By Joseph Tsidulko
By Patrick Range McDonald
By David Futch
By Hillel Aron
By Dennis Romero
By Jill Stewart
By Dennis Romero
By Dennis Romero
9/11 . . .
Congratulations on your “9/11” issue [September 14–20]. There is hope for American journalism after all. I had almost totally despaired in the face of the shills masquerading in the media as reporters and writers — forget thinkers. The prognosis is bleak, but what the hell, have fun fighting the good fight.
In the most terrifying week of my 23 years, I finally found some comfort in your coverage of the disaster in New York and Washington. There is a voice of reason outside my television set, beyond my city newspapers. Marc Cooper, John Powers and Harold Meyerson were the voices I desperately needed to hear — not the buffoons and bullies on TV making threats, as George W. put it, against “those folks.”
The hatred for the United States that exists worldwide did not happen overnight. It was carefully cultivated, for years, by our government, our foreign policy and our brand of corporate democracy. The United States has had a direct hand in creating the situations that led to the hate, resentment and evil that killed so many people this week. If we can’t admit this and stop it, then the terrorist acts that occurred on Tuesday are just the beginning.
Please continue to print an alternative view of these events and what is now unfolding. Those of us who don’t believe everything television news and corporate newspapers tell us desperately need to hear something different.
By and large, your writers missed the obvious. President Bush’s “We’re a target because we’re a beacon of freedom” provides greater insight into the attackers’ real motives than the feeble theories of provocation offered up by Powers, Cooper, Rappleye, et al. Promotion of democracy, a culture of individual expression, dedication to freedom of exchange. It isn’t America’s actions so much as America’s nature — just as it isn’t Israel’s actions, but Israel’s existence — that embitters hijackers and their handlers. Only the alteration of America, and the end of Israel, will appease them.
After seeing the picture of President Bush with the caption “In over his head,” I have decided to stop reading your paper. What a great response to the nation’s tragedy. What is wrong with you people?
John Powers’ “Apocalypse, Tuesday” was outstanding. His presentation of the issues at hand was handled with tact and wisdom. We are tired of sugarcoated regurgitation. We want answers, not posturing. Again, I thank you for printing this article.
While complaining of the media culture’s need to make everything “feel safely formatted,” John Powers managed to do the same. Instead of actual reflection, he fell into a knee-jerk partisan whining that was entirely out of place under the circumstances. The complaints about President Bush and Newt Gingrich were so pathetically predictable that the article looked as though it had been written from a template Powers had stored in his computer to respond to any international incident. The assertion that the terrorist attacks had something to do with Bush’s alleged arrogance toward other countries indicates Powers’ extreme ignorance of global politics. It is also sadly indicative of the kind of political myopia that will hopefully dissipate in light of this horror. This attack was planned long before the current administration came into power.
Wake up, John. This is much bigger than reflexive partisan bickering, which almost everyone in America but you seemed to have grasped immediately.
Re: John Powers’ claims that the president’s flights around the country were cowardly. I sincerely hope he made those misguided statements before he learned about the very real and credible threats to both Air Force Oneand the White House on that chaotic day. Earlier in the week, William Safire, in The New York Times, made the same misinformed presumption that Powers did; once the truth came out, however, he ate his words in the same public forum he had used to question Bush’s actions and judgments. Will Powers have the guts to do the same?
John Powers’ “Apocalypse, Tuesday” was the best expression of my own feelings yet. Congratulations to Mr. Powers for his insight and honesty. I only hope that we can find a place in our hearts to understand that we are all human â and all in pain, including George Bush and Osama bin Laden. One must try not to judge how another expresses despair.
I pray for the enlightenment of all beings.
Re: “Start of History.” As a kind of left-wing Jerry Falwell, Marc Cooper clings to the old-time religion, preaching fire and brimstone over our foreign policy and our presumed culpability in the terrorist carnage. America must be held accountable as an agent in the 9/11 bloodletting, Cooper declares. America must take responsibility for the crashed jetliners, the mangled office towers and the thousands who perished Tuesday morning.
Beware the wages of spin, Cooper chides us, spouting inanities as if they were epiphanies.