Top

news

Stories

 

Rider on the Storm: The Best and Worst of L.A. Buses, Subways and Light Rail

Scenic journeys to hell, on wheels

With all the bad news out there about our local public transportation, it’s no wonder that so many of us don’t even bother trying to get anyplace by bus or light rail. But after spending several months traveling around the city on trains and buses, I can report that our local transit has improved over the past couple of decades.

Let me count the ways: clean, efficient light rail linking Manhattan Beach to Norwalk (other lines roll into downtown from Sierra Madre and Long Beach); dedicated bus lanes that swoop eastbound, from downtown into the San Gabriel Valley, southbound to San Pedro and, from North Hollywood, westbound into the sunset across the San Fernando Valley. Then there’s the subway barreling from Union Station along the Wilshire Corridor before swerving northwest to North Hollywood, with a finger line extending along Wilshire to Western Avenue. Express and Rapid buses feature limited stops on our most traveled major roadways, allowing them to sweep past the “milk-train” local buses that serve the same routes. A single fare for any MTA bus or train ride runs $1.25. In New York, the equivalent fare is $2.

Compensating for the idiocy of keeping the light-rail Green Line at a mile’s remove from LAX are “Flyaway” buses, leaving every 30 minutes to and from Union Station. Using diamond lanes, these shuttles get you to and from the airport in about 30 minutes, for $3 a ride. (Similar service from JFK and LaGuardia airports into New York’s Grand Central Station run $12 to $15.) Other “Fly Away” destinations include Westwood and Van Nuys.

Recent improvements on the subway and many Rapid bus routes include electronic alerts of when the next train or bus is arriving. They’re usually accurate, but even where they’re off by five or 10 minutes, there’s a perverse comfort in receiving misinformation — as opposed to no information at all.

The bad news is that the connections between the MTA’s major routes will take you efficiently and swiftly in the range of where you need to be, but you can then spend just as much time completing the final leg of your journey. Local-run buses are overcrowded and infrequent, and Department of Transportation shuttle service is paltry. The Eastside and South Los Angeles are woefully underserved, while the Westside, with no train service at all, is so gridlocked that even the Rapid buses crawl along with millions of car drivers, eradicating the very point of limited stops. Poor connections also undo the benefits of the Rapid bus service.

Example: I took the 780 Rapid bus from Hollywood and Vine, hoping to move swiftly through Hollywood and down Fairfax, so I could make the 333 “limited” Venice Boulevard connection to Culver City. The first part of the plan worked well. My Rapid bus easily passed the local 217 local bus that serves the same route. And when I saw that the 217 had its flashers on because it was changing drivers, I thought, “Glad I’m on the 780,” as we swerved around and passed the stopped bus. We made it to Venice Boulevard with amazing efficiency. But then I waited with a small crowd for the 333 — and waited and waited. The local Venice Boulevard 33 pulled up, so jammed with riders that the driver refused to open the front doors to let anybody on, while a few passengers squeezed out the back. Finally the 33 hissed away, leaving the small waiting crowd squinting east for sight of the next local or limited bus. That’s when I spotted the 217 local cross Venice and Fairfax — the same 217 I’d passed about 20 minutes earlier — making it clear that being on the Rapid 780 had served me no purpose whatsoever. This is an allegorical example of where our public transportation lags behind systems in almost every other world city, and why a recent CNN poll cited L.A.’s public transportation as the biggest impediment to tourism here.

Here’s a sampling of some of the best and worst lines our local transport has to offer.

The Connector: Red Line

Provides fast, reliable subway service between Union Station and North Hollywood (30 minutes). The ticket machines can be infuriatingly slow and, on occasion, accept bills only — which brings your base fare up from $1.25 to $2. Ridership has been steadily increasing so that it’s standing-room-only during rush hours, when downtown workers are using the Seventh/Metro, Pershing Square and Civic Center stops. It’s also an ideal way to connect to the Metro-Link commuter trains that all leave from Union Station and serve the valleys, Orange County, Riverside, Moorpark, Lancaster and San Bernardino. L.A. City College students (Vermont Avenue/Santa Monica Boulevard stop) are frequent riders, and in the evenings you’ll find the line used by theater patrons of the Center Theatre Group (Civic Center) and Pantages Theater (Hollywood/Vine). Later at night, you’ll be accompanied by retro punks and hipsters aiming for Hollywood/Highland, and movie patrons headed for the Universal City stop. On a recent Saturday night, coming home to Hollywood from a play in North Hollywood, I found the Red Line crowded even at 11 p.m. The trains run every 10 to 20 minutes, depending on the time, until midnight.

1 | 2 | Next Page >>
 
  • Transit Planner 10/30/2009 4:33:00 AM

    Frequent Flyer: thanks for calling my community (Norwalk/Santa Fe Springs) "nowhere." Typical Westside attitude. They don't kmow why we hate them. P.S. The Green is one of the most utilized light rail lines in the U.S. on a passenger per mile basis. Much better than the yuppies Gold Line to Pasadena. Hopefully, the Eastside extension will help that line.

  • Frequent Flyer 12/20/2008 11:22:00 AM

    There is no "idiocy" in the green line stopping short of the airport. It connects to a bus to get to the terminals. If it came to the airport transit station, it would still use a shuttle bus. Why waste two billion dollars to achieve nothing? It is the Green Line. Only the airport employees ride it. Passengers won't - it doesn't come from anywhere. If it came from Santa Monica (aerial on Lincoln), connecting from the Red Line, if it came from deeper in South Bay, it might get some passengers, but at what cost?

  • Bewildered Bystander 12/10/2008 4:47:00 AM

    As a transplanted professional from Boston, i feel the need to chime in on the status of LA's public transportation. Back east, people of different economic classes take the public transport because its considered "intelligent" you get to where you are going faster, cheaper and without adding to our polution or oil dependancy. Here in LA, public transportation takes much longer than it would if you could drive to work (or other destination), like 3 times as long, so therefore ,a key componant in ridership desireablity is missing, plus there still is a stigma associated with taking the "looser cruiser"aka the bus. I am the only caucasion on the 16 bus down to Century City and there are absolutely not one person of a professional grade riding to work (if you dont count the Driver of the bus) now that gas is cheaper the crowds of 4 months ago are a thing of the past.

  • Teresa 12/08/2008 11:53:00 PM

    This was fairly accurate, except I have to agree with the comment about the 96! Also, the 750 Rapid on Ventura Blvd. equals the 720 on Wilshire in reliability and efficiency.

  • Juan 12/01/2008 7:43:00 AM

    Wow! I am surprised that the 96 or any number of the 70's didnt make the cut. I can't count the many times that i got a firsthand seat to fist fights, stinky winos, and the impoverished.

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy