Inside View of Inner-City Schools | Letters | Los Angeles | Los Angeles News and Events | LA Weekly

Inside View of Inner-City Schools 

A former LAUSD teacher writes in

Wednesday, Mar 5 2008

I'll admit "Teachers Behaving Badly" [Feb. 22-28] is a real nifty title, but Max Taves should get some facts straight rather than seeking the data to fit his title. First of all, "merit pay" has existed in certain inner-city schools in Los Angeles since 1979. I should know; I received it all those years. I got an extra $2,000 a year for various overtime duties, such as calling parents or after-school tutoring. UTLA didn't raise a protest, but various community activists did. Although the extra $2,000 helped make ends meet, if you do the math it's really overtime without time-and-a-half. In addition, UTLA and LAUSD worked out an agreement in which teachers would receive a bonus for uncollected sick leave at the end of each year and also at retirement. This was another form of "merit pay." When I retired, I combined the sum for my 1,781 hours of uncollected sick leave with a longevity bonus (another form of merit pay) into a tiny annuity. However, both my annuity and my pension are threatened by Arnold Schwarzenegger and company, who want to shut down CALSTRS [the California State Teachers' Retirement System] even though it is self-supporting.

The main reason teachers "resist" merit pay is simple: It rarely works. Most merit-pay schemes become the victims of budget cuts. If you teach in a nonunion charter school, merit pay can be a one-way ticket to the unemployment line — since charter-school operators would just as soon fire you to replace you with a cheaper teacher. The brouhaha over recess duty is equally ridiculous. Since I taught in an inner-city high school, I always ate my lunch in my classroom, primarily so that my students would have a safe refuge should anything happen. A lot of my colleagues keep lunchtime hours, too, for various reasons. However, I could not count lunchtime duty as overtime; nor did I ever expect to get paid for it. I felt I was lucky that I had a room to call my own.

As a former journalism adviser myself, I'd suggest that Taves' article seems like a textbook example of what I term "armchair journalism." Unless he's actually taught in inner-city schools, he should avoid trashing teachers who do.

Related Stories

  • Voter Guide 12

    Want to meet new people worth having over for poker or with whom to swap your second-hand novels? Try your voting precinct's active voters — also known as neighbors. There are about 1,000 of you per precinct, and it's always interesting to see who's out and about from your enclave...
  • Buy Arnold's Truck

    If you ask us, Arnold Schwarzenegger is getting a little soft in his old age. At the tail end of his stint as our Republican governor, he got quite cozy with Democratic leaders. And he has parked in his Westside garage a decidedly girly-man car—the eco-friendly Tesla Roadster. This is a...
  • Carr, Lieu Win Primary in Waxman's Congressional District 33 - Greuel Out

    With early vote-by-mail ballots partly counted, Republican Elan Carr and Democrats Ted Lieu and Wendy Greuel are in a tight battle to replace Henry Waxman in the Westside's 33rd Congressional District. Carr has 23.4 percent, Lieu has 19.8 percent and Greuel has 18.5 percent. Spiritual guru Marianne Williamson is well...
  • Sabotage is a Belt of Bourbon After Years of Sipping Diet Pepsi

    Arnold Schwarzenegger's name is only about one-seventh the font size of the title on the poster of Sabotage, formerly Breacher, formerly Ten, his third attempt — after the full-auto Western The Last Stand and the goofy Stallone–co-headlined prison-break joint Escape Plan — in 14 months at a post-gubernatorial comeback. A...
  • How to Vote 8

    You know the incumbents. So our June 3 voter guide is about the other stuff - like a comedic race for judge featuring candidates so bad the bar association finds both "Not Qualified." One is Charles Calderon, who L.A. Weekly previously reported as one of the worst legislators in California. There's...

Posted Feb. 22 by William Joseph Miller



The article "Bitter Homes and Gardens" [Feb. 29-March 6] incorrectly stated that Los Angeles County Supervisor Zev Yaroslavsky fought federal funding for subways after a methane explosion in 1985. In fact, Yaroslavsky called for further study of methane-gas dangers while Congressman Henry Waxman championed the federal ban. Later, Yaroslavsky led a ballot effort that prevented local sales taxes from being spent on the subway being tunneled under Hollywood, allowing that tax money to go to other transit projects.

In the story "Century City of Light" [Feb. 22-28], the name of SunCal Companies was listed incorrectly.

Related Content

Now Trending

Los Angeles Concert Tickets