Top

news

Stories

 

Tribal Flush: Pechanga People "Disenrolled" en Masse

On the eve of what could be the largest gambling expansion in U.S. history, a tale of power, betrayal and lost Indian heritage

John Gomez Jr. parks his silver family van in the back row of one more anonymous strip mall off California’s Highway 79, an hour and a half southeast of Los Angeles, on a windswept ridge overlooking the Temecula Valley. Gomez, his dark hair barely betraying a sprinkling of gray at his temples, steps out of the van and walks away from the mall, to a barren dirt lot marked off with adobe walls.

“This is where Pablo is buried,” he says as we peer over the locked iron gate.

Pablo is Pablo Apis, the celebrated 19th-century “headman,” or chief, of the Temecula/Pechanga Indians, who was given more than 2,000 acres of land in exchange for his work at the Mission San Luis Rey. Gomez, who is a direct descendant of Chief Apis, jiggles the lock on the gate. He has no key.

“This is where a lot of our people were buried,” Gomez continues, “including those killed in the famous Temecula Massacre.” He’s referring to the killing of several dozen Indians by Californio militias in the closing days of 1846. Apis survived and, indeed, the 1875 treaty between the Temecula tribe and the U.S. government, though never ratified, was signed at the chief’s village adobe home.

Today, on a corner of Apis’ original land grant, a few minutes down the road from the desolate burial ground, towers the $350 million Pechanga Resort & Casino, the glittering 14-story pleasure dome so familiar to Southern Californians from the promotional and political-advocacy commercials in near-constant rotation on local television stations. With 522 rooms, 185,000 square feet of casino floor, 2,000 slot machines, more than 150 table games and seven restaurants, along with Vegas-class showrooms, nightclubs and comedy lounges, the Pechanga Band of Luiseño Indians, as the tribe is now known, runs the largest and perhaps most profitable of California’s nearly 60 Indian casinos. And now, under terms of a deal negotiated by Governor Schwarzenegger, ratified earlier this year by the Democratic-led state legislature and set to go before voters in the February 5 primary election, the Pechanga and three other Southern California tribes may soon triple their battery of slot machines, allowing each of the four Indian groups to operate twice as many slots as any Vegas casino. If the referendums go through, the four tribes — Morongo, Agua Caliente, Sycuan and Pechanga — will be responsible for the largest expansion of gambling in recent U.S. history.

Gomez, a 40-year-old paralegal, helped birth the Pechanga mega-resort, which opened in 2002 and today grosses as much as $1 billion a year. He worked as a legal and cultural adviser to his tribe, a representative and lobbyist, and, along with several of his family members, served on key tribal committees as the Pechanga moved, almost overnight, from obscure poverty to a position of awesome political and economic power.

But it’s Gomez’s tribe no more. At least as far as the tribal leadership is concerned. Gomez and 135 adult members of his extended family (and 75 or more children) have been purged from formal Pechanga membership; they have been “disenrolled.” They were accused of no crime, no misbehavior, no wrongdoing, no disloyalty. But a series of tribal kangaroo-court hearings, bereft of even the pretense of due process, ruled that one of the family’s deceased elders was not an authentic tribe member and, therefore, not withstanding their years of service to the tribe, they were all to be banned.

And so today John Gomez can only stand outside the cemetery where Chief Apis and his other forebears are buried. “My family’s history is the history of Temecula and the Pechanga,” says Gomez. “But now, somehow, we have become traitors.”

As we drive from the cemetery and cruise by the city park named for Chief Apis, Gomez says, “I loved my job. I loved my tribe. But growing up .?.?. growing up, man .?.?. I would never, ever have thought our tribe would come to this.”

What it’s come to goes beyond tribal pride. As a result of the disenrollment, many in the Gomez family, which accounts for some 10 percent of the total Pechanga tribe’s membership, have lost their federal standing and benefits as American Indians. Some have lost their jobs at the resort. All of the adults, including Gomez, lost the generous per capita monthly payout, derived from casino profits, that was given to each adult of the tribe. When the Gomez family’s expulsion was finalized in 2004, that was about $15,000 per month. Currently, for those who remain members of the tribe, the figure has risen to about $40,000 per month.

The sharp increase is due in part to a second wave of purges, finalized last year, which disenrolled another extended family, this one descended from Paulina Hunter and representing yet another 10 percent of the tribe. That second purge went ahead despite a tribe-commissioned expert probe that concluded that Hunter was, in fact, a Pechanga. Simply put: The fewer the tribal members, the bigger the payout.

Some of the elderly disenrollees found themselves cut off from tribal clinics they helped to build. Some of the younger ones lost their education subsidies. What all the disenrollees have in common is not only the sudden loss of significant income but erasure of their collective cultural history and identity.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next Page >>
 
  • Abcdef 03/17/2011 3:26:00 AM

    What about Randy Pico look at the records Randy Pico was born in 1960 while Norman and Deborah Pico where married in 1966. Randy Pico's name was changed once Deborah Pico married Norman in Riverside California. Randy Pico is a Fake, Fake, Fake

  • Luiseno 05/24/2009 3:56:00 AM

    Tribes are not the harmonious band of people that non indians think they are. There are always schisms and factions that do not get along with one another. What happens when one small group gains complete control of the tribe with the added incentive of millions of dollars in there pockets (people have been killed for much less). What happens when your accusers become your judge and jury (this is what happened to us). Before the Tribe had anything they were happy to have us as members, it wasnt until it looked like they were going to get something that memberships were questioned. Our family has been recognized as members of the tribe for over 100 years according to the records on file with the BIA. It is a fact recognized by both sides of the Tribe that Paulina Hunter was an indian that lived in the origional village. She was also recognized by members of that tribe as a member via witnessed and certified documents of that period. She was evicted along with the rest of the tribe from that village and moved to the area known as Pechanga to live with them is also undisputed. Also one of the most revered and respected members of the Tribe most recently wrote before his death in a signed and wittnessed document stating that he knew her personally as a member of the tribe. Members who were alive at the time also said they knew her personally as a member of the Tribe, they gave signed wittnessed documents stating that they knew her as a member. Now more than a hundred years after her death, people (who I might add some are related to the Hunters) are trying to say that she was some other kind of indian, who just happened to live with the tribe in the origional village, and the people from that tribe mistakenly believed she was a member. They say that she just happended to be kicked out of the origional village to move to Pechanga with the rest of the Tribe to live. They say that the government mistakenly gave her a allotment on the reservation as a Pechanga indian. That she is listed on the origional Pechanga Reservation records as a Temecula Pechanga indian by mistake (that I might add happened year after year, every year until her death). That tribal members from the period were mistaken when they gave signed wittnessed depositions stating that they knew her as a member of the tribe. The disenrollment committee also hired Dr John Johnson, curator of Anthropology at the Santa Barbara Museum of Natural History to check on her. But much to there dismay he came back with a report saying that he was 95% sure (he now says he is 100% sure) that she was a Pechanga indian Then they say that the small group known as the CPP (who I might add had previously tried to take over the tribe eariler, but was shot down by the BIA) tell us that THEY know who are "real" members, and that documents meen NOTHING. Why do they say that documents meen nothing? Its because they have no documentation of there own showing decent from a origional Pechanga Indian, You might ask "if it is a small group, why hasnt the rest of the Tribe tried to put a stop it". Well they DID try a couple years back. In the largest gathering of our Tribe in recorded history, they voted to STOP ALL dissenrollments and remove the disenrollment process from Tribal law by a HUGE margen. Well this so shocked the CPP that they stopped ALL tribal meetings for the next few months, and in secret behind closed doors, guarded by armed guards decided to overthrow the vote of the people and disenroll the Hunters anyways. With such a HUGE voting block now disenrolled they now have assured there control and take over of the tribe. Those who are left live in fear on the Rez, and worry that if they now speak up that something will be done to them also.

  • SANPASQUALbyBLOOD 01/13/2009 8:34:00 AM

    http://www.youtube.com/user/SANPASQUALbyBLOOD San Pasqual Chairman denies members the right to vote in a violation of Civil Rights. Allen Lawson prevented San Pasquals biggest family from voting to win chairmanship again. These violations need to be stopped as we have a third world dictatorship within the United States funded by American Tax dollars.

  • Roscoe Pond 02/17/2008 12:45:00 PM

    I am an American Indian and my Tribe has an Indian Casino. The Positive thing about our Casino is we now have the money to preserve our culture and heritage. We've built a new Fire-Fighter Station, Housing for our Elders, a Cultural Institute, Indian Employment, a Veterans Memorial Wall, a Charter school for our teens and Courses that teach our Indian Languages. Indian Casinos can do wonders. After reading this article, the Pechanga Indian Casino is very negative in its' dis-enrollment of blood relatives. What kills me is that the Tribe hired their own Historian who claims that the Hunter family is very much Pechanga. Marc Macarro, The Tribal Chairman is wrong and he knows it. But, it's all about his greed and the greed of the Tribal members who support him, and keep voting him back in as Chairman. What people don't understand is that it happens on every Indian Reservation. Our Tribal Governments are split on every level with hateful in-fighting. This Pechanga split is on the highest Level in regards to dis-enrollment over MONEY & POWER! Until The Chairman gets voted out of his position, his Pechanga brothers and sisters will be enrolled again. Unfortunately, dis-enrolling of Tribal members will continue on every Indian Reservation, with a Casino that is making way too much money.

  • Ursula Simon 02/14/2008 5:01:00 AM

    My heart breaks for those people that have been disenrolled. Even more so for those children that have just been thrown away like garbage by their own blood, thier people. The saddest thing is that those that are metophorically killing thier own, are in fact killing themselves. By that I mean, the old people may not have been educated in the white man's world but they knew that they would only survive if thier children did. So to throw the children away they are killing themselves in the long run. CONGRAT's those disenrolling Tribal Governments just were promoted to be the Newly Appointed Indian Termination Agency. I bet your old people are so happy that they were rapped, tortured, and killed for nothing. I can only imagine how happy you are making the BIA's job easier by making less Indians to worry about.Thank you for acting mighty white "The Dominate Society"! Oh, Cuzn.

  • Joy HUnt-Schlendorf 01/29/2008 6:54:00 AM

    I find the article Tribal Flush by Marc Cooper to be very disturbing. I think the actions taken by the Pechanga Tribal Council treated the Hunter family and Gomez families in a despicable manner. As a former consultant in Indian Country I must point out that this Chairman could not do this all on his own. It took the backing of his tribal council to carry this off. Do I believe these families are Pechanga or Temecula members? Yes, probably. The danger of others getting involved in this internal tribal dispute is that in doing so their sovereignty granted by the US Congress in accordance with original treaties would be endangered. I am not a Native American, but I would like to think there is some small item in the original treaties that will be upheld, God knows we have broken almost every promise we made to the aboriginal people of this country and Sovereignty is the last and most important thing they still have left. The status of federally recognized tribes in this country is a position of government that is one step above the status of US states. They are called Sovereign Nations and there are between 575 and 600 of them last I checked. For over a hundred years after the treaties, most of these people lived in third world poverty conditions that we do not seem to allow in the actual third world countries. We always seem to be the ones coming to the aid of others as a nation wanting human rights. But, we did not really ever think twice about the atrocious situation we had in our own country. We monitor elections in other countries, even against their wishes, but will not even monitor an election in Indian Country if members of the Tribe request it. So their sovereignty has been used against their best interest as well. So, I must point out that sovereignty is a double edged sword and can be wielded for good or bad. In the story, it is clear to see how everyone including the Gomez family fought to retain that sovereignty when they were in power and enjoying the benefits of it. Now corruption seems to have reared it�s ugly head, just as it always does when people lust after the dollar. Now the same people want to encourage interference in that sovereignty. Some Tribal governments will be corrupted and their tribal members will get the gumption to get rid of those leaders and change things. I have no doubt about that. Thats their election process and they must fight within their government for it to be honest. The disenrollment can be reversed by another tribal council, it�s possible. So this is a tribal issue and we should not make a huge deal out of it. If we had to substantiate all the corruption on our government, let�s not even talk about the Coble case and all the missing Indian Funds, we would be hard pressed to find a system of government federal, state or local who could pass the integrity test. So why should their governments be different? They have the same human factors every other government has. Now, I want to know why this should be linked to the upcoming votes. Do they not have the right to do economic development, gaming and entertainment on their land? Should they have to continually give �gifts� to the State of California to do so? You see, anything they negotiate to give the State is not required by federal law, they are all going through this process to be cooperative. They are more sovereign than States. Should they really be supporting the California school system when that system doesn�t even make a less than best effort in supporting Indian Schools on the reservation? NO� But they do. They give millions to charities in California that have nothing to do with Indian gaming or casinos and they have brought hundreds if not thousands of entry level jobs and above to many poor communities in California. I�m not a supporter of gaming, but I fully recognize the American principle of people being able to do their own business on their own land, and this is no exception. Many people are jealous of their advancement and the power they have learned to lobby within our current system in California. Yes,they learned the ropes, just like other big businesses have. Like Matel with Nafta, and many other instances . Thats the way the State operates and they would have to be stupid not to do it. When did it become bad to be rich.... everyone loves Trump who is rich fromt he same business. This jealousy of a minority being rich is why some would like to link every negative thing happening on the reservations to their right to do business. I wonder if this happens in New Jersey when Trump wants a new casino? The Tribes are Nations and have certain rights to be Nations, like free trade agreements, land rights policies, water rights policies and they operate their businesses and governments under a different set of laws that pertain to their rights that are set by the Federal Government. We need to understand that if they don�t want unions, the State has no power to make them have them. But, I haven�t known of a lot of people complaining about that issue. Some states encourage unions other don�t. Some tribes may and others may not�That�s their business. Just like McDonalds, Burge King and many other high profit industries in this State and country. In the article I sensed some kind of disgust for the Agua Caliente teaching their staff (mostly non-Indians) how to access the rights and benefits due them by the US government. What�s wrong with that? All people working at entry level or non skilled positions in this country must have some government aid to survive. It�s just too expensive for most families to get by and very confusing for most people to try to access that help. I commend them for that. Linking this issue of disenrollment to the upcomming vote and affecting the others tribes on the measure is playing into the hands of those who just can�t see minorities get ahead and have some power. No. they won�t all use that power well all the time, but show me what Nation has? Certainly not ours.

  • Andrew 01/11/2008 8:24:00 AM

    It just may be that the plagues of smallpox and alcoholism visited on the Redman are only now now being returned in kind. No more gaming expansionism unless a significant allotment is earmarked for the education, prevention and treatment of those cursed with the horrible affliction of pathological gambling

  • Other Tribe 01/11/2008 2:24:00 AM

    I am also a member of this other tribe, and i agree that it's disgusting, because it's our family that is getting banned from our religious rights. Where is it going to end? Last year there was a scuffle that took place and nothing has been done except now those people are in power! Money? Money don't buy happiness but that seems to be the major issue at hand! I feel for those that have been disenrolled and wonder if that will happen to us!

  • OTHER TRIBE 01/11/2008 2:02:00 AM

    This is the sadest thing that anyone can go through we are from a tribe in the southwest and this is happeing right now as we speak our tribe is split into two sides and right now there is one side thinks that the other is embezzeling funds from the tribe and basically they have taken more funds then anyone living here. No community member knows of what is happening they are just doing what they want to do!!! It is so sad that it hurts not just the one family but the whole community at a whole, our tribe is basically run by the Men and no Women have a say but to sit back and watch this disgust happen!!! I feel for these people of this tribe and wish that they would only think what this does to a person as a TRIBE and not just do it to please themselves!! But again NO ONE knows what is happening here!!!! SCARY!! What is happening to OUR TRIBE maybe it will be no more one day????

  • EB 01/09/2008 8:47:00 AM

    This was an episode of NUMB3RS two years ago.

  • Mark$ 01/05/2008 7:16:00 AM

    I'm with RussBB. What's the point of this article? The LA Weekly is wasting an entire cover story demanding readers feel sorry for corrupt individuals cutting other corrupt individuals out of the loot? The whole phenomenon of "tribal casinos" is a fucked up joke. Hello Gray Davis, hello Arnold? These palaces are designed to enrich a few "gaming" corporations (like Stations Casinos, a Las Vegas chain of hotels preying on local Las Vegan addict gamblers, which has contracted to manage tribal casinos to entice a whole new generation of California gamblers to come to Nevada). C'mon Weekly and Marc Cooper, start reporting the REAL issues here: our politicians selling Californians down the river for campaign contributions. I'm shocked, fucking shocked!

  • Joel A. Montes 01/05/2008 3:03:00 AM

    I think the biggest issue in this piece and in gambling issues is not the power the tribal councils wield in Indian Casino reservations but the power of the State and Federal Government power to recognize "tribes" as legitimate. Think about it, these tribes are only parroting what the government does to tribes applying for federal or state recognition. I am glad our family heritage is not "contingent" on an external authority to determine my indigenous heritage. Thankfully, like the traditional councils, our heritage comes down from our own voices and relatives- not the government, not some council.

  • Ben Quinones 01/05/2008 2:03:00 AM

    I find it interesting that Marc Cooper is writing about California�s Indian Casinos considering he wrote a book on Vegas The Last Honest Place in America: Paradise and Perdition in the New Las Vegas and has also written articles on Vegas including All In With The Bad Boy Of Poker: A no-limits weekend with Phil Hellmuth Jr. and Aces and Addicts: Modern gambling in America and the rise of the machines. Marc seems to have a fondness of Vegas gambling, which is cool (Cause I�ve partied hard in Vegas) but I wonder what is the real motive of the Tribal piece? If this article is really about �Betrayal and lost heritage� and having empathy for California�s Indigenous people, then I think there must be some deep historical context of Indigenous peoples in the piece. To publish such an article and only write �after centuries of oppression,� OPPRESSION, Indigenous people were Butchered! The United States Government conducted a systematic and planned extermination of the American Indians, Forcibly took their land and then forced them onto guaranteed death sentences Reservations. But there�s no mention of the United States Congress passing the Indian Removal Act, the Indian Appropriations Act which authorized the creation of Native American reservations (because �civilized men� such as Benjamin Franklin saw Indians as �Savages�), or no mention of Native Americans becoming US Citizens until 1924! Well you get the picture. I think you can�t talk about the state of California Indians and their reservations until you give your readers some honest historical context and lay out how Indigenous people have gotten to this point, where Casinos are now there biggest source of income for American Indians across the US. I have to say I know and roll with many Native Americans from LA to South Dakota and I know NO Indian Millionaires. The majority of them are all struggling to survive, just like me. Ben

  • RussBBinVegas@aol.com 01/04/2008 11:10:00 PM

    Legalized gambling is an outrage. Who in their right mind allowed this insidious disease to be perpetrated upon the people of California; is the guilt of America's 200 year mistreatment of Indians supposed to be assuaged by these hideous "tribal" casinos. Obviously, we need more education to encourage young people never to start "gaming" (ie. having your money STOLEN by the phoney glamor of Las Vegas) in the first place. Gambling addicts victimized & preyed upon by Nevada corporations & California tribes, please start speaking out!

  • deshawn 01/04/2008 5:18:00 AM

    Well, I sure as hell will be voting against letting them expand. Gambling is just a tax on people who are bad at math - you will always lose over time. It's a social disease that unfortunately targets the poor and uneducated, the very people who can least afford to be bled this way. It's too bad that the tribes have had to resort to casinos as a way to make money, since it's not really a healthy thing. For a culture that didn't even recognize property ownership for most of its history, they've come full circle. The sad thing for the "disenrolled" is that there is no recourse for them to redress the loss of their heritage. No more casinos. They're not a good thing.

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy