Cruel Beauty | Good Rep | Los Angeles | Los Angeles News and Events | LA Weekly

Cruel Beauty 

Ingmar Bergman’s Cries and Whispers and Autumn Sonata

Wednesday, Oct 3 2007

When Ingmar Bergman died July 30, the adoring appreciations that swiftly followed habitually contained severe descriptions of his work as “bleak” and “despairing,” which, while hardly inaccurate, created an impression that watching his movies amounts to a succession of miserable experiences. But even at their most despondent, his films were something even his disciples rarely acknowledged: enormously comforting. As opposed to so much indie fare, which pretends to expose the fault lines in dysfunctional human relationships but rather piles on innocuous quirks so that we ultimately see how gosh-darn lovable we all really are, Bergman took the opposite tact. Particularly in his family dramas, he validated our darkest suspicions about those closest to us: They are a killing cancer we can never remove. Cries and Whispers (1972) and Autumn Sonata (1978) are suffused with horrible illness and withering contempt. In Cries, two hopelessly self-absorbed women (played by Liv Ullmann and Ingrid Thulin) hover dutifully by the death bed of their violently suffering sister (Harriet Andersson), not to make amends but to boil in the cauldron of their shared familial wretchedness. By comparison, Sonata is only mildly less harrowing as a distant mother (a shockingly middle-aged Ingrid Bergman) visits her mousy, resentful daughter (Ullmann again) to perform a slow-motion autopsy on their strained bond. While they were hardly a gleeful good time, the lingering impression left by both films is not sorrow or agony but, perversely, a cleansing exultation, an honest recognition that life sometimes is as difficult as we imagine. In the face of so much popular entertainment that is constructed to reassure us — you and your wife will work things out, the endless search for meaning ultimately is rewarding — Bergman’s greatest films treated us like grown-ups and spoke to the twitchy uncertainties we’re told to ignore. Yes, we’ll end up taking all that unresolved pain to the grave. And, sure, even Ingrid Bergman grows old. But that doesn’t make her any less beautiful. (New Beverly Cinema; Fri.-Sat., Oct. 5-6)

—Tim Grierson

Related Stories

  • Film Critics Need to Learn to Look — and Enjoy

    Star presence, that distillation of charisma and sometimes glamour, lies at the heart of the movies' appeal. The star presence James Harvey evokes so richly in his new book, Watching Them Be, is never simply about physical beauty. Harvey rightly points out that Ingrid Bergman's fresh unaffectedness was distinctly unglamorous,...
  • Women with cameras

    For her current show at Marc Foxx, Anne Collier took photographs of photographs of women taking photographs. That sounds nerdily meta, but the effect isn't that at all. In one image Collier takes as her subject, it's the mid-1960s, and Swedish actress Liv Ullmann is on the set of Ingmar...
  • Movies to See This Week: A Film on the History of Porn

    Friday, April 18 Starting on Friday at UCLA's Billy Wilder Theater is the film series Stages: Norman Lloyd and American Television. Since beginning his career as a child actor in the 1920s, Lloyd has done it all, from stage to film to television. Kicking off the six-part series through June 8 is...
  • Emancipation Proclamations

    Ingmar Bergman's Nora and two plays by Horton Foote at Open Fist Theatre present defiant women, in ways that feel almost nostalgic
  • Nora

    Ingmar Bergman's adaptation of A Doll's House restructures Henrik Ibsen's fierce family drama, stripping the play to its emotional essence, a goal that's underscored by director Dana Jackson's spartan but evocative production. On a simple set consisting of some chairs, a Christmas tree in the back and, later, a bed,...
Reach the writer at

Related Content

Now Showing

  1. Wed 17
  2. Thu 18
  3. Fri 19
  4. Sat 20
  5. Sun 21
  6. Mon 22
  7. Tue 23

    Find capsule reviews, showtimes & tickets for all films in town.

Box Office Report

Scores provided by Rotten Tomatoes

Join My Voice Nation for free stuff, concert and dining info & more!

Around The Web

Now Trending