No Secrets 

Two courts reject ashcroft's anti- terror strategy

Wednesday, Aug 28 2002

THE TOP-SECRET Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court is not exactly the ACLU. Meeting in a guarded, locked room on the highest floor of the Justice Department, this is a court that in 25 years has never met a wiretap it didn't like. Its judges routinely consider the most sensitive national-security questions and have signed off on more than 10,000 warrants.

So when this secret court publicly kicks John Ashcroft in the teeth, it's clear something is going on. It's even more clear something is going on when, just a few days later, another unanimous panel of federal judges -- this an appeals court in Cincinnati -- slams the Ashcroft Justice Department's secret deportation hearings: "Democracies die behind closed doors," writes Judge Damon Keith for the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

What's going on -- with the anniversary of September 11 just days away -- is that Ashcroft's entire post-attack legal strategy, a strategy built on broad domestic surveillance and broader secrecy, is collapsing of its own extremity. It is no exaggeration to say that the nation's federal judges -- many of them appointed by Reagan and Bush I -- are now in open rebellion at the measures embraced by the current Bush administration, measures that these judges perceive as a naked power grab by the executive branch.

Related Stories

  • Photography IS a Crime 2

    In the post-9/11 world, you can be questioned by federal agents simply for taking photos of what they believe are security-sensitive buildings. Not only that, but that questioning is often preceded by a "suspicious activity report" (SAR) that stays in your federal file. The ACLU of California is suing the...
  • Taking Down Armenian Power, California's Modern Mafia 46

    The whole thing started with a scene straight out of a mobster movie. It was around 6 p.m. when more than a dozen men from two organized crime groups opened fire on each other in a North Hollywood parking lot. Witnesses say nearly everyone was armed, and the shootout quickly...
  • 6 L.A. Sheriff's Officials Guilty in Ballsy Obstruction Case

    We hope this is the worst of it — that the L.A. County Sheriff's Department has turned over a new leaf following its inmate-abuse scandal. See also: Plagued By Scandal, Sheriff Lee Baca Resigns to Avoid Bruising Re-Election Battle The U.S. Attorney's Office in L.A. today announced that six sheriff's officials...
  • Did Alleged 'Craigslist Killer' Murder in L.A?

    The case of a 19-year-old woman who reportedly confessed to killing at least 22 people might be coming to Los Angeles. The FBI and the police chief in Sunbury, Pennsylvania, where Miranda Barbour was being charged with murder, couldn't confirm reports that Los Angeles authorities were contacted to investigate whether she...
  • Alleged 'Westside Gun & Bag Bandit' Charged in Bank Robbery Spree

    When the FBI gives you a nickname for robbing banks, it's usually only a matter of time before agents catch up with you. The bureau today said that is the case for 44-year-old Alim Shamil Urmancheev of Studio City, who was charged by the L.A. County District Attorney's office in connection...

Last week's extraordinary ruling by the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court is instructive. The court was set up in 1978, in the aftermath of Watergate and the revelations of FBI abuses, to make sure that the kind of raw information needed for foreign intelligence would not be abused in criminal investigations or politics. In fact, the court has not once rejected a national-security wiretap application and has, case by case, allowed foreign-surveillance information to be shared with prosecutors.

But when the Bush administration asserted that the USA PATRIOT Act allows a wholesale blurring of the line, with criminal investigators directing "national security" investigations, the judges went ballistic -- revealing 75 recent cases in which FBI agents "misled" the court, "a troubling number of inaccurate FBI affidavits" and repeated "violation of the Court's orders." The judges' point: Ashcroft and the FBI are not to be trusted with new power when they have abused the power they already had. The policies proposed by Bush "are not reasonably designed" to protect the privacy of law-abiding citizens, the court found.

Ashcroft spokeswoman Barbara Comstock made much of the fact that these documented abuses happened on Bill Clinton's watch, but that is precisely the judges' point: The abuse of power transcends particular administrations. So often have the FBI and Justice Department lied in order to stretch the limits of legal surveillance that the court now refuses to accept applications from the FBI agent in charge of Hamas.

AND BLUNT AS THAT REBUKE BY THE surveillance court was, it was a love letter compared to the reception the administration's secret deportation hearings received from that Cincinnati appeals court. Last year the INS began deportation hearings against Rabih Haddad, head of a Muslim charity whose assets were frozen after September 11. Attorney General Ashcroft had asserted the unilateral right to close Haddad's deportation hearings to press and public -- an assertion challenged by Detroit newspapers and Representative John Conyers (D-Michigan).

This week's ruling by the 6th Circuit panel could not have been more unambiguous, with the judges' own sense of urgency and outrage clear from the speed with which the ruling was issued -- just three weeks after argument. "The executive branch seeks to uproot people's lives, outside the public eye and behind a closed door," wrote Judge Keith. But "when government begins closing doors, it selectively controls information that rightly belongs to the people. Selective information is misinformation."

In the face of resistance from courts nationwide, Ashcroft's homeland-security strategies are unraveling so fast that you need a scorecard to keep up. An even broader case on secret immigration proceedings is on the federal appellate docket next month in Philadelphia, where a district judge ordered all such proceedings nationwide opened to the public in the absence of a good reason for secrecy. It's hard to avoid the conclusion that far from being a "wartime consigliere," Ashcroft has turned out to be a colossal failure, even on the administration's own terms, leading the White House down a succession of blind alleys. Congress, which until now rolled over for the administration's most draconian proposals, is beginning to ask questions. Congressman James Sensenbrenner (R-Wisconsin), the conservative law-and-order chair of the House Judiciary Committee, says he is ready to "start blowing a fuse" over the administration's addiction to secrecy and obsession with restoring the imperial executive. The anniversary of September 11 may be approaching, but the post-attack political honeymoon may at last be over.

Related Content

Now Trending

  • Foster the People's Downtown L.A. Mural Is Coming Down

    The controversial Foster the People mural downtown is coming down, the office of L.A. Mayor Eric Garcetti announced today. Despite claims by the pop band that it had necessary permits and that the artwork was legitimately produced, the mayor's office states what we reported previously: The piece is on a...
  • Sexual Predator Is Targeting Females in Eastside Park

    A sexual predator is on the loose in an Eastside park, police warned today. Cops say the creep has targeted "lone females" walking in Ernest E. Debs Regional Park three times between January and July. He has groped, exposed himself and even attacked with a knife, the Los Angeles Police...
  • U.S. Reps Call For Federal Intervention in Dodger TV Blackout

    A group of local U.S. representatives wants the Federal Communications Commission to help end Time Warner Cable's blackout of Dodger games for competing cable and satellite providers. Negotiations to bring the team's games to AT&T U-verse, Charter Communications, Cox Communications, DirecTV, Dish Network, Mediacom, Suddenlink Communications and Verizon FIOS have gotten...
Los Angeles Concert Tickets


  • Street League Skateboarding Super Crown World Championship
    On Sunday, Street League Skateboarding touched down in the Galen Center at USC as part of a four-stop tour for SLS's Super Crown World Championship. The L.A. stop determined the roster for Super Crown, airing August 24th on FOX Sports 1. The final eight are Nyjah Huston, Luan Oliveira, Torey Pudwill, Shane O'Neill, Paul Rodriguez, Chaz Ortiz, Matt Berger and Ishod Wair. All photos by Nanette Gonzales.
  • Comic-Con's "Celebrity" Autograph Area
    A sometimes overlooked (but still incredibly unique) aspect of San Diego Comic-Con are the celebs available to sign autographs, as well as the autograph seekers themselves. If you've ever wanted to meet the Soup Nazi from Seinfeld or the guy who played Michelangelo in the original Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, chances are, as you wander the Autograph Area, you'll be able to connect with someone you didn't even realize you were waiting your whole life to meet! All photos by Rob Inderrieden.
  • Real Madrid Soccer Practice at UCLA
    Fans came out to greet world champion soccer team Real Madrid as they practice at UCLA. This is the first time that soccer star Cristiano Ronaldo has practiced with the team this year. All photos by Jeff Cowan.