Top

news

Stories

 

Paving Over Playa del Rey

The last L.A. beach town and dunes still standing have a developer drooling

It could have been any other early-fall Southern California barbecue. The easygoing weather, old friends and good food in a sleepy beach town — Playa del Rey.

But partygoers were dismayed over three developments proposed by Edward M. Czuker and his company, EMC Development LLC, for the heart of the community. The developer was said to be seeking three projects including about 148 residential units and encompassing roughly 20,000 square feet of retail.

Czuker is not known for subtle or small. He once plunked a faux–French chateau apartment complex on a stretch of Lincoln Boulevard. And he was involved in megadevelopments in Marina del Rey and Channel Islands Harbor in Ventura County. Would Czuker’s plans spell the demise of the last original beach town still standing in Los Angeles?

To look at Playa del Rey is not to look at much, at first. Real estate interests tried and failed to define the community, founded in 1901, through large-scale development projects at four pivotal points in the town’s history, says local historian David “Duke” Dukesherer. The attempts did not always work out. During the depression, Fritz Burns, general manager of a local real estate empire, was so destitute he lived in a tent.

Instead, Playa del Rey grew more or less organically. Today, it is a sliver of a town composed of nondescript architecture and mini-neighborhoods like “the Jungle,” jammed with 1950s apartments and gentrified condos a stone’s throw from the beach. Up on the bluffs, more luxurious homes have taken root.

Even “the village,” as residents dub the small retail area where Czuker has two parcels, has none of the quaint visuals this designation implies on the coast. Instead, it’s ramshackle bars, funky cafés and squat little stores.

Residents, however, see the 11,000-person town differently. “It’s kind of a little gem, this little beach village we have,” says Marcia Hanscom, an environmentalist. “People enjoy the beach and the wetlands, but it’s a quiet little town during the evenings.”

With swank Manhattan Beach to its south, the skyscrapers of Marina del Rey to its north, and the insta-city of Playa Vista to its east, the area has still got that hometown feel.

“You can walk down the street and say hi to neighbors and friends,” says Lance Williams, who, 13 years ago, purchased Playa del Rey Florists, a local institution for decades.

The yearning here for livable space is, in truth, replicated all over Los Angeles, where large-scale development and mansion-ization are sweeping away communities. Mom-and-pop stores are wiped out by chains, and unique histories give way to the generic.

Joe Geever, born in neighboring Westchester, which sits atop a bluff and looks out over the Ballona wetlands, camped on Playa’s dunes as a kid. Now he’s an attorney for the Surfrider Foundation, which fights to protect the ocean.

“Playa del Rey is representative of a cultural heritage,” Geever says. “The beaches in the ’60s and ’70s were not the place for wealthy residential development. Back then, they were really attractive to people who went out and used the beach — swam and surfed.”

Until the 1970s, places like Palos Verdes were populated by those “fascinated with coastal culture,” notes Scott Hulet, who edits The Surfer’s Journal. “People who spent every waking moment they weren’t at work on the beach.” The ocean was beautiful, but also part of the fabric of life, from the black sea bass they spear-fished to the lobsters and abalone they dove for.

Hulet pegs the demise of Southern California’s beach-town lifestyle to a specific event: “I see the tipping point as being really definable — and that’s when you could no longer find abalone, in the late ’60s,” he says. Locally, the kelp beds and sea life were being wiped out by undertreated sewage, runoff and other degradation from L.A.’s burgeoning population.

“Now,” says Geever, “I’ve got a sense that people who live right on the beach in the most expensive property, they’re not there because they use those resources. They’re there because they like to look at them from inside their darkened windows.”

The notion of living closer to the natural world drew many to Playa del Rey. The Pacific lay to the west, Ballona Creek to the north, the Ballona Wetlands to the east, and a freshwater lagoon sat at its center.

“The beach was my backyard,” says Dukesherer, whose family also lived in Westchester, and spent hours on the water together. “I have a crystal-clear recollection of being on my dad’s paddleboard, with my dad. He was in awe of the ocean.”

Dukesherer became a surfer and took on that philosophy. “I learned a lot on Toes Beach — about people, respect for the water, respect for the land. You’re dealing with some pretty big waves, so you better respect the ocean and the tides. You’re trying to control them but they can control you pretty darn fast.”

1 | 2 | Next Page >>
 
  • ingrid mueller 10/28/2009 1:27:00 AM

    And here I was under the distinct impression that our Councilman Rosendahl sends approaching developers to 'the community' first, allowing us to make our impacting and environmental and historic cases, before those mostly speculative developers even apply for anything??!! Thanks for digging in. Before we'll need wetsuits. Sincerely, indeed, Ingrid Mueller 1027 Elkgrove Ave.#3 Venice, CA 90291

  • Marcia Hanscom 10/25/2009 7:03:00 AM

    As far as I can tell from reviewing the history of the Toes Beach Dunes site, it has never been for sale to the public. Several owners have sold it to new developers, but when Trust for Public Land asked the previous owners (SeaGlass) repeatedly, they continued to say it was not for sale, and then they sold it to Czucker. THIS TIME we *must* press for a willing seller to the public, and our elected officials are who we need to ask to help. They represent us.

  • mewo nix 10/24/2009 8:59:00 PM

    WHY do we have to keep up with this crap? Everyone tried to fight that ridiculous Playa Vista mess, and NOW look at the place. They THOUGHT they were going to sell them all off as condos, and now they're having PROBLEMS even RENTING them out. All over town, they build these STUPID luxury apartments/condos, but again I keep asking over and over, "WHO ARE THEY EXPECTING TO LIVE IN THEM??? HOW MANY MONEYED PEOPLE DO THEY THINK THERE REALLY ARE AROUND HERE???" People are LEAVING Los Angeles in droves, the job market stinks, and there just AREN'T as many moneyed people as these A-HOLES think. So, NOW they want to RUIN Playa Del Rey too, even though they STILL haven't been able to significantly rent out Playa Vista? Someone needs to pull this a-hole out of the equation altogether once and for all, but nobody has the nuts.

  • Ruth Lansford 10/24/2009 4:58:00 AM

    I've lived in Playa del Rey since 1960. And I've seen many plans like Czuker's come and go. Mostly go. And for good reason. The village in Playa del Rey simply can't support such intense development. This part of Playa del Rey is an island -- blocked on the north by Ballona Creek and the Marina, the east by the wetlands, the south by the airport and the west by Santa Monica Bay. There's nowhere to go, nowhere to expand, and no way to increase parking or roadways. The City of L.A. never met a variance it didn't like. I don't remember a single developer who came in with a plan that fit the code. If it hadn't been for the Coastal Commission,we would have been obliterated long ago. Why not hardship variances for neighborhoods like ours? The special conditions here are unique and they deserve respect. After all, you can't fit 10 pounds of shit in a 5-pound bag.

  • Beth Kudlicki 10/23/2009 10:58:00 PM

    Great article. One important aspect not mentioned is that this is one of the few neighborhoods left with free parking for all the inner city folks who come and use the park and enjoy the beach and lagoon on a daily basis. I have lived in the Los Angeles area for over 30 years and the last 9 in Playa del Rey have been the most neighborly!!

  • Albert 10/23/2009 9:27:00 PM

    I live in Playa del Rey and the development of the dunes would eliminate my view of the ocean. That being said, why was nothing done years ago when this land was for sale? That was the time to lobby the state to buy it and preserve it. No body did anything and now its too late. This land has always been zoned mixed residential/commercial. It was never a secret. Shame on all the historians and environmentalists that have lived here for years and figured that a private owner would just pay taxes on that land for ever. Protest loudly now so everyone can see how concerned you are and you can feel good about yourselves. But the morning the construction begins, deep down you will know that your long on self righteous indignation and short on action.

  • Jack Humphreville 10/23/2009 7:17:00 PM

    This fight to preserve the Playa del Rey neighborhood is the fight of every neighborhood in Los Angeles.

  • shane 10/23/2009 4:05:00 PM

    this is nice story as we can say that innovative topic has shown in this story . ======================== Shane http://www.socialpark.net

  • Duke 10/23/2009 2:55:00 PM

    Great job, Tibby. I sent a letter to Rosendahl. I am not plugging my own writing or anything; I just thought some of you would like to see it. Keep up the fight. http://www.examiner.com/x-4314-South-Bay-Community-Examiner~y2009m10d22-Further-Development-at-Playa-Del-Rey-An-Open-Letter

  • Lola Terrell 10/23/2009 5:18:00 AM

    Thank for this article. Great to read in the city-wide Weekly. All need to know of this impending insane development. We don't need more more development in the last few intact area of the area wide Ballona ecosystem. PDR truly is like a beachtown from the past (except for commuter speeding through at 50 mph in a 30 mph zone!). We who work and/or live there appreciate it no-end, and just like we stood up for the wetlands, when there was an agreement made between a local group, the Friends of the Ballona Wetlands, and Playa Vista to save 250 acres, where many other groups said, Wait, we can get more, and we did - over 600+ acres has been saved so far! The Friends did a lot of good work, but in the end, it didn't go nearly far enough, and others recognized that, thank them being in touch with their own true natures, and we prevailed. One of the groups involved in the care of the land is Ballona Institute, whose principals live and have offices in PDR, and who are Continually fighting the good fight to save these other areas now under threat. I work in PDR and live a few miles east. I so enjoy being able to just 'hang out' there, get to know local people, frequent their businesses (all generic and loved). We also don't want no Starbucks, MacDonalds, etc. We get all the good coffee we want from Cafe Milan and Tanners. Does Czuker Care about PDR - NO, because if he did he wouldn't think about developing on the areas he is considering. We'd rather remain as we are, a semi-funky little beach town, than get ruined by some development that isn't wanted here by most in the community. Let's keep something sacred in this profane world, just like we did a very large area of the wetlands. This little town is a throw-back to a non-gentrified time, and even many of the more well-to-do in the community do not want that to change. Help us save this wonderful little town, Los Angeles! As for slowing down traffic on Culver, and even enhancing the small-town feel, cut Culver to Two lanes from it's four, install angled parking so there is more for customers and employees which is sorely needed, and Wow, it might look inviting, having to drive more slowly, to stop along the way through for the commuters now speeding so fast and talking on their cells - they could care less. This should definitely not be a 'freeway' to the southbay. It doesn't fit, never should have happened, and those who want to speed through will just have to find another route to speed on! Thank you so much for this article. Also, just another correction, the Freshwater Marsh, was developed by Playa Vista, just a few years ago, and was never there originally. This is a salt marsh ecosystem, and would not have a contained a freshwater marsh as such. I also understand one of it's uses is for run-off the development, and that it has to be dredged/drained every few years? That is not a true restoration per se - it was added as 'mitigation' and as part and parcel of the development. It make 'look good' to some people, but when one digs deeper, they find it is a 'created/developed' feature, not a true restoration at all. SAVE THE REST OF BALLONA people! It helps global climate change (duh!) to keep OPEN SPACE. What are we about Los Angeles? Do we really want to be a model green city, or are we going to sit back in our comfort zones and let the world continue to be 'developed/paved over' by the incessant (and world destroying 'need') for more more, bigger, bigger, and most especially on super-sensitive, super-rare, super-sacred land that is Serving a Purpose on this Earth. SAVE all of BALLONA! Thank you.

  • Rob Cauffield 10/23/2009 4:38:00 AM

    Another PdR voice here. I wasn't at the meeting with the developer, but I have to ask-- does this area (Westchester/PdR) need yet another behemoth of a housing development? This Czuker sounds like another investor with deep pockets and little sense. The complex at the corner of Manchester and Lincoln on the site of the old Furama hotel -- a massive condo project that was forced to switch to apartments because of the busted economy -- is still struggling for tenants, both commercial and residential nearly a year after completion. Playa del Rey needs Czuker the same way a healthy person needs cancer. Go away and pollute another community.

  • JDH 10/23/2009 4:24:00 AM

    An article like this has been a long-time in coming for residents of Playa del Rey. Delighted to finally hear a true, balanced perspective on this issue. Thank you.

  • Cheryl 10/23/2009 3:54:00 AM

    Those of us who are fortunate to live in Playa del Rey are in a huge battle to protect this unique community, one of many battles in the grand war being fought across Los Angeles as the City allows developers to realize their high-density dreams, despite vociferous community protest. The fear for many in Playa del Rey is not change, but rather not having a say in what our community becomes. And we are not fighting just for ourselves. On any given weekend, Playa del Rey welcomes thousands of visitors to one of the few beach parks in Southern California not over-run by visionless development. At a community meeting with the developer last night, we were told that one of the three proposals, the 63 apartment, mixed-use project was a good thing for us � to cover the �blight� of the current vacant lot. It struck me that there were many steps between a vacant lot and a massive, modern behemoth � and which is truly �blight?� Well, I can plant flowers on one�

  • Mark Cappelletty 10/23/2009 12:26:00 AM

    As a proud seventeen-year-resident of Playa Del Rey, I will fight this plan until my knuckles are bloody and we force leeches like Czuker away from our communities.

  • nick 10/22/2009 11:35:00 PM

    If Rosendahls involved than its a done deal. He'll talk a good game but the developers will get what they want in the end.

  • Daymond Johnson 10/22/2009 11:12:00 PM

    This just shows no matter where you stay "the Big Money Developers still can buy members of City Hall" our "Mom-and-pop stores are been wiped out by these Big Mony Developers"

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy