Then This Priest Says. . .

HOWARD ROSENBERG'S RECENT L.A. TIMESCOLUMN DETAILING A DUSTUP WITH THE Fox network over a Catholic joke on The Simpsonsgot us thinking: Can many TV writers still be wringing yuks out of the One, True, Holy and Apostolic Church?

A trip to the Catholic League for Civil and Religious Rights' Web site was in order. The Catholic League, by the way, is not related to the Catholic Legion of Decency, the organization with an admirable Lex Luthor­vs.­Superman snap to its name, which helped enforce the Hays Motion Picture Code against sexual or "indecent" content from the 1930s through the 1960s.

The present-day Catholic League objects to plenty of movies and TV shows, not for "indecency," but for what it sees as anti-Catholic bias. It's an American tradition, says Father Gregory Coiro of the L.A. Archdiocese, with a long and wacky pedigree -- from the Ku Klux Klan (anti-Catholic, along with its other sterling credentials) to Norman Vincent Peale's panic about an impending Kennedy presidency's threat to democracy. (Peale was worried about the philandering, calculating Kennedy's tight links to the Vatican -- talk about positive thinking.)

The League Web site chronicles several years' worth of insults:

Performance art involving Jesus and condoms -- enough said there.

Hassles with the American Civil Liberties Union over Nativity scenes.

Nutty evangelical pamphlets claiming that Catholics worship the Virgin Mary as a goddess.

A catalog that offers a toy called "Nunzilla -- a wind-up doll armed with her missal and ruler" who "makes her way to your desk. Terrifying!" (OffBeat suspects that Nunzilla draws a titter from every Catholic, devout or fallen, who has been at the business end of a yardstick.)

Some of the quips are really offensive, but the real sin is that so many are as musty as the catacombs that hid the early Christians -- and probably first circulated there. (Sample: "The pope was a soccer goalie as a youth -- even as a young man he was trying to keep people from scoring.")

We think the church's recent dealings with Fox mogul Rupert Murdoch are a lot funnier than most of the gags on the League site. Murdoch, who also owns the Los Angeles Dodgers, was awarded a papal knighthood in the Pontifical Order of Saint Gregory the Great last year by Pope John Paul II. It's an honor awarded even to non-Catholics like Murdoch -- and Roy Disney and Bob Hope -- for their good works. And it makes Murdoch's wife, Anna, who is Catholic, a dame -- or, rather, his soon-to-be ex-wife, because the Murdochs split last year. Murdoch has since been linked with a woman less than half his age. It's not exactly a page from The Lives of the Saints. But luckily for Murdoch, there are no takebacks on papal knighthoods -- no matter what Bart says next.

--Bobbi Murray

 

F TROOP

---

 

TO ABBY ARNOLD, A MEMBER OF THE UNITARIAN UNIVERSALIST COMMUNITY CHURCH OF Santa Monica, having her 8-year-old son, Kevin, join the Boy Scouts when he comes of age next year would be nothing short of blasphemy.

"It wouldn't be right to put my son in a situation where he could be a victim of discrimination," said Arnold. "Even though it might not affect him on a day-to-day basis, the underlying issue is that he would be considered second-class."

Arnold, like hundreds of other Unitarian parents in California and thousands nationwide, are at odds with the Boy Scouts of America's decision to deny their children the traditional Religion in Life emblem because of their tolerance of homosexuality and religions that don't profess a belief in God. Unitarians, who have 220,000 members in North America and 27 congregations that sponsor Scout troops, accept both atheists and agnostics into the faith as well as bisexuals, gays, lesbians and transgender people.

And they don't take kindly to intolerance, as the Boy Scouts found out when they reviewed the Unitarians' Scout manual, which explained how to get the badge certifying proficiency in the tenets of Unitarianism. The manual contained an in-your-face reference to the Scouts' homophobia and intolerance of those with a broader view of God.

"The Boy Scouts teach them how to get along with other boys and expose them to experiences that they wouldn't otherwise get," said John Hurley, director of information for the Unitarian Universalist Association. "If we thought that this was a completely evil organization, we would not have spent the time and effort over the last few years to try and resolve this dispute."

Ron Schoenmehl, spokesperson for the San Gabriel Valley Scout Council, said religions without some form of a god or higher power are contrary to the Scouts' program. Barring gay scoutmasters is a moral-leadership issue, and one that has been upheld by the California Supreme Court, he added.

The court, in 1998, decided the case of Michael and William Randall, atheists denied Eagle Scout awards when they refused to affirm God's existence, by declaring that the Boy Scouts of America was a private membership organization, not a business, and therefore could set its own admission standards.

"As a private organization, whether we have the right or not is our decision," said Schoenmehl.