Roger’s Nest | News | Los Angeles | Los Angeles News and Events | LA Weekly

Roger’s Nest 

So what keeps this cardinal from flying away?

Thursday, Mar 11 2004

Page 2 of 3

Bishop Manuel Moreno of the Diocese of Tucson was presiding over a financial crisis made worse by the clergy scandal when Pope John Paul II appointed Bishop Gerald Kicanas to assist him in October 2001, reducing Moreno, whose health was failing, to a figurehead. It was not until Moreno’s health worsened, along with persistent upheaval, that the Vatican accepted his resignation last year in March. In November, Cincinnati Archbishop Daniel Pilarczyk pleaded no contest on behalf of his archdiocese to failing to report clergy who sexually abused minors, saving himself the trouble of having to resign.

The review board’s urgings are not what is likely to change the Catholic Church, experts say. At the institutional level, Rome stands in the way. “The Vatican is at fault for not demanding the resignation of the bishops who were involved in cover-ups,” says the Rev. Richard McBrien, a theology professor at Notre Dame University. “No bishop, apart from [Cardinal] Law, has resigned because of involvement in the cover-up of sexual abuse by priests. I do not believe that any of the bishops in question will resign.”


Related Stories

  • The Fantastic Encuentro 2014 Festival Showed the Power of Latino Theater

    Encuentro 2014, an inspiring, monthlong festival of 18 Latino performances and readings, just closed at Los Angeles Theatre Center downtown and a couple of off-site locations. It could accurately be described as a reactionary event. "Reactionary," however, does not refer to a yearning backward. Rather, in the purest sense of...
  • Condom War Continues

    Even though efforts to legislate mandatory condom use in California porn have failed repeatedly in recent years, that hasn't stopped the state Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) from making rules of its own. See also: Porn's Condom Law Goes Down The problem, as the L.A.-based AIDS Healthcare Foundation sees it,...
  • Turkey Traffic Warning

    L.A. has the worst traffic in America anytime of the year, rain or shine. So it should come as no surprise that the folks at traffic app firm Inrix have concluded that "Los Angeles tops the list of the country’s most congested cities this Thanksgiving season," according to a statement...
  • This New EDM Book Looks Awesome, But Will Anyone Actually Read It?

    Today, HarperCollins Publishers and their Dey Street Books imprint announced the impending arrival of a new book on American EDM culture. Written by highly regarded journalist Michaelangelo Matos, it's called The Underground Is Massive: How Electronic Dance Music Conquered America and is due out in March of next year. We're...
  • The Value of Amnesty 7

    UCLA researchers said this week that President Obama's widely expected initiative to expand amnesty for those in the United States illegally is good for the pocketbooks of Americans. The UCLA North American Integration and Development Center (NAID) says in a summary of its new report, "From the Shadows to the...

So where does that leave Mahony? A.W. Richard Sipe, a former Benedictine monk who’s now a psychotherapist, author and expert on clergy sexual abuse, says Mahony is in a double bind: He can give up the documents he is protecting, which could implicate him beyond what he already has admitted; or he can try to prevail in court and be criticized for obstructing justice. “There is no noble way out for him except to give up the documents and resign,” Sipe says. “But he thinks he can get away with it. Which shows Rome that the American Catholic Church cannot be compromised. Then he becomes Rome’s good boy.”

That leaves the people in the parish to pursue regime change — and, after all, it is their church. But as the most powerful prelate in the United States, Mahony must crush the notion that lay Catholics have any say over how to heal an infected archdiocese, according to the Rev. Thomas Doyle, a chaplain in the U.S. Air Force and a canon-law expert. “It’s a monarchy,” Doyle says. “Bishops are slowly being exposed in their duplicity, but Mahony will ride it out until there’s an indictment or some document disclosure or some report from the grand jury.”

Fred Allison, a spokesman for the Tucson diocese, says that some bishops may be struggling with whether to resign under fire or wait until they have righted their diocese before quietly stepping down. “Maybe after the problems are fixed is the time to go,” he says. Tucson plaintiffs’ lawyer Lynne Cadigan finds this idea laughable. Of Mahony she says, “You don’t get to be cardinal and step down just because of a flood of civil lawsuits and allegations of a criminal conspiracy. Rome could care less. It annoys them that a district attorney could dictate terms to them.”

Aside from resignations, a remedy bishops supposedly are addressing is “fraternal correction.” Experts find this lacking for an institution that has steadfastly refused to police itself. “Bishops are loath to tell another bishop what to do, lest someone attempt to do the same to him,” McBrien says. “Fraternal correction simply does not work.”

“It’s a great idea, sort of like peer review in the medical profession,” Wall says. “But the bishops have been raised in a Roman culture that is military in nature. They take a long view of history. Loyalty and faithfulness are rewarded. These men have been raised in the Latin tradition since they were 14. This is all they have.” Self-preservation compels them to sacrifice errant priests so the public sees them doing something. “The bishops don’t do battle like the Navy SEALs,” says Wall. “They aren’t looking to bring everyone home.”

Review-board members will not say why Cardinal Law, Cardinal Edward Egan of New York and Bishop O’Brien of Phoenix were singled out for concealing priests while criticism of Mahony was limited to hardball legal tactics. Perhaps the board is applying a double standard. “There are a lot of double standards among the bishops,” Panetta replies, noting that Mahony preaches openness but practices legal defense first. Then there is his PR strategy. “We encouraged bishops to get out in front of the scandal,” review-board spokesman William Burleigh says. “Others have done it too.”

Yet Los Angeles is the crown jewel of California’s dioceses. And Mahony is the head of the Metropolitan See of Los Angeles, which includes five “suffragan” dioceses from San Diego to Monterey. Mahony would be the last to resign, experts say. Even approving of others doing so based on pressure from lay overseers would for him be like bowing to the hoi polloi.

Related Content

Now Trending

Los Angeles Concert Tickets