Top

news

Stories

 

“But for Craigslist, Donna Might Be Alive Today”

Guilty plea this week in Southern California’s own Craigslist-connected tragedy

Click here for "Craigslist Declassified," by Bradley Campbell and Matt Snyders.

Donna Jou’s mother didn’t see the face of the man on the motorcycle who picked up her 19-year-old daughter in June 2007. He was wearing a helmet, and she was heading off to dinner from her Rancho Santa Margarita apartment. All she knew was this: Jou had said she was going to a party in Santa Monica, and the boyfriend of a friend was going to take her there.

That’s the last time a family member saw Jou. According to information posted on the memorial Web site set up by Jou’s family, a few hours after jumping onto the motorcycle, Jou called a friend in San Diego. She said she had locked herself in the bathroom of the apartment of the man who picked her up. He was freaking her out, Jou said, and he wouldn’t take the hint that she wasn’t interested in him.

The Jou family now believes that man was 36-year-old John Steven Burgess, a previously convicted sex offender. In late May or early June 2007, Jou and Burgess began exchanging messages on Craigslist. Jou’s parents said that the communication began when Burgess responded to an ad placed by Jou, an honors student enrolled at San Diego State, offering her services as a math tutor.

The day after Jou left on the motorcycle, she sent her mother some text messages. The last one read: “Battery’s dying. I’m in San Diego. Be home soon. I love you Mommy.” Her mother never heard from her again. On March 17, 2009, Los Angeles police charged Burgess with involuntary manslaughter, concealing an accidental death, and two counts of selling or transporting a concealed substance. According to the Los Angeles Times, police said that Burgess told them that Jou had overdosed on heroin and cocaine at his rented West L.A. home, and that he later dumped her body from a boat off the California coastline.

Burgess initially pleaded not guilty, but just before L.A. Weekly went to press on Wednesday, he changed his plea to guilty at a pretrial hearing in Los Angeles Central District Court. Before the guilty plea, Gloria Allred, the family’s lawyer, said the Jous were focused on finding Donna and bringing Burgess to justice. But they’re also thinking about the role Craigslist played, and haven’t ruled out a suit against the site.

“But for Craigslist, Donna might be alive today,” Allred says. “She most likely never would have met Mr. Burgess without it.”

Allred thinks that Craigslist should implement measures to detect sex offenders who use the site and either block their postings or warn others about whom they’re dealing with. The Weekly’s calls to Craig Newmark and other Craigslist spokespeople were not returned.

“[Donna’s] parents want to do whatever they can to prevent something like this from happening ever again,” Allred says. “I would hope and expect that Mr. Newmark would reach out to the family to express his condolences, and to have a conversation with the family as to how this occurred and what steps he plans to take, if any, to prevent this in the future. If he takes no such steps, I think it’s highly probable that there will be other such meetings of innocent victims with predators, with tragic results.”

 
  • Les 05/11/2009 10:10:00 AM

    This could have happened with any matching on the internet or matching up at a bar. The lying he did. The set up. The drugs in the needle he gave to her. The lack of those there calling for help. Him putting her (taking for granted dead) in his truck and taking back to her home, then deciding not and going back to his. Him taking her to the ocean on his boat. Was Donna in the wrapped up blanket, he posted the third day on the internet bed? A trophy? See Missing Persons thread on www.scaredmonkeys.net, Donna Jou. Craigslist was his medium. It made the set up, plan easier. Men and ladies don't go to parties alone, hike alone. God Bless all that suffer.

  • Kevin 05/10/2009 7:48:00 AM

    All great comments,however, let's not forget that taking responsibility for one's actions is not the American way. Blame must always be placed elsewhere and if you can get some money for it all the better. My best guess is Gloria Allred doesn't work for free.

  • Karen 05/10/2009 3:47:00 AM

    Not only did the young lady lie to her mother (not CL's fault), and fail to tell anyone exactly where she was going, along with the other mistakes mentioned here, but she is the party who placed the ad. How exactly is CL expected to prevent ads like hers from being viewed by violent offenders? Just doesn't make sense.

  • Seriously?? 05/09/2009 1:29:00 AM

    I am really beginning to feel sorry for the CL founders. What happened to this woman is really tragic, but it has everything to do with making poor decisions and nothing to do with the particular conduit for said behavior. I'm sure that grief can really shake up your perspective but I really wish this mother would stop for a moment and realize that there's a person on the other end of her accusation (Craig Newmark) and this is a pretty heavy thing to leave at his doorstep, especially when he's just trying to provide a free message board for people to sell cars/rents apartments/etc. Let's hope she comes to her senses and realizes people have to take responsibility for their actions - bad and good.

  • Fredo 05/09/2009 12:59:00 AM

    I wonder if LA Weekly would be printing this story if they were the ones that provided the same service as Craigslist to this young lady.

  • greg hartmann 05/08/2009 7:38:00 AM

    It's obvious why LA Weekly would publish this. Craigslist is really cutting into their classified advertising revenue. Follow the money!

  • Freon 05/08/2009 3:53:00 AM

    Johanna Justin-Jinich, the young woman killed in Connecticut, met her killer at a university. Were it not for those trouble-causing universities, Johanna might be alive today.

  • Jeff C. 05/08/2009 2:12:00 AM

    I wonder if the same thing was said about telephones when they were invented. Predetors could use them. I wonder where we would be without cars, the internet and cell phones. I think a lot better off.

  • Lynn 05/07/2009 11:21:00 PM

    It is unfortunate this young lady was murdered but it is obvious she lied to her mother. This 35 year old man was not the boyfriend of one of her friends. She met him through some type of ad she posted on line and began chatting with him then decided to meet him without caution. People must understand you cannot see the people you are chatting with. To go willing with a stranger you meet on line instead of meeting them at a neutral populated location or with friends is a very dangerous decision in this day and age. Teenagers must exercise more caution you never know who or what type of person you are chatting with. When you have a direct conversation with someone in person is the only way you can be sure of who you are chatting with. The pictures sent on line are either old or false. The old fashion way of meeting and interacting with people is sometimes the safest. If you want to use on line ads to meet people you must be very cautious when and if you decide to meet them in person. Parents must educate their children and teenagers about dangers involved with this type of dating and social interacting. The computer provides anonymity and is a breeding ground for criminals and it is impossible to police everyone that has access.

  • CC 05/07/2009 10:04:00 PM

    Realistically, there are sick people in the world who prey off of the naivete of others, so caution must be taken, online and off. Sometimes I think that our way of advertising ourselves online (with so much transparency) on sites like CL, Facebook, Twitter, etc. gives rise to a false sense of trust with strangers who seem to be transparent/honest with us about who they are (but are clearly not). Dishonest/sick people live all around us, and some of them seem charming and cute on the surface (whether through e-mail or initially in person); being wary is a good idea, whether you're buying and selling goods/services, joining a community group, or sharing information about yourself in a forum. Be safe, people!

  • Brenna 05/07/2009 9:28:00 PM

    Gloria Allred is a media whore. This tragedy happened because that young woman met the wrong guy. It has nothing to do with the website! She could have met him through NUMEROUS websites, so to say this happened because of craigslist is passing the buck because you don't wanna say the girl made a decision that a lot of other woman have, and it turned out horrible. This never should have happened, but it's certainly not Craig Newmark's fault.

  • Adam 05/07/2009 9:26:00 PM

    Yeah, don't blame craigslist. I blame the parents and the daughter. 1) they should have been more responsible and taught her daughter not to give out personal info over the internet like that. 2) The girl should have known better than to take a ride from strangers. Stop using the website as a scapegoat for your piss poor parenting abilities--that is just as responsible as letting your daughter take off with strangers.

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy