LIST OF ISSUES
I am glad to see Mike Davis "6 Remarkable Ways To Die" [The List 2004, December 2430] includes the "Mothman Curse." Intriguingly, Mr. Davis did not mention the most hauntingly reinforcing death of 2004 related to this curse the unfortunate passing of The Mothman Prophecies director Mark Pellingtons wife on July 30, 2004.
Someone kindly correct Peter Fletcher by telling him that the Audio Pepper Spray status he levies on the song "I Can See Clearly Now" ["Audio Pepper Spray," December 2430] is probably due to Johnny Nash. To associate Jimmy Cliff with one-hit-wonder status is pretty much sacrilege.
That Greg Burk writes that Immanuel Kant lived "in the late 19th century" ["Words Worth," December 2430] would no doubt come as a surprise to that philosopher, who died in 1804. Also surprising is the "fact" that the German Einfühlung means "one-feeling," since ein- here means "in," not "one," as is to be expected given that this is a calque from the Greek empatheia (I suspect Mr. Burk saw a link with something like "feeling at one with"); the Greek en- or em- means "in." Further, the Greek empatheia never originally "connoted solipsism," a philosophical position that seems to be entirely alien to the ancient West; it connoted "a state (of the body), a feeling," while the cognate adjective meant "in an emotional condition, passionate," and, more dully, "able to be affected" (of things) and "inflected" (of words). Nor does the Oxford English Dictionary suggest any connection of the English empathy with solipsism, past or present. The same is true of the German Einfühlung. The German word (like the cognate verb sich einfühlen) is often said to have been coined by Robert Vischer, the late-19th-century German philosopher, and translated into English as empathy by the English, but German-trained, psychologist Edward Titchener, who also claimed to have coined it, and certainly was the first to use it in a scientific context as part of a psychological theory (what came to be called "empathic understanding"). But the German word was used to understand something different from or alien to ourselves by the great theorist of German Romanticism Herder, and a century later taken over by phenomenologists like Vischer as a word for the perception of the aesthetics and symbolism of natural form.
Professor Catherine Atherton
Departments of Philosophy and Classics, UCLA
I am disappointed with L.A. Weekly this year, politically speaking. So much ranting in place of serious analysis. Doesnt the paper think being reasonable and rational, and not demonizing its opponents (which is merely a way of avoiding answering their arguments), is a better strategy for the long run?
In any case, I figured the Weekly would be a little chastened by the election results, but no. I see in the Zeitlist issue [December 2430], from writers such as Greg Burk, John Powers and Doug Ireland (not to mention the hopelessly biased Web sites that were recommended, including Juan Coles and the DailyKos.com), that 2005 wont feature even a glimmer of fairness on issues like the war in Iraq.
If L.A. Weekly continues on this path, I predict years in the wilderness followed by years of regret as the Weekly realizes it was on the wrong side.
DIVISION OF LABOR
I applaud Marc Coopers article regarding the County Federation of Labors endorsement of Jim Hahn [Dissonance, "Labors Dirty Move," December 31January 6]. As the executive director of the Engineers and Architects Association (EAA), IUPA Local 8000, AFL-CIO, which includes almost 9,000 members employed by the city of Los Angeles, I know firsthand that Jim Hahn has not been a friend to labor nor to the citizens of this city. EAA broke with the County Fed because of this endorsement, and we are working diligently and applying the resources we have available to help Antonio Villaraigosa become the next mayor of Los Angeles.
It appears to me that Cooper accurately deduced the reasoning for the County Feds action, and I must say that I am somewhat embarrassed that we would support Hahn at a time when he is spending taxpayer money like a drunken sailor on leave.
EAA applauds Marc Cooper for shining light into this dark crevasse.
Robert G. Aquino
JEWS AND GENTILES
In reference to Ernest Hardys film review of The Merchant of Venice [Calendar, December 31January 6], I strongly disagree with the comment on Al Pacinos "atrocious performance . . . whose laughably bad accent and scene-chewing delivery" causes the production to "collapse." This is outrageous, wrong and clearly misinformed (there are stronger words I could use). Al Pacinos reserved and laid-back Brooklynese could not be a better fit and contrast to the proper, high British accent used by the rest of the cast. The Jew as outcast and underdog may have a different accent and language that separates him from the gentile. The fact that Pacinos character, Shylock, is flawed and cannot make the "right decision" is Shakespeare at his best, and Pacino pulled it off, a consummate performance with the skill and mastery we have come to expect from him.
I find the film a masterpiece. It is most welcome in a time when mindless drivel is the usual fare at our local theaters. We need reviewers who are sympathetic and familiar with the classics. In each generation, we must interpret what came before in the context of our own world.
Jerome P. Helman, M.D.