By Michael Goldstein
By Dennis Romero
By Sarah Fenske
By Matthew Mullins
By Patrick Range McDonald
By LA Weekly
By Dennis Romero
By Simone Wilson
Courtesy Physicians forsocial responsibility
The controversy over potential toxic contamination of workers and the community surrounding Rocketdyne’s Santa Susana Field Laboratory in Simi Valley is now threatening to engulf a state agency charged with monitoring inquiries into the aerospace giant.
Assembly Members Sheila Kuehl (D– Santa Monica) and Scott Wildman (D-Glendale) have each called for investigations into the conduct of the state Department of Health Services, and on Monday, Governor Gray Davis weighed in. "I will do all I can to restore public faith in the state’s efforts to assist the community in addressing these concerns," Davis said.
The high-level attention was sparked by recent revelations that DHS staff suppressed findings of elevated levels of lung cancer in Simi and San Fernando Valley communities surrounding the Rocketdyne facility. The charge was compounded by separate instances of state staff working with company officials to soften the impact of critical reviews. In addition, critics say the DHS conspired to gut a public oversight panel supervising a Rocketdyne worker-health study. The oversight panel was formed in 1989 after the DHS was accused of suppressing yet another cancer study damaging to Rocketdyne; a decade later, lawmakers are responding to similar charges.
On April 13, Assemblywoman Kuehl ignited the latest fury. "The purpose of the independent panel was to restore the public trust that DHS had completely destroyed by suppressing the cancer study and appearing to collude with Rocketdyne," an angry Kuehl wrote to Grantland Johnson, head of the state Health and Human Services Agency, which oversees DHS.
"To my utter disbelief, it was disclosed to me today that DHS has suppressed another cancer study," Kuehl wrote. "DHS’s conduct is unconscionable, and it demands immediate action."
Johnson responded two weeks later. "We have taken the issues raised in your letter regarding the suppression of reports and information by DHS staff very seriously," he wrote to Kuehl. "We have contacted Winston Hickox, secretary of the California Environmental Protection Agency, and requested his assistance." Johnson and Hickox agreed to assign Edward Lowery, director of the state Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC), to head up the review. A report is expected within 90 days.
On May 3, Governor Davis stepped up, directing Hickox’s initiative and transferring $150,000 in funds to CalEPA. "By transferring these funds I am effectively removing oversight of this effort from the DHS and giving it to CalEPA," Davis wrote in a letter to Kuehl. "I share your concerns regarding the potential health impact on nearby communities resulting from site contamination at the facility," Davis wrote.
Kuehl said last week she was delighted by Davis’ response: "After years of neglect and stonewalling by the former Governor’s Office, I very much appreciate that we finally have a governor who is committed to restoring public trust in the agencies that have responsibility for protecting our health and safety."
The alleged collusion between Rocketdyne and DHS could lead to other charges against the agency as well. Assemblyman Scott Wildman, chairman of the state’s Joint Legislative Audit Committee, last week announced a broad inquiry to examine the agency. "[A] number of issues . . . have come together," he said, "[in] some of the things [the Weekly] has done about Rocketdyne. But also this perceived pattern of, basically, suppressing things from the Legislature that have been occurring . . . in the DHS for a number of years."
Specifically, Wildman said the DHS had blocked outreach programs for L.A. Medi-Cal recipients, had failed to identify and track children with lead poisoning, and had suppressed one of two studies of the state’s smoking ban.
"Over the past year, the investigations that the committee has initiated have found some serious difficulties within DHS in terms of a pattern of withholding information from the Legislature. We suspect that this is a real problem," Wildman said in an interview. "What we are looking at now is a history that goes back five or six years, of a department that has kind of done its own thing and, in essence, hasn’t really respected the intent of the Legislature."
The state agency’s most notorious entanglement, however, may stem from its effort to assess the health problems associated with Rocketdyne’s massive Santa Susana Field Laboratory (SSFL), in the hills between the Simi and San Fernando valleys. Workers there toiled on the frontlines of the Cold War, testing experimental nuclear reactors and developing rocket engines for the space race, along with MX missiles designed to carry nukes. A litany of SSFL accidents, including a partial meltdown of a reactor core in 1959 and widespread radioactive and chemical contamination, prompted an investigation of the health of Rocketdyne workers and of mortality rates in the residential communities nearby.
The DHS’s apparent pattern of data quashing and collusion with Rocketdyne stretches back to 1990, when it suppressed its own findings of elevated bladder-cancer rates in west San Fernando Valley tracts near SSFL. In 1996, over the objections of the oversight panel, the DHS leaked the preliminary draft of a UCLA radiation study to Rocketdyne, allowing the corporation to press for changes in it. And last year, the agency advanced a preliminary draft of a UCLA study of chemical exposure to the company, again over the panel’s protests. State officials intensified their scrutiny after last month’s disclosure, that DHS had failed to make public a report showing a 17.2 percent spike in lung cancers in the 19 Simi Valley census tracts nearest the lab.
Find everything you're looking for in your city
Find the best happy hour deals in your city
Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%
Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city