X-Raying Workers’ Comp | News | Los Angeles | Los Angeles News and Events | LA Weekly
Loading...

X-Raying Workers’ Comp 

Employers gain, insurers really gain, as for workers...

Thursday, Apr 22 2004
Comments

The Arnold Schwarzenegger show moved to Long Beach this week, where he shouted “hasta la vista, baby” to fraud in the workers’-comp system at a Boeing plant in Long Beach. But if you’re a Boeing worker, you might want to hold the applause. Likewise, if you’re a worker without health insurance, or if you’re an older worker, or one with a sore back — you’d best think twice before jumping with joy, especially if you risk hurting yourself in the process.

For employees, reforms signed into law this week trade a few legitimate gains for a number of lost or reduced benefits. Employers, for their part, will have more control over doctors and treatments and the hope of lower insurance rates. Even better still is the outcome for insurance companies. They’ve emerged with a more profitable business climate and no obligation to share these gains. It was precisely what they wanted from Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, whose campaigns they have heavily subsidized.

All these changes were wrought to tame an out-of-control $25 billion system, whose purpose is to help injured workers while also helping companies avoid litigation.

Related Stories

  • SoCal Meets Old World: Stone Brewing Co. and Green Flash Announce Plans to Brew in Europe

    This summer has been full of interesting expansion news from several California breweries, including Lagunitas in Petaluma — which recently opened a Chicago tasting room — and Sierra Nevada, which has an expansive North Carolina brewery that is already releasing product. But none of the announcements made in the last...
  • Hollywood's Tax Win 3

    Jerry Brown, California's skin-flint governor, acceded Wednesday to an increase in the film tax credit to $330 million. Brown is a well-known skeptic of Hollywood subsidies, but the combined forces of organized labor, multinational entertainment conglomerates, and B-list celebrities proved too powerful to resist. The industry didn't get the $400...
  • Splitting California Into 6 States? FAIL 10

    A proposed initiative by Silicon Valley venture capitalist Tim Draper to split California into six separate states failed to gather enough signatures to make the ballot, the California Secretary of State's office said today. The office said in a memo to local voter registrars and county clerks that "the petition...
  • Hey Baby 3

    Having a baby is hard enough these days. The costs of diapers and daycare can add up, not to mention a mother's astronomical physical pain and two solid years of never sleeping 8 hours. In California those given hardships are compounded by living in a state with one of the...
  • $100 Short 8

    L.A. is the most unaffordable rental market in the United States. And if you're lucky enough to be in the market to buy your own place, you're also facing some of the highest prices in the nation. Now comes word that the cash in your pocket has become less valuable...

“Throughout the reform, the most important thing for us was putting workers first,” Governor Schwarzenegger told his audience on Monday. “This reform will create workers’ compensation the way it used to be meant to be: to heal injured workers and get them back on the job.”

Democrats who signed on to this compromise, including state senator and liberal stalwart John Burton, hope it works out that way. But Senator Richard Alarcon (D–Los Angeles) voted no. “Clearly, there were tremendous reductions in benefits to workers,” said Alarcon, who chairs the Senate’s labor and industrial-relations committee, which has jurisdiction over workers’-comp bills. “The logic is that people were abusing the system. But these cuts will affect truly injured workers as well as those who abused the system. And because these reforms provide most of the control to employers, it is most likely that abuses would fall on the shoulders of working people. This didn’t turn out the way I wanted.”

 

So let’s start with that back of yours. It’s been bothering you off and on for years, but you toughed it out, didn’t miss a day on the job, didn’t ask for any lightening of the load. Until last week, when the agony forced you into bed. And now you can’t do your job, or work the hours you need to pay the rent.

You file a workers’-comp claim.

First off, you better hope that your pain shows up in an X-ray, or it will be a darn sight harder to get treatment than it used to be. If you fail this test, however, focus on the upside: Your sacrifice means that it also will be harder for the cheats to claim benefits.

The new system will squeeze out “fraud, inefficiency, incorrectness and litigation,” said Schwarzenegger spokesman Vince Sollitto. “In the past, because of the lack of objective standards for diagnoses or treatment, workers with the same kind of injury could get different awards. There was a large incentive for injured workers to litigate. We had the highest lawsuit rate in the nation and the worst return-to-work ratio.”

A running theme of the reforms is an insistence on “objective” medical findings to discourage fraud, even though the process will inevitably also work against some honest workers who are in pain.

Now, Mr. Sore Back, let’s say you used to play semipro baseball, or maybe you danced in the regional ballet. That’s pretty hard on the spine. So was lugging your three kids into the house when they fell asleep in the back seat on the way home — even if that was 10 years ago. And your previous job involved a lot of lifting, or maybe it was overly sedentary and involved too little lifting. And just maybe, at your age, the old back ain’t what it used to be anyway. Is it true that your grandfather had a degenerative disk? All that information gets considered. You may be 100 percent hurting, and 100 percent unable to work, but you’d get only 10 percent of the benefit if your current work in your current job has only borne witness to 10 percent of the damage.

And what if you’ve worked for companies that didn’t provide health insurance? Because of that, perhaps you didn’t get your stiffness treated while it was minor and an easier fix. Good luck with your claim, now that you’re nearly bent in two. Your pain is the system’s gain. After all, you can’t expect workers’ comp to serve the general health needs of the state’s 7 million uninsured. That’s partly what had happened before — workers were using workers’ comp as a fallback because they lacked regular health insurance.

Related Content

Now Trending

  • How Not to Get Ebola

    The first natural case of Ebola in the United States was confirmed by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Texas Department of State Health Services officials today. The patient arrived from Liberia Sept. 20, sought treatment in the Dallas area Sept. 26 after feeling ill for a couple days,...
  • Mayor of Bell Gardens Shot

    The mayor of Bell Gardens, a small city in southeastern L.A. county, was shot and wounded today, a sheriff's official told L.A. Weekly. The municipal website of Bell identifies the mayor as Daniel Crespo. The attack was reported this afternoon in the 6300 block of Gage Avenue in that town,...
    2
  • "Yes Means Yes" Sex App Is Here

    The ink was barely dry on California's groundbreaking "yes means yes" sexual consent law when we heard about Good2Go, an app that lets adults put their lovemaking affirmation on the record. The bill by state Sen. Kevin De León requires state colleges to establish a standard of "affirmative consent" for students...
Los Angeles Concert Tickets