Top

news

Stories

 

Measure B: Tweet Against the Machine

How L.A. City Hall power was struck down by blogs and online social networks

The opposition surfaced on neighborhood council websites and in blog posts by people like DWP ratepayer advocate Humphreville, DWP Advocacy Committee activist Soledad Garcia, Citywatchla.com’s Ken Draper, MayorSamBlogspot.com’s Michael Higby and former Los AngelesDaily News Editor Ron Kaye, who blogs at ronkayela.com.

On January 3, DWP officials presented Measure B to a meeting of the Los Angeles Neighborhood Council Coalition. Michael Trujillo, a consultant who ran the Yes on B campaign, disingenuously warned the crowd that without voter approval, “the DWP won’t do it” — when in fact, bloggers had already reported that DWP has a backup plan to embrace most of Measure B with or without voter approval.

“After the meeting, we started grappling with the idea that we had been dealt the hand of being a ‘No’ group,” says Stephen Box, a bicycle activist who wound up running the on-the-fly communications effort against Measure B.

Using sites like Twitter and Facebook, Box started organizing. By February, No on Measure B was trading punches with the mayor, City Council, IBEW and DWP, tapping into neighborhood councils and other groups to hold 80 town hall meetings and debates in February alone.

The blogging and social networking created a buzz, while the Los Angeles Daily News and L.A. Times both published editorials against the measure. A blog on the New York Times Website reported “dueling Facebook groups” fighting over Measure B. The City Council’s small group of just three fiscal conservatives, Bernard Parks, Dennis Zine and Greig Smith, broke ranks to slam the measure. City Controller Laura Chick, seen by some as the most popular politician in Los Angeles, warned that Measure B “stinks.”

This set the stage for a brilliantly sunny Election Day on March 3, when just under 18 percent of eligible voters showed up, and turned down Measure B by a margin of 2,644 votes.

“The public actually shut down a multimillion-dollar campaign” led by Villaraigosa, Box says. “They got a taste of real political will.”

Can rag-tag Facebookers and neighborhood council activists blog and tweet their way to a solar future and a real stake at the political table?

Mayoral spokesman Matt Szabo says Measure B’s opponents “will play an important role as citizen journalists in holding policymakers accountable as we move forward with our solar plan.” Garcetti’s office sounds less vague. “Eric did talk to Ron Kaye and Jack Humphreville and he does want to work with them,” says Garcetti spokeswoman Julie Wong.

But Brian D’Arcy, in a back-patting statement in which he insisted he was all about transparency, is already urging DWP and Villaraigosa to “swiftly implement a solar energy plan” that many experts say is not ready for prime-time.

Measure B’s opposition is wary about rushing a Measure B lookalike through City Hall. “The council members pay some lip service about transparency,” Kaye says. “But we haven’t heard [a plan for activing transparent] out of the mayor’s mouth or David Nahai’s mouth, and D’Arcy says, ‘Fuck you people, we will do whatever we want.’ ”

<< Previous Page | 1 | 2
 
  • r grant-miller 04/04/2009 12:30:00 AM

    Great article. Last week at a city planning commission hearing we also witnessed the Mayor's political machine in action when the council dismissed the recommendations made by a senior city planner for the Planning Department. who advised the panel to reject the Museum of Tolerance request to build a banquet hall on an R1 lot adjacent to single family homes and one of the busiest streets in the city, 9000 block of Pico Blvd. This is not an expansion of the Museum or its mission. This is strictly a money-maker, a party rental and food facility that will generate globs of money for the Rabbi's pet project -- to build another museum in Israel on top of a Palestinian burial ground. In the meantime, MOT's funding from both the city and state has helped secure it as a viable political machine. IOne with close political ties to Jack Weiss's office, the Mayor and his affiliates. We didn't stand a chance, the Planning Commission didn't roll over for the Mayor, they had already made their decision before the hearing began,, after all they were appointed by him. Current zoning issues that protect citizens from annexing and over building be damned, they deemed it not worth discussing; impact on city traffic moving through the area, pass, well they don't travel that route; increased pollution, not important, and destruction of a quiet neighborhood, hey the Museum needs to make more money because we can't afford to give them any The Mayor sent his representative to speak in support of the project, thus the committee rolled over and voted in support of the project without even examining the any of the problems related to it.

  • Jackson 03/27/2009 9:32:00 PM

    Mayor Viilaraigosa is weakening. Candidates are beginning to realize that the "Godfather's" endorsement may now be a negative. Some council members and maybe even Wendy Gruel are backing away from the Villaraigosa train wreck. Villaraigosa built his political career by standing on the shoulders of his family and friends. But when he was elected mayor, how quickly he forgot them all. It was time for him to diss them and go play with his new wealthy developer "friends." Measure B is the political tipping point. The Mayor's affair with a television reporter started the mass doubt about his fitness for higher office. His arrogance and bungling of Measure B is accelerating the crash and burn of his career.

  • NoHo Mom 03/27/2009 9:23:00 PM

    The LA Weekly, the blogs and talk radio are the only media outlets providing essential coverage of local politics. Thank you for your vigorous oversight of this story and also the mayoral race, not to mention the excellent article on the LA City Council a few weeks ago. Now if someone would pull the lid back on the odious AnsaldoBreda contract that just got rammed through the MTA...

  • NoHo Mom 03/27/2009 9:23:00 PM

    The LA Weekly, the blogs and talk radio are the only media outlets providing essential coverage of local politics. Thank you for your vigorous oversight of this story and also the mayoral race, not to mention the excellent article on the LA City Council a few weeks ago. Now if someone would pull the lid back on the odious AnsaldoBreda contract that just got rammed through the MTA...

  • Chris Rowe 03/27/2009 12:45:00 AM

    I have a different perspective of "Measure B" than the one portrayed here. While I thank Stephen Box for creating a Twitter and Facebook site, John Stammreich and Jack Humphreville also had a "No on Measure B" site. The individual blasts from our home pages on FACEBOOK probably reached more "friends". We used the traditional email tools - like Moveon does - Democratic Clubs actually ran "Measure B" events. Yes, there were the party loyal that voted early as Permanent Absentee voters. But there were other very intelligent Democrats that actually said that they were willing to listen to the "No on Measure B" message - and I know that we got more than a few votes from those Democrats. Some Progressive Democrats supported "No on Measure B". The internet is a strong tool - our strongest. While I could see Twitter posted, I did not Tweet - traditional emails are just as effective. The key was that we were organized, and that we had access to so many various organizations from the Neighborhood Councils, the Chambers, VICA, many labor groups, the Green Party, the Democrats, the Republicans, and even church friends. One of the key individuals was Laura Chick who came out against this measure. And Ron Kaye was able to get that message out. Then Councilman Smith did an e-blast of his own that spread throughout the City. Councilman Zine realized that Smith was right, and Councilman Parks began to see what the Measure B camp was saying was true. These Council members could not look their constituents in the face if they gave the IBEW jobs and blocked jobs for all. In the end, Ron Kaye, the Daily News, and the L.A. Times combined as all against "Measure B" sealed the deal. As far as Mitchell Schwartz goes, he is a well meaning activist who has worked his heart out for Obama. And he just does not understand the Neighborhood Council system as we do. He just thought that he was doing the right thing for the environment. I am sorry that he has had to take the attacks that went against him. Hopefully he will have learned never to put himself in that position again.

  • Jim Hilfenhaus 03/26/2009 7:35:00 PM

    The article fails to include the fact that the Laborers' and Carpenters Unions did major actions to stop Measure B. This included appearances at debates,discussions,letters to the editors, mailings and phonebanking against Measure B. Working with Ron Kaye and Jack H. and Mike C. at City Watch, the N.C.'s it was a Citizen's movement that stopped it.

  • Doug McIntyre 03/26/2009 5:24:00 PM

    With all due respect to Ron Kaye, Jack Humphyville and the Neighborhood Councils, I spent five hours a day five days a week for five weeks screaming about Measure B to a daily radio audience of nearly 400,000. Ron and Jack were guests many times as were proponents of Measure B, Including David Freeman and Wendy Greuel. While the opponets of Measure B might not have had money to fight the machine, we did have KABC Radio and a big educated audience of voters who showed up on election day.

  • ! 03/26/2009 12:03:00 PM

    I disagree with the entire premise that the organized No Campaign - as impressive as their use of social networks without significant financing was - defeated Measure B. These same networks promoted candidates like Noel Weiss for City Attorney who got about 3% of the vote and Nick Patsourus for Controller who came in third to Kathleen Suzy Evans. I think most voters who voted "no"- did so because Measure B sounded expensive at a time when people are enormously concerned about money. March 3 was also a very different electorate then the normal LA electorate and this measure likely would have passed had anything statewide, much less national been on the ballot to draw out LA's Democratic base. It was a question of bad press and bad timing for the proponents of the Measure. That said, having seen it I can say it was a herculean effort by the activists on the no side.

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy