a police matter, and Pelisek’s incredibly well-written story shows not only that but also the complexity and richness of the culture around them.”

Jan from Los Angeles has more: “Why is it that when someone is bold enough to write about a problem affecting us in South L.A. all the others who don’t live here and run away from this area scream racism? Then I beg you to let the casitas take their illegal activities to your neighborhoods.

“It’s not just casitas, many of the illegal immigrants now have loud parties in their yards with flashing strobe lights keeping everybody up at night. The sole purpose of many of these activities is to sell drugs and alcohol. They charge people to come in and set up just like a club and the police never respond to noise complaints unless you tell them that there are gangs involved.

“We the decent, hardworking homeowners of South L.A. who did not run away from the city are suffering. So I don’t want to hear any of you talk about racism. Let’s talk about how this City Council has sent our city into decay. Let’s talk about the lack of police response to all these noisy parties in people’s yards. Write on, L.A. Weekly. And I don’t care about the race of the writer. Thank God someone is finally addressing our problems.”

And then there are the Latino readers turning all these charges of racism on their head:

“So much ignorance all over the place,” laments Latin Guy from Los Angeles. “Since when are Latinos a race? There are black, white, East Asian, Indian (American) and mixed Latinos. And since when do reporters have to match the genetic, national or cultural makeup of the subjects they cover?”

“Racism? This article is painful for a Latino and Mexican-American to read. But it is not racism,” comments FSL from Pasadena. “What is racist is the corrupt, very white Mexican elite that forces so many of its people into abject poverty. Take a look at Spanish-language TV to see how the racial caste system works throughout Latin America. The casitas are at the lower end of the caste system that is being imported into the U.S. and they serve a purpose for the Mexican cartels that are operating more and more brazenly.

1 | 2 | Next Page >>
 
  • sandrita m 11/22/2009 6:59:00 AM

    Jan from Los Angeles, I kmow exactly what you're going through. As a lifelong urban dweller, I moved to northeast Los Angeles some years ago thinking that such a move would yield the same positive experience I'd had in other metropolitan neighborhoods. With a high percentage of home owners on the block, I naively thought they would maintain standards of decorum. After all, real estate contracts require disclosure of noise problems. I was soon disabused of that notion as every weekend one homeowner or another kept the neighorhood awake with pounding, stadium-grade speakers blasting music on weekend nights. My first reaction was to talk with the offending party. Decent people wouldn't want their behavior to cause someone distress, I thought. But, that reasoning went in one ear and out the other. So, like Jan, I resorted to calling LAPD. Most times they did show up-after two hours. The noise would stop for a while and then start up again. Tired of being at war with my neighbors, I eventually moved away. So have many others,as detailed in Rich Benjamin's new book, WHITOPIA. At a recemt book signing, Benjamin resignedly spoke of his own impression of latinos "They're just loud!!

  • E AG 11/20/2009 12:52:00 AM

    This story is told entirely from the perspective of law enforcement and the few folks in the area who spoke English. It's demeaning to Latinos and immigrants not because the writer is white but because she clearly allows herself to get swept into the generalizations and wide statements about immigrants fed to her by the police. It is extremely disappointing that the writer did not, in all of that copy, introduce readers to any B-girls or patrons of the illegal clubs. This tells me the writer does not speak Spanish or did not ask for someone to translate for her. It's unacceptable to report a story without talking to and sharing the perspective of both sides. The reporter allows the officers to make big statements about the patrons and women in the clubs without verifying any of this herself or at least giving readers insight into the mindset of the women and men who frequent these after-hours clubs. She also made statements about this being rampant in the countries where immigrants originate without giving factual data. It may be true that these types of clubs exist in other countries but are they legal? Do they operate in a different way? Or are these clubs a product of how undocumented immigrants are here without families and are already living a life in shadows that gangs and others are able to take advantage of them by hosting these clubs? The reporter is verbose and descriptive but in some ways that only enhances the perspective of the officers and it shows how unfamiliar she is with the Latino community. In particular it shows when she allows the officers to make statements about the Hispanic culture and "going to hell" or that "they" don't report things etc etc. She also is not clear in who the officers are out to get. If there is that much drugs was there a big drug bust in which a lot of drugs were confiscated? Or are they going after the gangs and mafia who allegedly are making money from the clubs? Or is it about the patrons and women? This story could have been a public service if it explored all the sides of the story and educated readers about the different parties involved and how each benefits or takes advantage of the underground system. Instead it feeds the hysteria around immigrants and gives the police a platform for their wide-sweeping views and stereotypes. ex

  • Brittanicus 11/19/2009 11:18:00 PM

    The lobbyists for the open border, business consortium's are deviously careful not to mention E-Verify, that discrepancies can be resolved at the Social Security agencies? Nor do they inform of the success rate of E-Verify, the fed immigration tool identifying illegal labor. These entities were nearly successful through the intervening Sen. Harry Reid (D-NV), with support from majority speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) to crush the computer verification program. Unfortunately, E-Verify may become obsolete if they pass Comprehensive Immigration Reform, that will legitimize 20 to 30 million illegal immigrants? Plus it's being kept in the dark, that millions more will pour across our undermanned border, or from across the world, once they get the word that AMNESTY is about to commence? We will be donating taxpayers dollars to support the poorest of families, with little or no education. Taxpayer will be paying for the old and sick person, mentally handicapped and those who need surgery who reaches American soil. It will be the--SAME-- nightmare as the1986 immigration bill (IRCA) all over again, when 3 million materialized into 5.3 million and those working in agriculture disappeared, to enter the mainstream of US working class. Unless we put a stop to another BLANKET AMNESTY now--the impoverished, the criminals will keep coming--forever. Grade your policy makers at NUMBERSUSA? Read about Capitol corruption at JUDICIAL WATCH, ALIPAC, CAPSWEB, AMERICAN PATROL & THE DARK SIDE OF ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION. What can you do for AMERICA?

  • nena 11/19/2009 9:22:00 AM

    The white folks that write about Latinos are probably transplants, therefore, don't know a darn thing about Latinos in California, especially in L.A. Why don't you write about yourselves? Explain to us why you think it is okay to own 6 dogs/cats and let them poop all over the sidewalks and not pick up after your pets. Explain to us why you don't think hygiene is necessary, so when you go to the market we have to smell your body funk. Explain to us why you don't eat, but smoke cigarettes and drink coffee all day long (it shows on your skin and decaying teeth that this is your daily nutrition). Explain to us why you can't stand it when we cook and I don't think it is the smell of the delicious food, but the fact that you choose to starve yourselves to stay sickly thin, therefore, your stomach starts to crave for real food, that really bothers you. I am a Mexican American, born in Los Angeles in 1958 and proud of my heritage and proud to be an American. My school years in L.A. were the best because we had outstanding teachers and lots of physical activities. Hey, maybe I should write about you folks!

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy