By Joseph Tsidulko
By Patrick Range McDonald
By David Futch
By Hillel Aron
By Dennis Romero
By Jill Stewart
By Dennis Romero
By Dennis Romero
FISK’S MIDDLE EASTERN POLITICS; COOPER’S MIDWESTERN PROBLEM
Re: “Beyond Disappointment” (Dissonance, April 19–25). I would like to thank Marc Cooper and the Weekly for interviewing Robert Fisk, who has been an honest voice in the Palestinian situation. I have had the opportunity to talk with Mr. Fisk at lunch when he was speaking at Northwestern University, where I am a student, and he truly offers an insightful perspective that is hard to find in the American media. Keep up the good work.
Robert Fisk claims hundreds of civilian deaths in Jenin. Does he have any proof of this? Does he repeat “reliable” Arab sources? Why did Marc Cooper not ask him this question? Accusations without proof, rather than helping to create an atmosphere for negotiations, simply incite more hatred and violence. The “best and most knowledgeable correspondent” of the Middle East should know this, and the L.A. Weekly’s interviewer should have reminded him of this fact.
—Dr. David Shichor Fullerton
Robert Fisk recognizes that both Yasir Arafat and Ariel Sharon are bad leaders, but points out what U.S. officials are loath to point out, that Sharon is a butcher who does not want anything to do with the Oslo accords or a Palestinian state. Unless the U.S., along with the European and Arab nations, gets involved and pressures Israel to end its brutal and illegal occupation, Fisk’s disturbing prophecy of an Israeli-Palestinian war like the French-Algerian war may come true.
I applaud the L.A. Weekly for publishing this eye-opening interview.
—Farah Haq West Chester, Pennsylvania
Robert Fisk makes a seriously flawed analogy between the French-Algerian war and the current Israeli-Palestinian war. To begin with, French Algerians had a country to go home to, hence the name FrenchAlgerians. Algeria was not a French homeland, thus the French Algerians packed their bags rather than fight to the end. Israelis are Israelis and speak Hebrew. To what country does Fisk propose Israelis go? Poland? Germany? The U.S.?
It is this knee-jerk tendency by the Third World banana-republic press to equate Zionism with racism that has the entire world, with the exception of the U.S., rooting for the Palestinians. This mentality also pervades France, a banana republic that lacks even bananas. France does, however, have a rapidly growing Muslim population that its government needs to placate for domestic political purposes.
As a Jew who has long supported the state of Israel, I am in agreement with Robert Fisk’s criticism of Ariel Sharon’s brutal policies of occupation and military retaliation. As an American, however, I take angry exception to Fisk’s statement that “Europe” — as if that continent has ever been a single unified entity — “[hasn’t] had a chance yet to make a mess of the Middle East in the way you Americans have.”
Mr. Fisk, our friends across the pond have managed to make a mess of the Middle East in ways that are uniquely European. That began with the Crusades, and a series of bloody wars fought along the Nile and in the sands of North Africa, as Italy, France, Germany, Turkey and England fought among themselves to plunder the region’s strategic waterways and natural resources, including oil. The United States may have soiled its hands in a similar fashion, but we came late to the party, and at Europe’s invitation.
—Keith Cornell Santa Monica
“. . . generating an often rock star–like reception (a crowd of 900 saw him last week in Cedar Falls, Iowa!).” Shouldn’t the presence of 900 concerned individuals be enough to end the prejudice against the Midwest reflected in the preceding statement? Who does Marc Cooper think we, his fellow countrymen/women, are? If the West Coast is the harbinger of forward thought, how do you explain away Dianne Feinstein and Pete Wilson?
I once told a friend from L.A. that I was from Ohio. He responded with “Oh, you guys grow a lot of potatoes out there, huh?” With attitudes such as the ones expressed by Cooper, I am no longer surprised at how my friend came to that conclusion.
—Christopher Snively St. Louis (that’s in Missouri)
Please tell writer Marc Cooper that this Marc Cooper really enjoys the nasty comments his readers send me about his stories.
—Marc Cooper Springfield, Missouri
THE BOTTOM LINE
Re: Harold Meyerson’s “Boundaries Going Up” [Powerlines, April 19–25]. Let’s look back a little, when Israel had more than fence separating it from Egypt. I mean the Barlev Defensive Line, which didn’t keep the Egyptians from storming it to get back what is theirs. What the two countries have between them now is a piece of paper, which is holding better than any fence and is expected to last for a very long time. â Why? Because none of the parties involved is holding property of the other in his own hands. It’s as simple as that. When each party gets back his own property and rights, this is called justice.
—Aboul-E, Khaled, M.D. Alexandria, Egypt
ROCKIN’ POLS, EH?