Who's That Bard? 

New book threatens to out the real Shakespeare

Thursday, Nov 17 2005
One can’t in good faith write about the Globe Theatre of London’s Measure for Measure, currently on view at UCLA, without reporting on Brenda James and William Rubenstein’s just-published book, The Truth Will Out: Unmasking the Real Shakespeare. With potent research and authority, the scholars argue that the provincial and slightly educated William Shakespeare — an alderman’s son and grammar-school graduate — couldn’t have written many of the worldly plays such as Hamlet, The Merchant of Venice, or even Measure for Measure, that have been attributed to him. That Shakespeare might have been a front man for a mystery scribe is not breaking news, and now James and Rubenstein have added a little-known English diplomat and courtier named Sir Henry Neville to the list of candidates suspected of writing Shakespeare’s plays. (Others in that club include Ben Jonson, Sir Walter Raleigh, Francis Bacon, Christopher Marlowe, Edward de Vere and William Stanley.) To readSteven Leigh Morris' accompanying review of Measure for Measure click here. Some salient facts: Neville and Shakespeare lived and died within years of each other — the former from 1562 to 1615, the latter from 1564 to 1616. Shakespeare’s friends and family spun in Neville’s circle: Shakespeare’s mother, Mary Arden, was a relative; Shakespeare’s patron, the Earl of Southampton, was one of Neville’s associates.Then there’s the matter of the plays themselves, their locales and content. Unlike Shakespeare, Neville visited all of the countries in which Shakespeare’s plays are set. Notes taken by Neville in those countries appear to form the basis of ideas that show up in Shakespeare’s plays. Henry V, written when Neville was the English ambassador to France, contains entire passages in French — a language that, unlike Shakespeare, Neville spoke fluently.As to why Neville would need to write incognito, James and Rubenstein argue that Neville was a Plantagenet, whose clan was in conflict with the ruling Tudors. In fact, he was involved in a rebellion that landed him in the Tower of London for treason. A theatrical version of notes he took while in prison shows up in Henry VIII. Though that Tudor king beheaded Neville’s grandfather and uncle, Neville’s life was spared. He, too, might have been hanged had his authorship of, say, Richard II, been presumed. Finally, James and Rubenstein present as evidence a document discovered in 1867 containing Neville’s 17 practice-attempts at forging Shakespeare’s signature. In the book’s foreword, the Globe Theatre’s artistic director and star, Mark Rylance, expresses his fascination with the thesis and his desire to explore it further.

Related Stories

  • Hearsts v. Chandlers

    Los Angeles has never been particularly renowned as a town conducive to festival-grade professional Shakespeare. Whether it’s the city’s proximity to Hollywood and its blind ambivalence to what is in its own backyard, the collective trauma of force-fed, high school field-trip Bard, or a simple scarcity of seasoned directors and...
  • Week of July 31st

    It's in the stars.
  • Queen Lear?

    Considered one of Shakespeare's greatest tragedies by luminaries like Samuel Taylor Coleridge and Percy Bysshe Shelley, King Lear has also been taken to task for its wanton cruelty by the likes of Samuel Johnson, and writers Charles Lamb and A.C. Bradley have deemed it nearly impossible to be properly represented...
  • Shakespeare and Dance on the Big Screen: Your Weekly Movie To-Do List

    Friday, June 6 Friday marks the opening night of Dance Camera West, the 13th annual dance media film festival, with a free live performance at 7:30 p.m. followed by a block of international short films starting at 8 p.m. for $5. Both take place at the Music Center. The lineup includes...
  • Shakespeare With Hipster Puppets

    "Shakespeare with puppets" may sound like a kiddie gimmick, but the Bristol Old Vic's A Midsummer Night's Dream, now at the Broad Stage, should not be so easily dismissed. The mortal characters are purely human, while the fairy characters are portrayed using masks and puppets created by South Africa -...
Reach the writer at smorris@laweekly.com

Related Content

Now Trending

  • A Sex Play That's Not Really About Sex

    Oh, sex: Can we ever get over it? And if we do, what will there be to write about? What would the state of the world be if it weren't largely defined by overt and subliminal sexual impulses? Ian MacAllister-McDonald's new play, The Sexual Lives of Savages, presented by Skylight...


  • A Day in Griffith Park
    Pack a picnic basket and escape the hustle and bustle of L.A. by spending the day in beautiful Griffith Park.Stop and grab a cold drink at Trails, then go hike. Stroll around the Observatory. Cruise past The Greek Theater to the Bird Sanctuary, or practice golf and grab a snack at the Roosevelt Cafe. Just remember, you don't need to be a tourist to enjoy what Griffith Park has to offer. All photos by Michele McManmon.
  • FANFARE-LA: Fine Art Nude, Fetish, and Risque Exhibition (NSFW)
    FANFARE-LA, the Fine Art Nude, Fetish, and Risque Exhibition was held Jan. 31st to Feb. 2nd at the Hamilton Galleries in Santa Monica. Here is a peek of the sexually-charged, fetish-fine art that is featured in the show. More info at fanfare-la.com.
  • Gloryhole 2013 @ The Pleasure Chest
    The Pleasure Chest's annual anniversary party, Gloryhole, took place Thursday night, transforming the popular West Hollywood sex shop into a pleasure den filled opportunities to get spanked, tied up and dominated. For those of a more voyeuristic nature, the live XXX Gloryhole installation offered a glimpse of erotic play and sexuality. All photos by Nanette Gonzales.